How long will an engine last on the limiter?
Discussion
Supernova190188 said:
I remember hearing years ago that VW used to test the golf gti engine on the limiter for 24 hours solid, is there in truth in this? i never really believed it at the time. Do any manufacturers test their engines like this for hours on end?
I worked for Gates Power Transmission in the test lab for their belts. We would regularly hold an engine at its maximum revs, hooked up to a torque convertor (to replicate a car fully loaded), and wait for it to destroy itself one way or another.Was quite interesting.
Surely if there is a good amount of oil, and the cooling system is up to scratch, i would expected a car to sit on the limiter (off load) for ages and ages; it should be after all part of the safe operating range of an engine. Although engine wear will obviously be accelerated.
My mates 325 drift car was pretty much sat on the limiter under extreme load all the time, he had it for two years, before he sold it on. In that time he put 10k on it, and was still spot on at 180k miles
My mates 325 drift car was pretty much sat on the limiter under extreme load all the time, he had it for two years, before he sold it on. In that time he put 10k on it, and was still spot on at 180k miles
The Porsche GT3 engine was tested at the limiter non stop for 3,000 km:
http://www.motorsportmagazine.com/road-cars/road-t...
I guess that means the production version should technically be able to do the same.
http://www.motorsportmagazine.com/road-cars/road-t...
I guess that means the production version should technically be able to do the same.
Engines are not tested "at the limiter" for any period of time. They are tested at peak power speed(rpm @ full throttle) for usually 180hrs continuously.
These days the actual "Limiter" will include a secondary "torque reduction" via the throttle closing. So, hitting the limiter (i.e. the engine speed at which the ems is programmed to deliver zero effective torque) will initially cause a spark cut (the fast path control) that will limit engine torque very quickly to avoid overspeed. If the accelerator pedal is still held down, and results in a driver demand that would cause the engine to overspeed, the EMS system will limit engine torque to prevent that overspeed. That is done by closing the throttle plate(the slow path control). As such, the engine will now just sit at peak rpm but at a much lower load.
Worst case (for engine loading) is often the fast torque direction reversal caused by the spark cut events, when the pistons inertial loads are suddenly no longer partially offset by firing loads (cylinder pressure). However, it is not really sensible to make the engine robust to these events continuously, because they are transient (very transient for the average road car). This sort of engine durability will be covered by vehicles doing aggressive durability drive cycles and for more sporting cars, things like N/ring circuit tests etc.
These days the actual "Limiter" will include a secondary "torque reduction" via the throttle closing. So, hitting the limiter (i.e. the engine speed at which the ems is programmed to deliver zero effective torque) will initially cause a spark cut (the fast path control) that will limit engine torque very quickly to avoid overspeed. If the accelerator pedal is still held down, and results in a driver demand that would cause the engine to overspeed, the EMS system will limit engine torque to prevent that overspeed. That is done by closing the throttle plate(the slow path control). As such, the engine will now just sit at peak rpm but at a much lower load.
Worst case (for engine loading) is often the fast torque direction reversal caused by the spark cut events, when the pistons inertial loads are suddenly no longer partially offset by firing loads (cylinder pressure). However, it is not really sensible to make the engine robust to these events continuously, because they are transient (very transient for the average road car). This sort of engine durability will be covered by vehicles doing aggressive durability drive cycles and for more sporting cars, things like N/ring circuit tests etc.
daviebroon said:
I remember watching the Astras (and kangoos) come off of the line at the Luton plant... I was absolutely shocked at the check/RR it got before final release. Surprised the things worked afterwards.
Makes you wonder about the 'running in' period, doesn't it? I witnessed the same thing at a certain UK bike manufacturer, as each unit came off the production line.This is ford showing off their ecoboost engine to the americans ecoboost torture test
It obviously varies with different piston and conrod weights and such like, but on most of the numbers I've seen the difference in stress on the "bottom end" parts from max revs unloaded to max revs fully loaded was not much at all.
In these cases, something of the order of 80% of the stresses involved came from accelerating the pistons up and down the bores when unloaded at max RPM, the remaining 20% came from the load.
The lighter pistons, conrods and boost pressure bring this bias down, but doesn't tip the bias (that I've seen) and conversely heavy pistons & conrods and a naff cylinder head will make the bias more extreme.
In these cases, something of the order of 80% of the stresses involved came from accelerating the pistons up and down the bores when unloaded at max RPM, the remaining 20% came from the load.
The lighter pistons, conrods and boost pressure bring this bias down, but doesn't tip the bias (that I've seen) and conversely heavy pistons & conrods and a naff cylinder head will make the bias more extreme.
