Problem with Main Dealer, Advice Required Please
Discussion
Thought the good people of PH could help here:
This isn't my car but putting the story up here to see if anyone can help.
Bought a used (2006) Audi A3 from an Audi Main Dealer down south in mid December 2012. Bought over phone due to it being a main dealer. The person who bought the car would not have known what to look for anyway so just did the safe thing and bought from main dealer.
Car brought up to the north east by Audi and car looked ok.
Supplied with 12 month warranty as main dealer supplied and sale of goods act etc.
After a week or two noticed that the clutch was squeaking a little bit going up hills. Emailed Audi to let them know in around early January 2013. They said bring it in when you get chance, no rush.
Car taken into local Audi dealer in the North East recently.
Audi say that they need to take out the gearbox to inspect what the issue is and that will cost £750 and that's not covered by warranty. Then, they will decide what the problem is and rectify. That bit may or may not be covered by warranty. So, minimum cost £750.
Obviously, the argument from the buyers side is that the car is warrantied and they let the main dealer know within a reasonable time of taking delivery and therefore that Audi should fix it free of charge.
There are issues with Audi UK, the dealer in the North East and the dealer down south who, whilst main dealers, don't appear to be in the same group.
Obviously bought from Audi main dealer and paid more money but did so because precisely because if something like this happened then it'd be fixed, no questions asked.
Help required as to what options the buyer has. The simple thing is for Audi to simply fix it. But, if they want money for it due to it being in warranty the buyer's not happy with this.
Thanks
This isn't my car but putting the story up here to see if anyone can help.
Bought a used (2006) Audi A3 from an Audi Main Dealer down south in mid December 2012. Bought over phone due to it being a main dealer. The person who bought the car would not have known what to look for anyway so just did the safe thing and bought from main dealer.
Car brought up to the north east by Audi and car looked ok.
Supplied with 12 month warranty as main dealer supplied and sale of goods act etc.
After a week or two noticed that the clutch was squeaking a little bit going up hills. Emailed Audi to let them know in around early January 2013. They said bring it in when you get chance, no rush.
Car taken into local Audi dealer in the North East recently.
Audi say that they need to take out the gearbox to inspect what the issue is and that will cost £750 and that's not covered by warranty. Then, they will decide what the problem is and rectify. That bit may or may not be covered by warranty. So, minimum cost £750.
Obviously, the argument from the buyers side is that the car is warrantied and they let the main dealer know within a reasonable time of taking delivery and therefore that Audi should fix it free of charge.
There are issues with Audi UK, the dealer in the North East and the dealer down south who, whilst main dealers, don't appear to be in the same group.
Obviously bought from Audi main dealer and paid more money but did so because precisely because if something like this happened then it'd be fixed, no questions asked.
Help required as to what options the buyer has. The simple thing is for Audi to simply fix it. But, if they want money for it due to it being in warranty the buyer's not happy with this.
Thanks

Have they rung Audi customer service to report it? They will let you know what the real options are and will possibly apply a bit of pressure if the dealer does have an obligation. As the car is out of manufacturer warranty, there are various levels of extended warranty, and not all cover faults such as this. If its the clutch, it may just be put down to wear and tear.
premio said:
Have they rung Audi customer service to report it? They will let you know what the real options are and will possibly apply a bit of pressure if the dealer does have an obligation. As the car is out of manufacturer warranty, there are various levels of extended warranty, and not all cover faults such as this. If its the clutch, it may just be put down to wear and tear.
Thanks, it was supplied with an Audi main dealer 12 month warranty when bought in December, but yes it may be classed as wear and tear but it was mentioned to Audi within 2 weeks of having the car.As the car is out of manufacturers warranty, the warranty is likely to be an insurance based warranty, this means that investigating problems won't be covered unless there is a fault and the warranty covers it.If it was an approved Audi warranty, then Audi may want to assist,if not they won't.Your friend should also take it back to the supplying dealer,they are under obligation to look after the customer. Clutches are difficult areas to judge as a clutch can easily be destroyed by poor driving styles in a very short space of time.If it is the friction material causing the problem it is unlikely to be covered, if mechanical, it may be. Buying a 6+ year old Audi is pretty brave anyway, they are not cheap cars to maintain, unfortunately your friend is just discovering this.Good luck with getting it covered without cost to your buddy.
