M-I-L and Tyres
Discussion
Ok, so here we go...
Mother in Law has a Clio that is 7 years old. She has owned it from new and has done about 18k miles in it. All four tyres have cracks in the sidewall and an advisory was given in March for the M.O.T. highlighting this.
She has decided to change all four tyres and I would agree with this as the cracks are quite bad. I always have premium tyres on my car but would it be a waste of money on a car that does about 2500 miles a year and never goes faster than 55mph?
I called a local tyre place today and was quoted £48 for a Goodyear, £43 for a falken and £34 for a budget. He said I'd be wasting money on premium tyres and to just fit the budget ones as they would still have to be replaced in 7 years because of sidewall cracks rather than tread.
It goes against all what I believe to tell my mother in law to get the budget tyres but then it does seem a bit of a waste to go for the Goodyears.
What would you do in the same situation?
Mother in Law has a Clio that is 7 years old. She has owned it from new and has done about 18k miles in it. All four tyres have cracks in the sidewall and an advisory was given in March for the M.O.T. highlighting this.
She has decided to change all four tyres and I would agree with this as the cracks are quite bad. I always have premium tyres on my car but would it be a waste of money on a car that does about 2500 miles a year and never goes faster than 55mph?
I called a local tyre place today and was quoted £48 for a Goodyear, £43 for a falken and £34 for a budget. He said I'd be wasting money on premium tyres and to just fit the budget ones as they would still have to be replaced in 7 years because of sidewall cracks rather than tread.
It goes against all what I believe to tell my mother in law to get the budget tyres but then it does seem a bit of a waste to go for the Goodyears.
What would you do in the same situation?
jagnet said:
I'd put the Goodyear tyres on, it's not as if they're expensive to start with. Less than a tank of fuel difference in price between them and the budget tyres for peace of mind.
Alternatively, source some decent part worn tyres.
There is that peace of mind thing too and if they last another 7 years then £50 is nothing really.Alternatively, source some decent part worn tyres.
I did also think about the part worn option too but I'm put off because you never know what's happened to them in the past. I might look in to this though, just to see what's out there.
10 Pence Short said:
I'd go for the ditchfinders. The MIL isn't, I imagine, going to test grip levels or journey in conditions that make the extra cost worthwhile. Why spend more in those circumstances?
This is what I am torn between. Every fibre of my body says get the Goodyear but its not like she drives like she stole it so why spend more.GC8 said:
Very, very bad advice. I suspect that the REAL reason for the advice was that there is FAR more profit on the ditchfinders than there is on Falken or Goodyear tyres.
I'm not so sure TBH. They are THE cheapest place in town and I ask for prices for one tyre, then asked if he could do me a deal for four. He reckoned that it was the lowest he could go and only made £10 per tyre. That was on the Goodyear too. Could he really be paying a lot less than £24 for a budget tyre?
Gassing Station | General Gassing | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff




