Buyer wants his money back.
Discussion
I sold my Suzuki jeep yesterday on ebay, he paid cash £870, signed a bit of paper saying sold as seen.
http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/151092179364?ssPageName=...
Drove it home from Cheshire to Bournemouth over 200 miles.
Today he sends me an email saying:
Dear nantw*******,
engine cuts out frequently and misfires when cruising. you said good mechanical condition and didn't mention engine issues even when I asked if it had any potential challenge to driving home. given that you and your dad are obviously mechanically aware based on the vintage cars you own I think this was a dishonest listing.
- bagabloomin*******
Now normally I know what you would all say, but this guy turned up and told me a story about his past ebay experience.
He told me he bought a speedboat that wasn't described correctly, so he took the guy to court and won his money back plus an extra £1000 for costs.
Where do I stand legally?
I would give the guy his money back, but I have a feeling he would thrash the living daylights out of it all the way back.
Just out of interest the car was fine, it was not misfiring when I owned it.
http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/151092179364?ssPageName=...
Drove it home from Cheshire to Bournemouth over 200 miles.
Today he sends me an email saying:
Dear nantw*******,
engine cuts out frequently and misfires when cruising. you said good mechanical condition and didn't mention engine issues even when I asked if it had any potential challenge to driving home. given that you and your dad are obviously mechanically aware based on the vintage cars you own I think this was a dishonest listing.
- bagabloomin*******
Now normally I know what you would all say, but this guy turned up and told me a story about his past ebay experience.
He told me he bought a speedboat that wasn't described correctly, so he took the guy to court and won his money back plus an extra £1000 for costs.
Where do I stand legally?
I would give the guy his money back, but I have a feeling he would thrash the living daylights out of it all the way back.
Just out of interest the car was fine, it was not misfiring when I owned it.
Just reply saying there were no mechanical problems with the car when it left your premises. If he wants to take you to court, then you will await the summons papers. Any more contact will be reported as harrasment.
Surely if it was misfiring and cutting out that badly, it would not have made it the 200 miles home, and who knows how it was treated during that 200 miles!
Surely if it was misfiring and cutting out that badly, it would not have made it the 200 miles home, and who knows how it was treated during that 200 miles!
I've given up selling on eBay theirs to many scammers I've just been done for £60 and eBay customer services are about as useful as a chocolate teapot and even went as far as paying the bloke who scammed me and charged me for the privilege in eBay and PayPal fees on top.
Looking on the net people are leaving ebay in droves because of issues as this.
If you got a receipt as sold as seen I would not be paying him a penny,
I would say he's bluffing you to get some money off you hence the story about the speedboat,
If there was a misfire wouldn't he just spend £30 on a set of leads and plugs sounds like he's hoping you will offer him a couple of hundred quid to get him off your case so then he has an extremely cheap car,
If your a private seller surely he hasn't a leg to stand on plus what court will expect the chancer to be buying an brand new car with warranty for that price.
I've just looked at your ad and it looks a nice car for the money( I would buy it if I was after a cheap reliable 4x4) with nice low mileage as well I can't see how he would have a leg to stand on with a 28 year old jeep tell the arse to do one.
Looking on the net people are leaving ebay in droves because of issues as this.
If you got a receipt as sold as seen I would not be paying him a penny,
I would say he's bluffing you to get some money off you hence the story about the speedboat,
If there was a misfire wouldn't he just spend £30 on a set of leads and plugs sounds like he's hoping you will offer him a couple of hundred quid to get him off your case so then he has an extremely cheap car,
If your a private seller surely he hasn't a leg to stand on plus what court will expect the chancer to be buying an brand new car with warranty for that price.
I've just looked at your ad and it looks a nice car for the money( I would buy it if I was after a cheap reliable 4x4) with nice low mileage as well I can't see how he would have a leg to stand on with a 28 year old jeep tell the arse to do one.
Edited by Vince70 on Saturday 10th August 12:22
Two trains of thought.
1) It's an old cheap 4x4 - pays ya money, takes ya chance.
2) If it did run a bit iffy the advert should have made it clear.
Isn't there a distance sellers act or something stating that goods bought via such as eBay have clause to say they have to be fit for purpose etc. etc. ???
BTW - not saying I agree with that clause but just something that's stuck in my sawdust grey matter.
1) It's an old cheap 4x4 - pays ya money, takes ya chance.
2) If it did run a bit iffy the advert should have made it clear.
Isn't there a distance sellers act or something stating that goods bought via such as eBay have clause to say they have to be fit for purpose etc. etc. ???
BTW - not saying I agree with that clause but just something that's stuck in my sawdust grey matter.
Edited by HaloGen8 on Saturday 10th August 12:22
"Who did you buy the car from?
"Your rights are different depending on whether you bought from a dealer or a private seller. If you bought the car from:
"-a dealer, it must be of satisfactory quality. If the car turns out to be faulty, you may be able to get a full refund, insist that it is repaired or ask for a replacement
"a private seller, you can't argue it isn't of satisfactory quality. If the car turns out to be faulty, there is little you can do unless you can show that the seller did not give a correct description of the car."
Source:
http://www.adviceguide.org.uk/england/consumer_e/c...
If you are a dealer and put "sold as seen" you've broken the law (SOGA and/or Consumer Protection Act). If you are not and he had a good chance to test drive the thing, then tough s
t to him.
"IF THE CAR YOU BUY HAS A DISCLAIMER
"Some car traders try to use disclaimers such as 'sold as seen', 'trade sale only' or 'no refund' to restrict your rights. This is against the law and you can report any trader that does this to Consumer Direct, the Government funded consumer advice service."
Source:
http://www.youandyourrights.co.uk/31.asp
"Your rights are different depending on whether you bought from a dealer or a private seller. If you bought the car from:
"-a dealer, it must be of satisfactory quality. If the car turns out to be faulty, you may be able to get a full refund, insist that it is repaired or ask for a replacement
"a private seller, you can't argue it isn't of satisfactory quality. If the car turns out to be faulty, there is little you can do unless you can show that the seller did not give a correct description of the car."
Source:
http://www.adviceguide.org.uk/england/consumer_e/c...
If you are a dealer and put "sold as seen" you've broken the law (SOGA and/or Consumer Protection Act). If you are not and he had a good chance to test drive the thing, then tough s
t to him."IF THE CAR YOU BUY HAS A DISCLAIMER
"Some car traders try to use disclaimers such as 'sold as seen', 'trade sale only' or 'no refund' to restrict your rights. This is against the law and you can report any trader that does this to Consumer Direct, the Government funded consumer advice service."
Source:
http://www.youandyourrights.co.uk/31.asp
Him taking the car is basically agreeing that the car is as you described. Ignore him. Sold as seen. The odd misfire doesn't mean its not in good mechanical condition. His fault for reading good mechanical condition as 'is an absolute dream to drive and drives as it came straight out the dealerhship'.
Major Fallout said:
Thanks guys, this is helping a lot.
I have sent this reply to him:
Dear *****loominbargain,
Hello
I am very shocked to hear that, as it never had a misfire with me.
When did the misfire start?
Regards
Jeremy
I realise your trying to be polite but i wouldnt even bother asking questions. Just say politely that it was running fine on the test drive and when he left your property with it. Goodbye.I have sent this reply to him:
Dear *****loominbargain,
Hello
I am very shocked to hear that, as it never had a misfire with me.
When did the misfire start?
Regards
Jeremy
Gassing Station | General Gassing | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff





