Which short term commute car
Which short term commute car
Author
Discussion

Muncher

Original Poster:

12,235 posts

280 months

Monday 5th August 2013
quotequote all
I may be sent out on secondment to do 6 months in Brentwood (travelling from Ipswich) which is 60 miles, almost all on the A12.

If I am going to do that, I probably don't want to be doing it in either of my current cars (VX220 SC or Mk3 Mondeo Ghia X 2.5V6) as the latter will return very low 20s mpg, around town at the moment I get 18mpg but don't do many miles at all.

So ideally I need something for 6 months that I can put 15k on, will be very comfortable for the journey (maybe even an Auto) and will return very high mpg that I can sell on again for little to no loss 6 months later. I will probably only get 25p per mile so would only be doing this to save money.

I am thinking a diesel Octavia/Passat maybe? It doesn't need to be in any way fun, just comfortable, reliable and cheap.

Edited by Muncher on Monday 5th August 14:54

Hoofy

80,190 posts

313 months

Monday 5th August 2013
quotequote all
Given the cost of insurance and that you won't get what you paid for it unless you got an exceptionally good deal (consider knocking at least £1k off), I wonder if it's a false economy to buy another car just for this commute.

kambites

71,748 posts

252 months

Monday 5th August 2013
quotequote all
Six months or 60 months?

simonrockman

7,136 posts

286 months

Monday 5th August 2013
quotequote all
Audi A2

Krikkit

27,943 posts

212 months

Monday 5th August 2013
quotequote all
Peugeot 306 N/A diesel - cheap as chips, won't depreciate with a few extra miles, comfy seats.

Muncher

Original Poster:

12,235 posts

280 months

Monday 5th August 2013
quotequote all
Krikkit said:
Peugeot 306 N/A diesel - cheap as chips, won't depreciate with a few extra miles, comfy seats.
Nothing French thanks! It needs to be at least a little bit refined.

Krikkit

27,943 posts

212 months

Monday 5th August 2013
quotequote all
Muncher said:
Nothing French thanks! It needs to be at least a little bit refined.
Refined? As in soft-touch dash?

trickywoo

14,288 posts

261 months

Monday 5th August 2013
quotequote all
Audi A2 not a bad shout but not sure how comfortable they are. I thought the ride was on the firm side.

By my reckoning a car capable of 40 mpg will (with a 25p / mile payment)give you a surplus (after fuel is paid) of approximately £1,300. 50 mpg would give nearly £1,800.

At 30 mpg you will still be 'up' £500 ish.


Matt UK

18,084 posts

231 months

Monday 5th August 2013
quotequote all
Hoofy said:
Given the cost of insurance and that you won't get what you paid for it unless you got an exceptionally good deal (consider knocking at least £1k off), I wonder if it's a false economy to buy another car just for this commute.
Agreed. Plus the Mondeo should be cracking 30 on a run like that, late 20's at the very worst.

Sorry to add this, but IME the A12 is a terrible road for outside lane hogging, drives me insane.

RizzoTheRat

29,170 posts

223 months

Monday 5th August 2013
quotequote all
Get something with an already high mileage as the extra 15000 won't cause much more depreciation. The VAG 1.9TD engine has a good reputation, so Octavia or Golf make sense. 306 is also a good suggestion, both the 1.9TD and 2.0HDI engines get 50ish mpg and are reliable.

Muncher

Original Poster:

12,235 posts

280 months

Monday 5th August 2013
quotequote all
RizzoTheRat said:
Get something with an already high mileage as the extra 15000 won't cause much more depreciation. The VAG 1.9TD engine has a good reputation, so Octavia or Golf make sense. 306 is also a good suggestion, both the 1.9TD and 2.0HDI engines get 50ish mpg and are reliable.
My Dad's old Passat 1.9 and 2.0 both returned pretty decent fuel economy, 50+ in real driving, so that would be worth a shout.

ewenm

28,506 posts

276 months

Monday 5th August 2013
quotequote all
Long term hire/lease?

Matt UK

18,084 posts

231 months

Monday 5th August 2013
quotequote all
I presume you've done the maths, but I reckon you may only have a saving of about a grand.

Buy the time you have insured and taxed two cars over that time, you're only a minor bork away from zero gain... even if there's a few hundred in it, the ball-ache of buying/selling/parking/running a fleet may wear thin for the reward on offer.

Fire up the Mondeo!

Muncher

Original Poster:

12,235 posts

280 months

Monday 5th August 2013
quotequote all
Matt UK said:
I presume you've done the maths, but I reckon you may only have a saving of about a grand.

Buy the time you have insured and taxed two cars over that time, you're only a minor bork away from zero gain... even if there's a few hundred in it, the ball-ache of buying/selling/parking/running a fleet may wear thin for the reward on offer.

Fire up the Mondeo!
You are right, I haven't done the maths, this was only sprung on me today. I would SORN the Mondeo and just run one of them.

kambites

71,748 posts

252 months

Monday 5th August 2013
quotequote all
Assuming 6 months/15k miles; a 60mpg car would save you around £2000 in fuel compared to the Mondeo. Whether you can practically buy, run and sell a 60mpg car for £2000, I don't know. You probably can if you're careful, but you're likely to end up with something a lot less comfortable than your Mondeo.

matt21

4,404 posts

235 months

Monday 5th August 2013
quotequote all
Sell the Mondeo, either buy something you like to keep with better MPG or buy a VAG 1.9TDI with high miles already. They are tough.

SORNing the mondeo will do it no good, you will have bills when you re commission it again and 6 mths could always end up extending.

Chris71

21,549 posts

273 months

Monday 5th August 2013
quotequote all
Faced with a similar dilemma I got a Rover 75 diesel auto. It's not quick and nor is it remotely sporting, but it wafts beautifully, it's very comfy and it returns pretty respectable mpg on the motorway (a genuine 50mpg is possible sitting at 70, although this plummets in town).

It's got a bit more character than the mainstream repmobiles IMHO and it was usefully cheaper than, say, a Passat of the same age and mileage. I don't doubt the Germans are better screwed together, though, a few electrical bits have gone awry on mine already.

CYMR0

3,940 posts

231 months

Monday 5th August 2013
quotequote all
Dare I say it but I'd lose the Mondeo and get something more economical for the long term.

Either that or I'd try to swallow the extra fuel costs for the short term, but I'd probably be happy to take the opportunity to upgrade the Mondy for essentially free.

Matt UK

18,084 posts

231 months

Monday 5th August 2013
quotequote all
Muncher said:
I will probably only get 25p per mile so would only be doing this to save money.
Just looked it up - I run a Jaguar XJ6 3.0 V6 Auto and the past 7 months / 9,000 miles petrol has cost me 22.3p/mile @ an average of 27.58mpg.

Food for thought maybe about the Mondeo.

Muncher

Original Poster:

12,235 posts

280 months

Monday 5th August 2013
quotequote all
It's pretty much confirmed I will be going, it will be for 6 months, it cannot be for any longer.

I would lose the Mondeo permanently in favour of a Passat or similar if I could get one with a good trim level. The Mondeo was cheap (£900!) and had a lot of toys but most people would not buy one because it is so thirsty, but only doing about 4k per year in it (and probably less in a years time) it suited me fine.