RE: Autonomous driving - tested
RE: Autonomous driving - tested
Thursday 16th May 2013

Autonomous driving - tested

OK, officially 'semi' autonomous, but we tried taking our hands off the wheel anyway...



Semi-autonomous driving is how Mercedes describes it and, having semi-driven it, we’re a little scared.

This isn’t the future either, this is right now. If you choose the Driving Assistance Package on the newest E-Class your car will drive itself. And by that we mean you can take your hands off the wheel and the car will steer itself on motorways and in town traffic jams, taking corners and braking to avoid hitting the car in front.

Hands-off driving is technically 'verboten'
Hands-off driving is technically 'verboten'
OK, you’re not actually supposed to take your hands off the wheel, and we discovered that after 30 seconds or so it scolds you with a sharp beep and the appearance of a pair of blood-red hands on the screen.

It works via a combination of radar and cameras that monitor the white dividing lines on the road and the distance to the car in front. That’s not new, but Mercedes has grown bolder thanks to the fitment of a 3D camera that is able to lock onto the car you’re following in traffic to get a ‘tow’, turning with it to follow the curves of the road. The tech will also brake the car to a standstill.

This so-called Distronic Plus with Steer Control still works one-handed and the gentle steering wheel guidance in the E-Class Cabriolet we tried it in doesn’t feel too intrusive. In fact, we felt ourselves relaxing a bit, for example in conversation with our passenger we used more eye contact. Which may or may not be a good thing, depending on who’s in the passenger seat.

System can find its way around corners
System can find its way around corners
This is either a huge step in relieving tension on long dull journeys or a dangerous way to lull drivers into relaxing past the point at which they can quickly react in emergencies. Right now, we can’t work out which.

Even Mercedes warns not to get too comfortable: “You have to be well aware that something can go wrong, and be aware of the limits,” Dr Michael Kramer, the guy in charge of C-, E- and CLS-Class model ranges, told us. In other words, make them too good and they’ll never pass legislation.

We did find that. Cars suddenly cutting in aren’t picked up quickly enough, and if the white line disappears for whatever reason, the Merc will just keep drifting over. What Mercedes is saying is that the system will let you split concentration between driving and other tasks. “With it you arrive relaxed and maybe having made some useful appointments on the way,” said Gerd Junginger, product manager for the E-Class coupe and cabriolet. “You don’t have to focus so much on the traffic.”

We imagine this statement will have as many people privately punching the air as publicly berating him for it.

This could become your mobile office. Hmm...
This could become your mobile office. Hmm...
Take-up for the £2,345 option on the E-Class coupe and cabriolet will be small, estimated at 10-15 per cent according to Mercedes. You get more for that price, including automatic braking if you fail to spot a car or pedestrian while pulling out at junctions.  But that take-up will be an increase on the sub-10 per cent for the less sophisticated system in the old car. The imminent S-Class will get the tech too.

The Japanese have become so addicted to the tech it’s standard on Merc E-Class coupes and cabrios sold there, and what that country likes is a pretty useful barometer for what becomes popular (unless it’s a Nissan Cube).

Of course Google is hard at work on the self-driving car and, also in the States, Stanford University has an autonomous Audi TT track day car.

Mercedes itself has previously demonstrated it can build autonomous cars, but says that’s not the plan. The driver will be in charge for a good while yet, says Dr Kramer. “The law is very simple. Autonomous driving is not allowed. One day if we can convince the authorities, maybe they would change that law, but I have my doubts.”

Author
Discussion

suffolk009

Original Poster:

8,093 posts

196 months

Thursday 16th May 2013
quotequote all
And I thought semi-automatic gearboxes were ruining the joy of driving.

Triumph Man

9,652 posts

199 months

Thursday 16th May 2013
quotequote all
Oh great, another thing to distract people from the job in hand. One step closer to autonomous pods.

PaulMoor

3,209 posts

194 months

Thursday 16th May 2013
quotequote all
Why the focus on US autonomous cars? No wonder people don't think we make anything in the UK:

www.eng.ox.ac.uk/public-relations/news/wildcat-now...

http://mrg.robots.ox.ac.uk/robotcar/

Prawnboy

1,326 posts

178 months

Thursday 16th May 2013
quotequote all
how do you explain it to Plod when he nicks you for not paying attention.

mickymellon1

371 posts

196 months

Thursday 16th May 2013
quotequote all
another excuse for squishing bikers and cyclists

"sorry mate, I didn't see you"
"sorry mate, my car didn't see you"

as if people didn't pay enough attention at the moment frown

BaronVonVaderham

2,322 posts

178 months

Thursday 16th May 2013
quotequote all
No No No a thousand times NO!

A plague upon humanity is what this robotised invaison will become.

This could all end very badly, has anyone checked Sarah Connor's availbility in the not too distant future?

Edited by BaronVonVaderham on Thursday 16th May 10:03

sanctum

191 posts

206 months

Thursday 16th May 2013
quotequote all
Good to see this tech arriving, it's been a long time coming.
I welcome it for motorways and stop start traffic. The computer is always going to be able to react faster than a human. Make it mandatory for all motorways in all vehicles, the price of the technology will plumet and it will be retrofittable at the MOT.
The A and B roads are still out there to be driven, but no one really enjoys having to actually drive a car on the motorway.

scubadude

2,619 posts

228 months

Thursday 16th May 2013
quotequote all
sanctum said:
The computer is always going to be able to react faster than a human.
Yes, the computer might be... but the sensors it relys on are still far from perfect (which is why Google and others self-drive cars are festooned with additional sensors, lasers and 3D cameras) so it would be idiotic to make them mandatory, even thinking it should qualify you for sectioning!

