Man maths at its best. Cater-field content included.
Man maths at its best. Cater-field content included.
Author
Discussion

Benbay001

Original Poster:

5,895 posts

188 months

Wednesday 1st May 2013
quotequote all
Last September i bought my current car, a Jaguar S Type R. It a lovely car, and after having fixed the initial faults that the car came with it hasnt (touch wood) thrown any more at me.
However, it would seem someone has filled my shoes with itching powder (I now have itchy feet)
The S Type is very good at doing what it does best, namely going very quick on higher speed stuff, but its too wide and too heavy to really be fun on a B road. It would also cost a bomb to do track days with, which is soon to be another consideration of mine.

I decided that to make a change in car worthwhile, id have to get something completely different.
And decided i wanted an Elise or a cheap Exige, however, i have since decided that such a car is too practical.

I then started looking at Westfields and Caterhams, and this is where my mind is now.

I did some rough maths and worked out that depreciation aside, my yearly running costs would be reduced by half (from £4000 for insurance, tax, fuel and a reasonable maintainance allowance to just over £2000) If you include depreciation then the saving is even greater.

So, i guess my question is, why isnt every PHer tooling around in a fiberglass kit car? Reasons i can think of
1) Dont want to look like a tool
2) Far too impractical
3) Powerfully built company directors couldnt possibly fit inside such a focused/small car.
4) I have missed a crucial factor in my financial calculations.

However, all is not so rosey! My troubles lie with the used prices of Caterhams.
My ideal car would be a Ford Sigma engined Caterham Roadsport 150, but looking at the used prices, you may as well buy new!

Doing some rough calculations I should have between £9000 and £12000 cash,including my car as p/x, and im happy to take out £4000-£6000 credit. Leaving me with circa £15000.
Id like something comparatively high mileage, as i will be doing 7000 miles per year and would hate to watch the cars value plummet. The new the better, Preferably Ford Duratec or Sigma engined, by having a K series engine car doesnt bother me.

I guess im asking
A) have i fked up my man maths?
B) Which type of Caterham/ Westfield should i look to buy?

Help!
Cheers.

McWigglebum4th

32,414 posts

235 months

Wednesday 1st May 2013
quotequote all
Have you got room for a shed also?

As caterham running costs are washers

Benbay001

Original Poster:

5,895 posts

188 months

Wednesday 1st May 2013
quotequote all
McWigglebum4th said:
Have you got room for a shed also?
I dont need a shed. I want the 7esk car to be a daily driver. I have no commute so if the weather is proper crappy i can simply not make the journey, or could borrow a family members car.

McWigglebum4th said:
As caterham running costs are washers
Wait, maybe you mean an actual shed? Somewhere to fettle and fix?
Do you mean the running costs are very low? Or that i will be constantly replacing washers? scratchchin

McWigglebum4th

32,414 posts

235 months

Wednesday 1st May 2013
quotequote all
In which case

Go and buy a Caterham

you won't regret it

Just one small adjustment to your mental process

It is not an impractical car

It is a very practical motorbike

Benbay001

Original Poster:

5,895 posts

188 months

Wednesday 1st May 2013
quotequote all
McWigglebum4th said:
In which case

Go and buy a Caterham

you won't regret it

Just one small adjustment to your mental process

It is not an impractical car

It is a very practical motorbike
Thats fine then. I commuted for a year on a motorbike (2 years if you include a moped).
And this time i dont even have to commute! biggrin

Will adding a fair number of miles per year affect the value hugely? 10 year old examples seem to have the sort of mileage i would expect to add in a year!

civicduty

1,857 posts

234 months

Wednesday 1st May 2013
quotequote all
Well lets put it this my old man has one as a weekend, second car and in 2 and half years

has


covered









1000 miles

petewaugh

69 posts

163 months

Wednesday 1st May 2013
quotequote all
No commute = no practicality worries. That's why most people don't drive one as life is generally full of compromises, and Caterfields are uncompromising cars. In the words of my inner self when looking at anything remotely tasty: "BUY IT!!!!"

ceebmoj

1,899 posts

292 months

Wednesday 1st May 2013
quotequote all
Do it. There are a number of people on hear including my self that do, its great fun. Hears my imposer BEC 7 on a chilly day earlier this year.



you will also want a sensible budget for some good out door clothing as well.

Benbay001

Original Poster:

5,895 posts

188 months

Wednesday 1st May 2013
quotequote all
Lovely thumbup
How does a £13000 Westfield compare to a £13000 Caterham?
Can only seem to find comparisons between cars of the same age, but the Westy is alot cheaper than the Caterham.