Why do nearly all cars have open diffs?
Why do nearly all cars have open diffs?
Author
Discussion

blugnu

Original Poster:

1,523 posts

272 months

Monday 12th August 2013
quotequote all
Limited slip diffs on 2 wheel drive cars would seem to be vastly superior to the open type - living near some big hills as I do I find that I can get almost anywhere in winter with the correct tyres, but it'd be a lot easier with a LSD I would imagine.

Having got delayed in a field on Sunday as someone tried to rev their way out of a mud-patch I got to wondering why more cars don't have one fitted. The traction benefit would be great and the weight and fuel efficiency penalty minimal. I know Citroen have a van version of the Berlingo with one, and the Qubo Trekking has one too, I think (or that might be an electronic simulation of one - not sure)

I guess they would cost more, but am I missing something else? Are they noisy or unreliable compared to an open diff?

Also, as an aside, I presume you could fit an aftermarket one to any car, should you be able to find one that fits?

kambites

71,747 posts

252 months

Monday 12th August 2013
quotequote all
How often does the average driver get into a situation where a locking/limited slip differential would make any difference?

Most modern cars don't have differentials in separate housing but rather as part of a transaxle unit, which makes replacement a bit more complicated than simply bolting a different unit in.

McWigglebum4th

32,414 posts

235 months

Monday 12th August 2013
quotequote all
Mainly cost/benefit.

Also a good traction control can do the same job


Also you can't chrome it and have a shiny thing on display

RobCrezz

7,892 posts

239 months

Monday 12th August 2013
quotequote all
Cost.

GroundEffect

13,864 posts

187 months

Monday 12th August 2013
quotequote all
They're cheaper and they work 99% of the time.

blugnu

Original Poster:

1,523 posts

272 months

Monday 12th August 2013
quotequote all
Fair point about how often it'd be needed, although sat here at my desk I can see three Range Rovers and none of them look like they go off-road, so mere necessity doesn't seem to put customers off smile

Personally I'd like one as I take my car into fields (camping , car boot sales and so on) fairly regularly. Once or twice I've got stuck, and a few more times I've come close. I've recently bought a trailer so will no doubt at some point have to tow that through a muddy field too. I also live on a big hill that is sometimes a challenge even in winter tyres: I messed it up once last winter and it took half an hour to get going again (I should have reversed up the hill but decided it'd be fine to turn the car around. I was wrong.) A limited slip diff would seem to be the ideal thing to make such occasions easier to deal with.

In fact the more I think about it, the more I want one. How do I find out if a car has a replaceable diff? (consults google)

kambites

71,747 posts

252 months

Monday 12th August 2013
quotequote all
If it's FWD it'll be a transaxle so you'll have to dismantle the gearbox to change the diff.

Of course it's not impossible, but it'd almost certainly be cheaper to replace the car.

motco

17,674 posts

277 months

Monday 12th August 2013
quotequote all
On a rear wheel drive car it can be much easier to lose the back end through a heavy right foot with an LSD. With an open diff it's only the unloaded wheel (inside of the corner) that spins up - to little effect. Dunno about FWD...

jimbobsimmonds

1,824 posts

196 months

Monday 12th August 2013
quotequote all
Cost...

Krikkit

27,943 posts

212 months

Monday 12th August 2013
quotequote all
McWigglebum4th said:
Mainly cost/benefit.

Also a good traction control can do the same job
Spot on - for the extra cost of developing/manufacturing an LSD, even a cheapo Quaife-type ATB, it's far cheaper to engineer traction control through ABS to help out.

chris182

4,240 posts

184 months

Monday 12th August 2013
quotequote all
The average consumer doesn't understand the difference so will not pay any more money for a vehicle so equipped. Adding an LSD is therefore just increasing cost for no benefit, thus decreasing profit margin.

