Manual or SMG e46 m3?
Author
Discussion

torqueofthedevil

Original Poster:

2,088 posts

208 months

Sunday 11th August 2013
quotequote all
Currently looking to buy an e46 m3. Always thought i wanted the manual because I thought i'd read that the SMG was a bit jerky / clunky in normal automatic mode. Also that id prefer the manual shift when giving it some.

However I test drove an SMG yesterday and the guy who had it loved it. When he drove it wasnt jerky when in auto mode (it was when i drove it but id imagine its something you quickly get used to).

So is it something worth going for? Anyone had one and regretted it? There seem to be much more SMGs out there than manuals.

Im not convinced yet though. Cant help but think that id get more satisfaction from blipping the throttle before a downshift - myself - that the car doing it.

The strange lul as it depresses the clutch when driving normally just feels strange too!

*Al*

3,830 posts

253 months

Sunday 11th August 2013
quotequote all
I've recently sold my E46 M3 SMG, once you understand the concept of SMG it's a superb system, very smooth and a pleasure to drive. The manuals are typical BMW manuals, clonky and heavy but with less risk of potential SMG failures. If I bought another M3 it would be SMG 100%.

torqueofthedevil

Original Poster:

2,088 posts

208 months

Sunday 11th August 2013
quotequote all
*Al* said:
I've recently sold my E46 M3 SMG, once you understand the concept of SMG it's a superb system, very smooth and a pleasure to drive. The manuals are typical BMW manuals, clonky and heavy but with less risk of potential SMG failures. If I bought another M3 it would be SMG 100%.
How expensive is the SMG failure? is there anything which can be done to prevent it? Are there any warning signs or things to look / listen for?

How often did you drive your SMG in 'manual'?

martinnitram

244 posts

232 months

Sunday 11th August 2013
quotequote all
I regretted it.

Problems with clutch not disengaging fully (adaptations BMW call it) and the robot that drives the gear change forced the change resulting in knackered box,
Two clutches, one done by independent, 2nd one by BMW
Various electrical gremlins with the system


Although wonderful when working properly.


billzeebub

3,913 posts

230 months

Sunday 11th August 2013
quotequote all
Manual

shibby!

930 posts

229 months

Sunday 11th August 2013
quotequote all
SMG, I prefer the smg and dct to the manual.

Not really all that impressed with the manual to be honest, the engine characteristics I think are much more suited to the smg type gearboxes.

samvia

1,635 posts

201 months

Sunday 11th August 2013
quotequote all
I took a gamble on SMG at the start of the year after a manual E36, I'm pretty impressed with it and I don't regret it yet. Sure, it's not as smart as more modern twin clutch setups but it's still bloody quick to change in S5/S6.

As daft as it sounds I've never tried driving in auto mode, I'm just not interested in it but it's not a daily driver so only ever comes out for a blast usually. It's pretty easy to adapt your driving to smooth it out, you get used to the timing of shifts and when to lift if you want to keep it smoother.

I say I don't regret it yet - nothing's broken on it yet...

sjj84

2,396 posts

250 months

Sunday 11th August 2013
quotequote all
I had SMG in mine, if I bought another I'd get the same again. Only with they did the same system in the z4 coupe I've got now.

Burrito

1,705 posts

251 months

Sunday 11th August 2013
quotequote all
I test drove both and ended up with the SMG, but only because I was getting a better trade in price. As it happens I really enjoyed using the SMG and would have another, but I still prefer the greater feeling of involvement with the manual.

That said, banging through the gears on full throttle and Level 6 is something else!

I'd read that the relay often went, so always had a spare in the glovebox, which went unused. I also had a preemptive fluid change to ease my nerves.

Best car I ever had. frown

Birdster

2,548 posts

174 months

Sunday 11th August 2013
quotequote all
samvia said:
I took a gamble on SMG at the start of the year after a manual E36, I'm pretty impressed with it and I don't regret it yet. Sure, it's not as smart as more modern twin clutch setups but it's still bloody quick to change in S5/S6.

As daft as it sounds I've never tried driving in auto mode, I'm just not interested in it but it's not a daily driver so only ever comes out for a blast usually. It's pretty easy to adapt your driving to smooth it out, you get used to the timing of shifts and when to lift if you want to keep it smoother.

I say I don't regret it yet - nothing's broken on it yet...
So am I correct in thinking that as you flick it up a gear you should release the throttle like you would a manual?

