RCZ or Juke Nismo
Author
Discussion

MBBlat

Original Poster:

2,081 posts

180 months

Wednesday 1st May 2013
quotequote all
I know that they are supposedly aimed at totally different market segments but they are the only non-german cars that fit my requirements for a small(ish) sporty auto tow car.
No flames as to how I should really get a BMWAUDIVWMERCADES please, and no a MX5 is mot sutible smile

The Juke is cheaper, better equipped, 4WD for the winter and has a higher towing capacity.
The RCZ is prettier and has slightly better performance, but some reviews criticise its handling. I have also not been able to drive the Auto.

No kids or big dogs, so lack of space in the rear seats Isn't a problem.

LaurasOtherHalf

21,429 posts

227 months

Wednesday 1st May 2013
quotequote all
Really? Thee are your only two options?

How about a mini paceman JCW?

BE57 TOY

2,628 posts

178 months

Wednesday 1st May 2013
quotequote all
Out of those two I'd take the RCZ based on looks. Juke would probably be miles ahead in build quality and reliability in the long term though.

I have driven neither car.

greggy50

6,281 posts

222 months

Wednesday 1st May 2013
quotequote all
Juke myself seems vey good vfm and has had decent reviews as well smile

Hammer67

6,476 posts

215 months

Wednesday 1st May 2013
quotequote all
OP you may wish to check. IMIIC Nissan state that the Juke Nismo is unsuitable for towing and do not list any towbars for it.

AnotherClarkey

3,698 posts

220 months

Wednesday 1st May 2013
quotequote all
LaurasOtherHalf said:
Really? Thee are your only two options?

How about a mini paceman JCW?
Makes the Juke the less aesthetically challenged option I suppose.

MBBlat

Original Poster:

2,081 posts

180 months

Wednesday 1st May 2013
quotequote all
Hammer67 said:
OP you may wish to check. IMIIC Nissan state that the Juke Nismo is unsuitable for towing and do not list any towbars for it.
Checked with dealer - no official towbar yet but nothing stopping one being fitted.
Strangely if you check the Nissan UK website it lists a towbar as an optional extra for the Nismo and the builder lets you select one as well.

MBBlat

Original Poster:

2,081 posts

180 months

Wednesday 1st May 2013
quotequote all
LaurasOtherHalf said:
Really? Thee are your only two options?

How about a mini paceman JCW?
Got a Mini at the moment (clubman) and fancy a change

Hammer67

6,476 posts

215 months

Wednesday 1st May 2013
quotequote all
MBBlat said:
Hammer67 said:
OP you may wish to check. IMIIC Nissan state that the Juke Nismo is unsuitable for towing and do not list any towbars for it.
Checked with dealer - no official towbar yet but nothing stopping one being fitted.
Strangely if you check the Nissan UK website it lists a towbar as an optional extra for the Nismo and the builder lets you select one as well.
OK, I`ll check Nissan Dealer Bulletins tomorrow. I`m pretty sure there is one stating Nismos cannot be fitted with towbars. I`ll report back.

Cyder

7,190 posts

251 months

Wednesday 1st May 2013
quotequote all
Apart from the change to the bumper and fog lamp I can't think of a reason why you couldn't fit one.

Hackney

7,444 posts

239 months

Wednesday 1st May 2013
quotequote all
Is there a reason you have to choose between the two ugliest cars on the market?

chopper602

2,335 posts

254 months

Wednesday 1st May 2013
quotequote all
GT86 / BRZ ?

Heartworm

1,938 posts

192 months

Wednesday 1st May 2013
quotequote all
Hackney said:
Is there a reason you have to choose between the two ugliest cars on the market?
I rather like the Juke, embody bought one then realised nothing wrong with the current fleet. Well specced and a nice observe to be.

David87

7,046 posts

243 months

Wednesday 1st May 2013
quotequote all
I believe the Juke Nismo is only available with 4WD in conjunction with a ste CVT gearbox. Best bear that in mind!

Edited by David87 on Wednesday 1st May 22:46

Hammer67

6,476 posts

215 months

Wednesday 1st May 2013
quotequote all
Cyder said:
Apart from the change to the bumper and fog lamp I can't think of a reason why you couldn't fit one.
Possibly but here`s an extract from a post on a Juke Forum about this topic supposedly from Nissan:

The reality is the cost of developing and testing a tow-bar on this relatively low volume car does not justify the cost - we estimate less than 5% of this specific market would want to tow with it and in the end its a very expensive thing to do. You would not believe how expensive in order to test and ensure its 100% safe legally. The numbers don't add up I'm afraid. Of course, as I say, all this should have been known and communicated well in advance. I apologise again on behalf of Nissan, to you.


As previously I`ll check tomorrow. H67

Cyder

7,190 posts

251 months

Thursday 2nd May 2013
quotequote all
David87 said:
I believe the Juke Nismo is only available with 4WD in conjunction with a ste CVT gearbox. Best bear that in mind!

Edited by David87 on Wednesday 1st May 22:46
Sorry mucker you're wrong, it's also available in 2WD with manual box.

Cyder

7,190 posts

251 months

Thursday 2nd May 2013
quotequote all
PW said:
Cyder said:
Sorry mucker you're wrong, it's also available in 2WD with manual box.
Sorry mucker, you've completely misinterpreted the comment - he's not saying it is only 4WD, but that the 4WD option is only available with the CVT box.

Edited by PW on Thursday 2nd May 08:15
Quite right! getmecoat

TheJimi

27,801 posts

274 months

Thursday 2nd May 2013
quotequote all
If the RCZ drives as well as it looks, then I'd go for that.

Otherwise, the Juke.

Risotto

3,934 posts

243 months

Thursday 2nd May 2013
quotequote all
Is the German thing really a deal-breaker? I was just wondering if a 996 or 997 can be fitted with a tow bar... scratchchin

A tiptronic Carrera 4 would meet your criteria, apart from being German.

Edit:




Edited by Risotto on Thursday 2nd May 11:48

Bill

58,944 posts

286 months

Thursday 2nd May 2013
quotequote all
Humour me for a moment, but I'm struggling to see how you got from here:

MBBlat said:
small(ish) sporty auto tow car.
To here:

MBBlat said:
RCZ