Shurv said:
As the car is out of manufacturers warranty, the warranty is likely to be an insurance based warranty, this means that investigating problems won't be covered unless there is a fault and the warranty covers it.If it was an approved Audi warranty, then Audi may want to assist,if not they won't.Your friend should also take it back to the supplying dealer,they are under obligation to look after the customer. Clutches are difficult areas to judge as a clutch can easily be destroyed by poor driving styles in a very short space of time.If it is the friction material causing the problem it is unlikely to be covered, if mechanical, it may be. Buying a 6+ year old Audi is pretty brave anyway, they are not cheap cars to maintain, unfortunately your friend is just discovering this.Good luck with getting it covered without cost to your buddy.
Ok, thanks for your help.Yes, its an approved audi warranty so maybe not insurance backed?
So, supplying dealer is probably best bet? Tell them to get down to the south with the car and make it into a weekend break perhaps?!
Warranty is against defects, not abuse. Hence the debate.
If this problem was reported last Dec why is action only being taken now? What mileage in between?
One thing is certain, if the problem is a defect with the car then the dealer should cover all of the costs, not just part of them, either under the written warranty or under the implied Sale Of Goods Act warranty. But make sure you read the written warranty carefully to make sure exactly what it says.
If this problem was reported last Dec why is action only being taken now? What mileage in between?
One thing is certain, if the problem is a defect with the car then the dealer should cover all of the costs, not just part of them, either under the written warranty or under the implied Sale Of Goods Act warranty. But make sure you read the written warranty carefully to make sure exactly what it says.
Ozzie Osmond said:
Warranty is against defects, not abuse. Hence the debate.
If this problem was reported last Dec why is action only being taken now? What mileage in between?
One thing is certain, if the problem is a defect with the car then the dealer should cover all of the costs, not just part of them, either under the written warranty or under the implied Sale Of Goods Act warranty. But make sure you read the written warranty carefully to make sure exactly what it says.
thanks.If this problem was reported last Dec why is action only being taken now? What mileage in between?
One thing is certain, if the problem is a defect with the car then the dealer should cover all of the costs, not just part of them, either under the written warranty or under the implied Sale Of Goods Act warranty. But make sure you read the written warranty carefully to make sure exactly what it says.
car bought mid December last year. reported early jan via email. they said to bring in when need repaired, no rush was their words. due to bad weather and using another car they've recently got around to taking it in.
Mileage between the car being delivered and it being reported is very little, maybe 100 miles. It's probably done 2,000 miles from being delivered to present date.
The car is driveable and hence not taken in straightaway.
I thought that it would be done under implied sale of goods act but i'll get the buyer to read the documents.
thanks
Im pretty sure should the claim be apprived under warrety the investigation charges would be covered (actually i am sure of this)
They will have got pre autorisation for the costs to remove and inspect, the might find the clutch has been burnt out by miss use etc, they cant know this until they strip it. The customer would be liable in this case to pay the repair.
They will have got pre autorisation for the costs to remove and inspect, the might find the clutch has been burnt out by miss use etc, they cant know this until they strip it. The customer would be liable in this case to pay the repair.
jonah35 said:
thanks.
car bought mid December last year. reported early jan via email. they said to bring in when need repaired, no rush was their words. due to bad weather and using another car they've recently got around to taking it in.
Mileage between the car being delivered and it being reported is very little, maybe 100 miles. It's probably done 2,000 miles from being delivered to present date.
The car is driveable and hence not taken in straightaway.
I thought that it would be done under implied sale of goods act but i'll get the buyer to read the documents.
thanks
four months down the line?car bought mid December last year. reported early jan via email. they said to bring in when need repaired, no rush was their words. due to bad weather and using another car they've recently got around to taking it in.
Mileage between the car being delivered and it being reported is very little, maybe 100 miles. It's probably done 2,000 miles from being delivered to present date.
The car is driveable and hence not taken in straightaway.
I thought that it would be done under implied sale of goods act but i'll get the buyer to read the documents.
thanks
andymc said:
jonah35 said:
thanks.
car bought mid December last year. reported early jan via email. they said to bring in when need repaired, no rush was their words. due to bad weather and using another car they've recently got around to taking it in.