Cemesis

771 posts

193 months

Sunday 11th August 2013
quotequote all
Its SMG or buy another car. People talk about the manual but the clutch is offset, the release of the clutch pedal is crap and the gearchange is rubbish.

The SMG is brilliant once you learn how to use it and makes the car far more interesting to drive. The gearbox is identical in both the manual and SMG but the SMG runs a hydraulic pump that changes gear. This can fail but not that often and is certainly worth the risk (which is tiny).

Burrito

1,705 posts

251 months

Monday 12th August 2013
quotequote all
Birdster said:
So am I correct in thinking that as you flick it up a gear you should release the throttle like you would a manual?
You can, which makes the change much smoother and more mechanically sympathetic. But you can also do full throttle changes!

Birdster

2,548 posts

174 months

Monday 12th August 2013
quotequote all
Thanks for the information.

Baryonyx

18,297 posts

190 months

Monday 12th August 2013
quotequote all
Cemesis said:
Its SMG or buy another car. People talk about the manual but the clutch is offset, the release of the clutch pedal is crap and the gearchange is rubbish.

The SMG is brilliant once you learn how to use it and makes the car far more interesting to drive. The gearbox is identical in both the manual and SMG but the SMG runs a hydraulic pump that changes gear. This can fail but not that often and is certainly worth the risk (which is tiny).
It's definitely worth getting the clutch delay valve removed in the manual cars. I wouldn't bother with the SMG if I could get a good manual.

Captainawesome

1,817 posts

194 months

Monday 12th August 2013
quotequote all
I bought an SMG. Took me a few weeks to really get used to it but i absolutely adore it. Yes the auto mode is not the greatest but you can drive smoothly with it. TBH though i never use auto mode. Driving in manual is so easy and i find it a brilliant system for around town in traffic, very much less work than a manual. It is my first flappy paddle box but i love it. Had no issues with mine whatsoever. I would take it over the manual any day.

Naddy786

442 posts

207 months

Monday 12th August 2013
quotequote all
I think the SMG makes the M3 feel that little bit extra special imho.

I test drove a manual and SMG E46 M3 years ago and just loved the SMG by far.

I went on to buy an SMG one and another 2 more SMG M3's after that!

Never had a single issue with SMG on any of them or any other fault for that matter (all 3 e46 M3's were utterly reliable for me).

If I were to have another E46 M3 it would most certainly be SMG again. Manual wouldn't be an option for me on it.

Still a great car though regardless of what gearbox you go with.

crazy about cars

4,454 posts

200 months

Monday 12th August 2013
quotequote all
Correct me if I am mistaken but there seems to be 2 versions of SMG in the SMG. Never driven the SMG2 but heard it is more reliable and better than SMG1.

martin mrt

3,885 posts

232 months

Monday 12th August 2013
quotequote all
crazy about cars said:
Correct me if I am mistaken but there seems to be 2 versions of SMG in the SMG. Never driven the SMG2 but heard it is more reliable and better than SMG1.
You are correct, however the E46 was SMG2 only

The E36 M3 Evo had the SMG1

MMT

598 posts

217 months

Monday 12th August 2013
quotequote all
I'm fairly sure all E46 M3 are SMG2.
I have an SMG E46 M3 and love it, I wouldn't have bothered with the M3 had it only come as a manual. Also, my understanding is that you don't lift when it changes gear. They have an electronic accelerator pedal and the ECU adjust the revs automatically when changing gear. Obviously with traction off and the clutch in mode 6 things get a *little* lumpy on gear change, but then it's got to if its going to change gear that quickly.
Did I say I love SMG.

samvia

1,635 posts

201 months

Monday 12th August 2013
quotequote all
Birdster said:
So am I correct in thinking that as you flick it up a gear you should release the throttle like you would a manual?
Driving around town I tend to lift just to smooth it out - the timing is very slightly different to a manual in that I find it's smoothest if you pull for the next gear and then lift momentarily, rather than lifting before shifting. Around town I tend to keep it in S3 or S4.

I've only managed one track day in it so far and was really impressed - the flat shifts in S6 are properly violent in an old school manual shift sort of feel, it almost feels like it's trying to tear the rear subframe off more so than they normally do...

Would be interested to see stats on how many SMG cars vs. how many manual cars have had boot floor repairs - had mine done a few months back with the Redish strengthening kit but it still feels like the SMG is going to tear it's arse off flat shifting in S6 biggrin