Focus or Astra?
Author
Discussion

MitchT

Original Poster:

17,167 posts

240 months

Friday 21st June 2013
quotequote all
The OH is eligible for a company car in about a month. She's been given a list of 1.7 Astras and comparable Focuses, all diesels. We're wondering what the PH consensus is on these two cars? She owns a BMW 120d but has been driving an Astra 1.7d for the last few months as her work hired her one to use until she's eligible for a company car.

Due to the length of her commute the fuel saving on any of the cars she's been offered (when compared with her BMW) is more than the company car tax she'll have to pay, so she'll be better off for having a company car, even if she keeps her BMW, which is all good as she loves her 120d and wants to keep it.

The Astra and her 120d are pretty much night and day as a driving experience, so we're wondering how a Focus compares. We both prefer the looks of the Astra - the Focus is too fussy for our liking - but will the Focus be a better driving machine than the Astra, or are they both going to be so inferior to her BMW that she might as well just get the one she most likes the look of?

What say you lot?

SystemParanoia

14,343 posts

229 months

Friday 21st June 2013
quotequote all
ask for a prius, or an ampera

why pay loads of tax if you dont have to smile

David87

7,046 posts

243 months

Friday 21st June 2013
quotequote all
Not driven either of them, but the Astra looks miles better, not because it's particularly beautiful, but because the Focus is a bit of a dog.

MitchT

Original Poster:

17,167 posts

240 months

Friday 21st June 2013
quotequote all
SystemParanoia said:
ask for a prius, or an ampera
The list she's been given only has Astras and Focuses on it... and Insignias but she doesn't want a car that large.

David87 said:
Not driven either of them, but the Astra looks miles better, not because it's particularly beautiful, but because the Focus is a bit of a dog.
This is exactly what we're thinking.

dwol

100 posts

164 months

Friday 21st June 2013
quotequote all
Astras look smart but still drive like they did 20 years ago,focus drives well and looks ok.

SystemParanoia

14,343 posts

229 months

Friday 21st June 2013
quotequote all
Its like they're asking "do you want dog st rubbed in your face, or would you prefer we hide it in your pillow for you to discover with your face later"

frown

Blue Oval84

5,399 posts

192 months

Friday 21st June 2013
quotequote all
An Astra or a Focus will provide big fuel saving over one of the most efficient diesel cars in it's class? I'm guessing it's an older 1 Series? What mpg is your wife getting from it?

anonymous-user

85 months

Friday 21st June 2013
quotequote all
Ignore these dick heads who clearly know nothing. Cannot comment in the Astra but Focus is a global car and properly engineered. DAB radio is standard and it's nice to drive. Why not call a dealer and go for a test drive in both?

ps. 1.6 diesel Focus averages 55mpg and goes well enough, especially on the motorway.

Edited by anonymous-user on Friday 21st June 23:27

MitchT

Original Poster:

17,167 posts

240 months

Friday 21st June 2013
quotequote all
Blue Oval84 said:
An Astra or a Focus will provide big fuel saving over one of the most efficient diesel cars in it's class? I'm guessing it's an older 1 Series? What mpg is your wife getting from it?
Her 120d is a 54 reg early 2005 model. Old then, but still feels light years ahead of the hired Astra that she's using. She's getting about 39mpg from the BMW. The list of company cars is claiming about 60mpg for the Astra.

craste

1,227 posts

238 months

Friday 21st June 2013
quotequote all
Focus is a cracking car to drive, one of the best sorted chassis at any price.

MitchT

Original Poster:

17,167 posts

240 months

Friday 21st June 2013
quotequote all
wormus said:
Why not call a dealer and go for a test drive in both?
We might do that, at least for the Focus. She's using a hired Astra at the moment, so we know what that's like to drive. If the Focus is miles ahead of the Astra to drive then she might go for it. If not then she'll probably go for the Astra as it's a much nicer looking car. Basically, unless the Focus can give her 120d a run for its money as a driving experience then she'll probably get an Astra. The Focus will have to do something amazing to excuse its challenging looks!

bugmenot

129 posts

164 months

Friday 21st June 2013
quotequote all
wormus said:
Why not call a dealer and go for a test drive in both?
Yes do this. I test drove both (although they were petrol models) and I didn't think there was much in it.
But I massively preferred the looks of the astra. The interior and exterior of the focus just looked odd to me.

anonymous-user

85 months

Friday 21st June 2013
quotequote all
Can you take a car allowance and keep the current car?