Mileage between the car being delivered and it being reported is very little, maybe 100 miles. It's probably done 2,000 miles from being delivered to present date.
The car is driveable and hence not taken in straightaway.
I thought that it would be done under implied sale of goods act but i'll get the buyer to read the documents.
thanks
four months down the line?car bought mid December last year. reported early jan via email. they said to bring in when need repaired, no rush was their words. due to bad weather and using another car they've recently got around to taking it in.
Mileage between the car being delivered and it being reported is very little, maybe 100 miles. It's probably done 2,000 miles from being delivered to present date.
The car is driveable and hence not taken in straightaway.
I thought that it would be done under implied sale of goods act but i'll get the buyer to read the documents.
thanks
The warranty will cover what it covers, and not what it doesn't. Hence my assertion earlier that it's a hell of an assumption that the warranty on a car from a main dealer will cover "whatever goes wrong with it". It doesn't, there's either a list of things it covers (and excludes the rest) or a list of things it doesn't cover (and includes the rest).
My point was that it's a rather unrealistic expectation, and the owner is more likely to get a satisfactory resolution if their expectations are not so far from the reality.
Really tricky situation and I feel for the OP, and it's also difficult to decode what the dealer meant by "no rush". They might have meant, take your time, the more you wait the easier it is for us to fleece you, particularly if the amount of friction material is low/non-existent.
The big problem is the logo on the front of the dealer's building. One could assume they have something to do with Audi and that they have an image to protect, and that you can buy blind. The reality is that they have nothing to do with Audi UK. They've simply signed a franchise deal which allows them to become a client of Audi UK and grants them a protected catchment area, in theory anyway.
I am sure there's load of BS Corporate procedures, checklists, controls, validation, minimum levels of service, mystery shopping etc etc . But the minute a target needs to be met, they all go out of the window and the "official dealership" returns to form and is only just as good as your average car dealership, ie not very.
There are exceptions of course (Franchised or not) but usually it's down to quality management and genuine care rather than it being coerced by the manufacturer, in other words it's rare.
The big problem is the logo on the front of the dealer's building. One could assume they have something to do with Audi and that they have an image to protect, and that you can buy blind. The reality is that they have nothing to do with Audi UK. They've simply signed a franchise deal which allows them to become a client of Audi UK and grants them a protected catchment area, in theory anyway.
I am sure there's load of BS Corporate procedures, checklists, controls, validation, minimum levels of service, mystery shopping etc etc . But the minute a target needs to be met, they all go out of the window and the "official dealership" returns to form and is only just as good as your average car dealership, ie not very.
There are exceptions of course (Franchised or not) but usually it's down to quality management and genuine care rather than it being coerced by the manufacturer, in other words it's rare.
It's becasue it's a clutch. If it was something like a window motor not working it would be easy.
As above clutches can be mullered by s
t driving. Your client will only be liable if, when the dealer removes the box, the clutch has been abused. Pressure plate in peices, flywheel blue from heat etc (not the full list) If it is just a simple mechanical failure it would be covered. Don't expect it done inside a week though. These claims always take longer because fo the back n forth with the warranty company.
As above clutches can be mullered by s
t driving. Your client will only be liable if, when the dealer removes the box, the clutch has been abused. Pressure plate in peices, flywheel blue from heat etc (not the full list) If it is just a simple mechanical failure it would be covered. Don't expect it done inside a week though. These claims always take longer because fo the back n forth with the warranty company.It's amazing how people jump on the sale of goods act, I wonder how many people actually know it! This fault is for a noise on a hill, the car I presume drives and there is no report in any of this of loss of power, failure to start etc this therfore renders the car fit for purpose, squeeks and rattles are not covered by the SOGA unless they affect the overall driveability which in this case is a tough one to argue. This is not aimed solely at the OP just makes me laugh reading through how many people jump on the bang wagon of SOGA, it's 7 years old with average mileage it's going to have done 60k+ and when new it was built on a budget.....it won't last forever and as it hasn't actually failed any help on the warranty in my eyes is a bonus.
Gassing Station | General Gassing | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