I don't believe that road cars really have a need for them anyway unless they are very powerful and 2wd (apart from perhaps on the two days of snow a year). There is no situation on the road I can think of where a LSD would make any difference assuming one is driving safely and legally.

motorhole

692 posts

251 months

Monday 12th August 2013
quotequote all
Viscous and clutch-pack type LSDs are not maintenance free, so where the diff/gearbox are a single unit (pretty much all FWD cars, some RWD cars), clutch pack replacement would be involved.

Tyres will wear faster with any kind of LSD.

Automatic torque biasing diffs (Quaife, Torsen et al.) are maintenance free but have some foibles with respect to driving - tramlining etc, which a normal everyday driver might not appreciate. They are also heavy and expensive.

As said, an open diff is cheap, maintenance free and works 99% of the time for 99% of drivers in 99% of the cars that are sold.

RichwiththeS2000

443 posts

165 months

Monday 12th August 2013
quotequote all
This is why I'm put off all non-M BMWs. I'd probably have a 335d if it had a proper rear end. These guys are releasing relatively very powerful cars, with no LSD, relying on the traction control to stop the inside wheel spinning.

However, some of us are (more than) happy to control the back end and steer from the rear! I'd never buy a RWD car without an LSD, I've driven them and the feeling of the inside wheel spinning is horrible.

But agree with the comments here, it's cost/benefit. Most people don't understand what they do and dont press on hard enough to benefit from one. It's also safer in some regards because its less likely to drift, its less safe in other regards because when it does step out with an open diff, you have less control and it can turn into a lottery of which wheel(s) will grip.

motco

17,674 posts

277 months

Monday 12th August 2013
quotequote all
RichwiththeS2000 said:
This is why I'm put off all non-M BMWs. I'd probably have a 335d if it had a proper rear end. These guys are releasing relatively very powerful cars, with no LSD, relying on the traction control to stop the inside wheel spinning.

However, some of us are (more than) happy to control the back end and steer from the rear! I'd never buy a RWD car without an LSD, I've driven them and the feeling of the inside wheel spinning is horrible.

But agree with the comments here, it's cost/benefit. Most people don't understand what they do and dont press on hard enough to benefit from one. It's also safer in some regards because its less likely to drift, its less safe in other regards because when it does step out with an open diff, you have less control and it can turn into a lottery of which wheel(s) will grip.
My soft top weekend-mobile is a 2.2 Sport Z3 and it has a Torsen LSD as standard. It does tramline on some tyres but not on others. The OEM Dunlop SP Sport seem fine.

DanielSan

20,118 posts

198 months

Monday 12th August 2013
quotequote all
kambites said:
If it's FWD it'll be a transaxle so you'll have to dismantle the gearbox to change the diff.

Of course it's not impossible, but it'd almost certainly be cheaper to replace the car.
Only if you have a car worth less than 1500-2000. It's around a grand to buy and fit an LSD in a FWD car. Priced them up for my Civic and then VXR afterwards. Just never got round to doing it.

Zwolf

25,878 posts

237 months

Monday 12th August 2013
quotequote all
RichwiththeS2000 said:
This is why I'm put off all non-M BMWs.
Ones with V12s have 25% locking LSDs too. Oddly, despite an M engine, the Z8 has an open diff. I *think* it's a singular exception.

Edited by Zwolf on Monday 12th August 17:26

Ozzie Osmond

21,189 posts

277 months

Monday 12th August 2013
quotequote all
Cheap LSDs can upset handling so a very mixed blessing. Therefore makers don't bother with cheap ones and decent ones only get fitted on decent cars.

Mr2Mike

20,143 posts

286 months

Monday 12th August 2013
quotequote all
motorhole said:
Tyres will wear faster with any kind of LSD.
Why would there be any extra wear with a torque biasing or viscous diff?

Mr2Mike

20,143 posts

286 months

Monday 12th August 2013
quotequote all
doogz said:
What's a 'cheap LSD'?
Possibly one that involves using a welder? biggrin

kambites

71,747 posts

252 months

Monday 12th August 2013
quotequote all
Mr2Mike said:
doogz said:
What's a 'cheap LSD'?
Possibly one that involves using a welder? biggrin
That would be very limited slip. hehe