Blue Oval84

5,399 posts

192 months

Friday 21st June 2013
quotequote all
MitchT said:
Her 120d is a 54 reg early 2005 model. Old then, but still feels light years ahead of the hired Astra that she's using. She's getting about 39mpg from the BMW. The list of company cars is claiming about 60mpg for the Astra.
Hmm, don't be disappointed when she gets nowhere near that then, in my experience the figures in the book for some diesels are utterly ludicrous! frown

CYMR0

3,940 posts

231 months

Friday 21st June 2013
quotequote all
Blue Oval84 said:
MitchT said:
Her 120d is a 54 reg early 2005 model. Old then, but still feels light years ahead of the hired Astra that she's using. She's getting about 39mpg from the BMW. The list of company cars is claiming about 60mpg for the Astra.
Hmm, don't be disappointed when she gets nowhere near that then, in my experience the figures in the book for some diesels are utterly ludicrous! frown
A friend of mine is getting about 57 overall from his 62 plate Astra diesel estate, using 'acceleration sense' and cruising at an indicated 80-85.

MitchT

Original Poster:

17,167 posts

240 months

Saturday 22nd June 2013
quotequote all
wormus said:
Can you take a car allowance and keep the current car?
Sadly not, but I've no idea why. It makes no sense that they simply can't pay her what they'd otherwise be shelling out on a company car, but they won't do it unless you're employed above a certain grade.

MitchT

Original Poster:

17,167 posts

240 months

Saturday 22nd June 2013
quotequote all
CYMR0 said:
Blue Oval84 said:
MitchT said:
Her 120d is a 54 reg early 2005 model. Old then, but still feels light years ahead of the hired Astra that she's using. She's getting about 39mpg from the BMW. The list of company cars is claiming about 60mpg for the Astra.
Hmm, don't be disappointed when she gets nowhere near that then, in my experience the figures in the book for some diesels are utterly ludicrous! frown
A friend of mine is getting about 57 overall from his 62 plate Astra diesel estate, using 'acceleration sense' and cruising at an indicated 80-85.
She could fall quite a bit short of the quoted figure and still be saving enough to offset the company car tax compared with what she'd pay if she was using her own car, such is the length of her commute, so we're not too worried about manufacturers' optimistic economy claims.

rix

2,966 posts

221 months

Saturday 22nd June 2013
quotequote all
Wife has a 2010 1.7 cdti astra (125), and I occasionally have cause to drive a new 1.6 derv focus. focus is better spec'd as standard, slightly sharper than the astra to drive and seems decent on the economy. Astra looks better IMO, durable interior and I think a bit nicer inside generally. Astra slightly stodgier to drive but very comfy as a cruiser. Astra gets nowhere near its supposed mpg - averaging a smidge less than 40mpg in mixed use.

Very little between them, both more than adequate but quite 'meh', tho I guess you already know that!

MitchT

Original Poster:

17,167 posts

240 months

Monday 12th August 2013
quotequote all
Update!

The OH is currently driving a two litre Focus Titanium which the lease company have sent her to try out as she's under pressure to get her car ordered but can't decide. She still also has the 1.7 Astra from the hire company.

My thoughts are that the Astra is much tidier looking on the outside but the Focus is a slightly nicer place to be on the inside. The OH feels that the Focus feels like a comfier ride - the Astra feels harder and somewhat 'crashy' on rough surfaces. I think the Focus feels firmer but she thinks it feels softer! Overall she's preferring the Focus but may be tempted by a smaller engine than the demo car she's got as it's indicating about 49mpg - she says she was doing a lot better than that in the Astra. The Focus is a little fiddly to get used to - she turned on the rear wiper and couldn't get it to turn off again - and couldn't work out how to wash the front screen at all. Turns out you have to pull it harder than she was doing, so you could call it a "blonde error", but she's not had this problem with any other car. Finally, the "keyless go" seems like a bit of an unnecessary gimmick which will probably go wrong at some point.

Performance wise, the Focus feels to have a little more mojo than the Astra, though not as much more as I'd expect for a 2.0 compared with a 1.7. Both cars feel significantly slower than her 120d which, despite its age, also feels much better built and has a far better ride.

I have a feeling that the Focus will win. Frankly, neither are a bad place to be - especially when all you're having to pay is the company car tax - but she'll be keeping her 120d for personal use as it's "night-and-day" different to both the Focus and the Astra.