Three Cylinders better than Two?
Three Cylinders better than Two?
Author
Discussion

User33678888

Original Poster:

1,147 posts

168 months

Monday 5th August 2013
quotequote all
I notice far more 3 cylinder engines are being produced for small engines, like the 660cc 3 pot to be put in the Caterham, the Bluemotion Polo engine etc.
Why not use a V Twin instead? Am I missing something? Odd numbers of cylinders are naturally unbalanced.

Matt UK

18,084 posts

231 months

Monday 5th August 2013
quotequote all
I think it may be development costs - I think a lot of triples are sawn off 4-cyl engines. Maybe.

CrowCrow00

4,254 posts

187 months

Monday 5th August 2013
quotequote all
The Fiat TwinAir is a two cylinder, isn't it?

kambites

71,747 posts

252 months

Monday 5th August 2013
quotequote all
I'd imagine a V-twin would be a rather odd thing to package in a small car's engine bay. You'd probably have to put it longitudinal which would hurt drive-line losses.

Jimmy No Hands

5,102 posts

187 months

Monday 5th August 2013
quotequote all
My 3 cylinder sounds like a 911.













Ish.

dirkgently

2,160 posts

262 months

Monday 5th August 2013
quotequote all
User33678888 said:
Odd numbers of cylinders are naturally unbalanced.
I think you will find that is not the case.

zcacogp

11,239 posts

275 months

Monday 5th August 2013
quotequote all
User33678888 said:
Odd numbers of cylinders are naturally unbalanced.
3-cyl with balance shaft is a much smoother engine than any straight or V-twin.

Flat twin can be smoother but is an expensive engine to build.


Oli.

kambites

71,747 posts

252 months

Monday 5th August 2013
quotequote all
dirkgently said:
I think you will find that is not the case.
Is it? Ones are debatable I suppose but threes and fives are fundamentally unbalanced in primary harmonics.

Of course you can correct primary balance with balancer shafts, but that adds a fair chunk of weight.

budgie smuggler

6,088 posts

190 months

Monday 5th August 2013
quotequote all
kambites said:
dirkgently said:
I think you will find that is not the case.
Is it? Ones are debatable I suppose but threes and fives are fundamentally unbalanced in primary harmonics.

Of course you can correct primary balance with balancer shafts, but that adds a fair chunk of weight.
Ford use an out of balance flywheel in the 1 ltr EcoBoost 3 pot instead of a balancer shaft.

http://www.carmagazine.co.uk/News/Search-Results/I...

Ozzie Osmond

21,189 posts

277 months

Monday 5th August 2013
quotequote all
I'm no engineer but won't a triple produce more torque than a twin, other things being equal? The engine produces its torque by exploding the mixture in the cylinders. A 4-stroke twin engine only has a single firing in each rpm. A triple will have more.

Bikes don't weigh as much as cars so need less torque to get them moving.

(Guess why a V8 has lots of torque. smile )

kambites

71,747 posts

252 months

Monday 5th August 2013
quotequote all
budgie smuggler said:
kambites said:
dirkgently said:
I think you will find that is not the case.
Is it? Ones are debatable I suppose but threes and fives are fundamentally unbalanced in primary harmonics.

Of course you can correct primary balance with balancer shafts, but that adds a fair chunk of weight.
Ford use an off centre flywheel in the 1 ltr EcoBoost 3 pot instead of a balancer shaft.

http://www.carmagazine.co.uk/News/Search-Results/I...
Surely that gives poor secondary balance?

Rovinghawk

13,300 posts

189 months

Monday 5th August 2013
quotequote all
User33678888 said:
Why not use a V Twin instead? Am I missing something?
Cost of two cylinder heads? Other additional costs?

M4cruiser

5,261 posts

181 months

Monday 5th August 2013
quotequote all
It's all down to development costs, build costs, and packaging in a small front-drive hatchback.

Balance doesn't seem to matter, the average driver doesn't care! I know some Fiesta drivers who can't tell they have a 3 cylinder, whereas to me it's more than obvious as soon as the engine fires up.

A flat twin is more balanced but try fitting that in a Polo.
Fiat's parallel twin packages better.

Shurv

1,024 posts

191 months

Monday 5th August 2013
quotequote all
Triples give you the best of both worlds, ie, 2 and 4 cylinders, and I think that for a certain cc, give a better natural balance. They also sound great.

dirkgently

2,160 posts

262 months

Monday 5th August 2013
quotequote all
kambites said:
Is it? Ones are debatable I suppose but threes and fives are fundamentally unbalanced in primary harmonics.

Of course you can correct primary balance with balancer shafts, but that adds a fair chunk of weight.
I think that's what I am saying, that the imbalance makes it more balanced IYSWIM biggrin Harmonics that's the word.

Captain Muppet

8,540 posts

296 months

Monday 5th August 2013
quotequote all
kambites said:
budgie smuggler said:
kambites said:
dirkgently said:
I think you will find that is not the case.
Is it? Ones are debatable I suppose but threes and fives are fundamentally unbalanced in primary harmonics.

Of course you can correct primary balance with balancer shafts, but that adds a fair chunk of weight.
Ford use an off centre flywheel in the 1 ltr EcoBoost 3 pot instead of a balancer shaft.

http://www.carmagazine.co.uk/News/Search-Results/I...
Surely that gives poor secondary balance?
You should have a look at a Ford Fox idling - it bounces around a fair bit inside the engine bay. You can't feel the vibration in the car though (well done engine mount chap at Ford).

alangla

6,853 posts

212 months

Monday 5th August 2013
quotequote all
CrowCrow00 said:
The Fiat TwinAir is a two cylinder, isn't it?
I found there were a lot of issues with vibration in the Twin Air. On the one I drove, the steering wheel was buzzing in my hand at 50mph in 5th, not what you want for a relaxed run. You ended up dropping it down a gear and spinning the engine faster in an attempt to get it a bit smoother but that then threw away any economy gains from the tiny engine. TBH, I'd be surprised if it's much cheaper to run than the 1.2 straight 4.

On the other hand, the 3 pot Peugeot 107 I drove was pretty smooth across the rev range. If it hadn't been for the slower engine note you'd have been hard pressed to notice a difference vs a similar sized 4 pot. Personally I'd always pick a straight 3 vs a parallel twin for a car, though I'm still not convinced they're any better in the real world than a similar capacity 4 cyl.

rallycross

13,763 posts

268 months

Monday 5th August 2013
quotequote all
Have noticed recently how many small. 3 cylinder petrols there are on the road now.

it's taken a while the first decent ones came out in the late 80's from Japan they have a very distinctive sound quite a nice thrum to them like a mini 911, my first one was a Subaru 1200 3 cylinder with switchable 4 wd in 1991.

Liquid Tuna

1,403 posts

187 months

Monday 5th August 2013
quotequote all
Years ago I went to Donnington to watch the Superbike GP. Triumph were developing their 3 cylinder and I have never heard anything like it. The Jap inline 4's were lovely, screaming round the track, but this Triumph sounded like the gates of Hell had been opened. Just awesome.

BFG TERRANO

2,172 posts

179 months

Monday 5th August 2013
quotequote all
Remember a mate had a charade gtti, 3 cyl turbo. Sounded sweet.