Max_Torque said:
Engines are not tested "at the limiter" for any period of time. They are tested at peak power speed(rpm @ full throttle) for usually 180hrs continuously.
These days the actual "Limiter" will include a secondary "torque reduction" via the throttle closing. ....
Doesn't this require a "fly-by-wire" accelerator? I thought the majority of cars still used a cable - or am I showing that I'm out of date again?These days the actual "Limiter" will include a secondary "torque reduction" via the throttle closing. ....
A few years back at a friends farm he had a knackered old ford Orion 1.6 CVH, somebody decided it deserved to die completely!
It was started and the throttle jammed wide open, we left it to scream itself to death....lasted about 10mins before it started spewing oil then slowing down and eventually seizing.
It was started and the throttle jammed wide open, we left it to scream itself to death....lasted about 10mins before it started spewing oil then slowing down and eventually seizing.
I had a 106XRD (1.5D) with a weepy cam cover gasket so I needed to keep topping it up with oil.
This was a regular thing and I soon got complacent, figuring I 'knew' just how much to dribble in every few days.
This worked well...for a while, but I was over-estimating the consumption, erring on the side of caution. Or so I thought.
I left for work as normal one day but about 7 miles down the road, when the engine had reached full temperature, something weird began to happen; the car started to accelerate on its own!
Luckily I was on the M9 at the time but it was very scary. What of course had happened was that my over-filled engine had begun sucking in oil through a breather and this was initiating compression ignition without any fuel needing to be added.
Not good.
I deliberated just running it - after all the little car couldn't do much more than about 95mph anyway - or repeatedly braking down to about 55 then letting it accelerate again, but I didn't appreciate what was going on and I was worried that something would go pop or I'd run out of road (the roundabout at Dunblane was about 25 miles away). The clouds of white smoke should've been a clue.
So I pulled over and sat at the side of the road, got out and called the Police.
I then sat and watched as my little car revved its little nuts off for about 10 minutes, being gradually enveloped in a cloud of smoke, first white, then grey and finally black, until the revs eventually died down and the motor stopped with a series of sickening noises
What I should've done of course try to stall the bugger by sliding my foot off the clutch (possible, I'm told) or even just keep on driving; if the oil wasn't too much then it would probably have burned off in the next 20 miles or so.
So, a lesson learned for me and an answer of sorts for this thread: Less than 10 minutes with a hydraulic-ing 90s diesel hatchback
This was a regular thing and I soon got complacent, figuring I 'knew' just how much to dribble in every few days.
This worked well...for a while, but I was over-estimating the consumption, erring on the side of caution. Or so I thought.
I left for work as normal one day but about 7 miles down the road, when the engine had reached full temperature, something weird began to happen; the car started to accelerate on its own!
Luckily I was on the M9 at the time but it was very scary. What of course had happened was that my over-filled engine had begun sucking in oil through a breather and this was initiating compression ignition without any fuel needing to be added.
Not good.
I deliberated just running it - after all the little car couldn't do much more than about 95mph anyway - or repeatedly braking down to about 55 then letting it accelerate again, but I didn't appreciate what was going on and I was worried that something would go pop or I'd run out of road (the roundabout at Dunblane was about 25 miles away). The clouds of white smoke should've been a clue.
So I pulled over and sat at the side of the road, got out and called the Police.
I then sat and watched as my little car revved its little nuts off for about 10 minutes, being gradually enveloped in a cloud of smoke, first white, then grey and finally black, until the revs eventually died down and the motor stopped with a series of sickening noises

What I should've done of course try to stall the bugger by sliding my foot off the clutch (possible, I'm told) or even just keep on driving; if the oil wasn't too much then it would probably have burned off in the next 20 miles or so.
So, a lesson learned for me and an answer of sorts for this thread: Less than 10 minutes with a hydraulic-ing 90s diesel hatchback

Edited by loudlashadjuster on Monday 12th August 11:42
Years ago a friend had a 2.0L Sierra (F-reg I think it was, in white).
Anyway, it eventually was going to the big scrap heap in the sky, so he thought he'd blow it up.
No oil, no water, and a brick on the accelerator pedal. It lasted, sounding ok, for a fair few mins (3-4) and then started sounding clattery and very very bad. Then eventually something metal went through something metal and created a big hole. So a grand total of probably 7mins or so. Far more than you'd ever think!
Anyway, it eventually was going to the big scrap heap in the sky, so he thought he'd blow it up.
No oil, no water, and a brick on the accelerator pedal. It lasted, sounding ok, for a fair few mins (3-4) and then started sounding clattery and very very bad. Then eventually something metal went through something metal and created a big hole. So a grand total of probably 7mins or so. Far more than you'd ever think!
Gassing Station | General Gassing | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