IMO We should be going in the opposite direction and have deadman's handles in cars (or an equivelent system) where the cars starts braking the millisecond your attention wavers.

The first person who is run over by a self drive or drive assist car will be So rich from their payout they could probably buy Mercedes itself in entirety

Roma101

859 posts

178 months

Thursday 16th May 2013
quotequote all
I hope Mercedes' legal department is up to speed. Start revising those disclaimers now boys and girls!

dandare

959 posts

285 months

Thursday 16th May 2013
quotequote all
As mentioned above, for stop start traffic, and possibly on motorways, it may be a good thing. I start to fall asleep within a couple of minutes when in stop-start traffic (I usually take the next exit and try to sleep through the jams), so something that would work up to 10mph could be helpful.

For the rest of the time, warning systems are a good idea, but there are enough bad drivers out there who will become even lazier. If you can't be bothered to drive and pay attention, you should stay at home, or take a bus.

The whole thing is a bit frightening, to me.

Ex Boy Racer

1,167 posts

223 months

Thursday 16th May 2013
quotequote all
So Merc has developed this system but warns us that we shouldn't use it because that would be illegal and dangerous. The lunatics have taken over the asylum I reckon.

Captain Muppet

8,540 posts

296 months

Thursday 16th May 2013
quotequote all
Wouldn't it be safer to develop a computer system to make your "appointments" for you so you can concentrate on the driving?

They're automated the wrong process.

Although I think it could be fun to drive in front of a MB in a Defender and take the occasional off-road detour at speed.

MonkeySpanker

319 posts

168 months

Thursday 16th May 2013
quotequote all
What Mercedes is saying is that the system will let you split concentration between driving and other tasks.

Er, you're either driving (therefore concentrating on driving) or you're not driving (a passenger). People are already distracted with ipads & candy crush as it is without thinking they can just sit there & let the car sort it out.
Like Yoda & Mr Miyagi (sort of) said 'Do or do not, there is no try.'

daytona111r

916 posts

235 months

Thursday 16th May 2013
quotequote all
sanctum said:
no one really enjoys having to actually drive a car on the motorway.
I do, I enjoy most motorway and town driving . . . even in an Elise. The only time I don't is when the traffic is stationary/stop-start or there are mobile chicanes in the overtaking lanes. I honestly can enjoy myself as much on the North Circular sometimes as on a country road. That's why I don't understand the view of some to leave all motorway/town driving to the machines and just take the helm on the twisties. Unless of course you just want to take a nap or do some work. As I don't drive to work, I do really saviour it whenever I get behind the wheel, and enjoy 90% of my journeys.

Edited by daytona111r on Thursday 16th May 11:06

anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 16th May 2013
quotequote all
Another small step on re-enforcing in the general publics mind that "Driving" is not a task in its own right, but mearly like say "texting" or being on "facebook".

IMO, There are really only two options that make sense:

1) driver in full control
2) computer in full control


Anything else leads directly to the "I thought you were doing that bit" situation.............

MikeyBoy2000

72 posts

180 months

Thursday 16th May 2013
quotequote all
Utter nonsense.

You are either working or driving, NOT both.

Driving is one of the most skilled and dangerous things we do as humans - key word is that it's a SKILL that needs to be honed continuously.

Clearly MB has decided it's demographic are too daft to be able to get better at anything.

Adds nothing in my book.


Tomatogti

383 posts

200 months

Thursday 16th May 2013
quotequote all
It scolds you after 30 seconds! - that's a massive amount of time to not have your hands on the wheel - even on the motorway you'd have veered off the road/into the central reservation by then (lane control systems not in place).

Kawasicki

14,419 posts

266 months

Thursday 16th May 2013
quotequote all
sanctum said:
Good to see this tech arriving, it's been a long time coming.
I welcome it for motorways and stop start traffic. The computer is always going to be able to react faster than a human. Make it mandatory for all motorways in all vehicles, the price of the technology will plumet and it will be retrofittable at the MOT.
The A and B roads are still out there to be driven, but no one really enjoys having to actually drive a car on the motorway.
Computers don't always react faster than a human.

I really enjoy motorway driving.

Andy ap

1,147 posts

203 months

Thursday 16th May 2013
quotequote all
You may as well of just said here's the new Mercedes E-class looking for a place to have an accident near you......

Just what we need some more tech to make the Moronicons pay even less attention behind the wheel. Think when this technology comes into force as no doubt it will i'll take to having a sledgehammer in the boot so if said Moronicon crashes into me becuase they were letting their car do the driving i'll get out and pound it with the hammer with the excuse of It didnt see that coming did it?

oh god i despair about cars now.

McWigglebum4th

32,414 posts

235 months

Thursday 16th May 2013
quotequote all
Hurry up and give us automatic cars

I want a big button in my daily driver that takes me to work and then home again

I fecking hate commuting

I'd be perfectly happy if i never had to drive my daily driver ever again.

Make it electric and it would be even better


But my daily driver is how shall we term it????

st