Making the transition back to petrol from diesel?
Making the transition back to petrol from diesel?
Author
Discussion

fjord

Original Poster:

2,143 posts

168 months

Monday 12th August 2013
quotequote all
About 10 months ago i chopped in my st220. Reliability was one reason, but i was pissed off with 25mpg all the time. I only do about 10,000 a year but it was still starting to hurt the wallet a bit. It got to the point where i couldnt go out for a spirited drive without blowing 1/4 of a tank, and as such I started limiting myself to when I used it.

Anyway, I bought a low mileage e46 320d and not really looked back. Running at 42mpg and i actually cant recall the last time i filled up.

Now i've moved house, im starting to save and have a bit of change left over, and am looking at E91 330's.

Based on my experiance of the st, is it pointless looking at 330/335i's? They sell (in some cases, a lot) cheaper than their diesel opposites but im still unsure if i want to be back in the Mondeo mindset of hating driving it because of the cost. I heard the 330d with the autobox is bloody brilliant anyway, but i'd have to drive one first.

I like the 320, but its just a bit boring and not much fun. Hopefully a 330 would fix that. I've looked at 325's but there doesnt appear to be much justification for a half-assed engine.

I've also kept a close eye on VXR8's. As a bit of a dream car, i'd love one, but i know thats just a stupid fking idea biggrin



Edited by fjord on Monday 12th August 22:05

dm46

377 posts

175 months

Monday 12th August 2013
quotequote all
You've sold your soul to the devil.

HustleRussell

26,715 posts

191 months

Monday 12th August 2013
quotequote all
I 'downgraded' from a Mondeo TDCI to an old 5-series with a 2.5 straight six and I haven't regretted it for a second. I was worried I would before I did it but i quickly realised that ultimately I was happier to drive the BMW and that's all that matters smile

poing

8,743 posts

231 months

Monday 12th August 2013
quotequote all
Keep the 320 and buy a cheap weekend toy?

Phateuk

1,034 posts

168 months

Monday 12th August 2013
quotequote all
You may be in a similar situation with a pre face lift E9x averaging 30mpg at best. And the facelift 330i models are a lot less common (everyone seemed to switch to diesel) and therefore similar price (if not more) than a 330d.

macp

4,823 posts

214 months

Monday 12th August 2013
quotequote all
Completely get where your coming from its a real pisser.We bought an audi a3 sportback tdi and its been great but now the dmf is getting noisy and it regularly goes into limp mode resulting in zero boost.We are going to have to spend some serious cash on it soon.So we have to ask ourselves was it really worth buying a diesel?

fjord

Original Poster:

2,143 posts

168 months

Tuesday 13th August 2013
quotequote all
macp said:
Completely get where your coming from its a real pisser.We bought an audi a3 sportback tdi and its been great but now the dmf is getting noisy and it regularly goes into limp mode resulting in zero boost.We are going to have to spend some serious cash on it soon.So we have to ask ourselves was it really worth buying a diesel?
In comparison, i've never had a problem with my 320.

I'd like to think with the miles im doing, if i get a decent one, things like DMF shouldnt be a huge issue straight away.

I suppose it comes down to this:

Is a 330i more fun than a 330d by enough to justify the extra fuel & tax costs?

HustleRussell

26,715 posts

191 months

Tuesday 13th August 2013
quotequote all
fjord said:
I suppose it comes down to this:

Is a 330i more fun than a 330d by enough to justify the extra fuel & tax costs?
To the average person? probably not. To you or I? maybe. Although I have to say it's much harder to make the man maths stack up if a 330i will really cost you as much to buy as a 330d.

VeeFource

1,079 posts

208 months

Tuesday 13th August 2013
quotequote all
The 123d is meant to be the best of both worlds and a LOT cheaper to buy than an equivalent 330d. They're also more nimble and a bit more fun handling if not as good looking.

I was looking into 130is as I prefer the more fun side to cars but unfortunately they seem to go for the same as an equivalent 123ds so again can't make the man maths work. So I've just ended up keeping my old E36 as can't decide

Edited by VeeFource on Tuesday 13th August 12:49

R1 Indy

4,511 posts

214 months

Tuesday 13th August 2013
quotequote all
I did this, chopped my 3yr old Alfa 159 derv in for a 12yr old CLK55 AMG.

Now cry at only getting 200 miles to £80! But soooo worth it driving

rossub

6,072 posts

221 months

Tuesday 13th August 2013
quotequote all
I changed a Civic 2.2 Diesel for the Type R after finding myself in the same position. The diesel was just about quick enough, but it wasn't desirable and never put a smile on my face.

Sacrificed 48 mpg and cheap tax, for 32 mpg and £270 tax. But you've got to accept extra cost for driving enjoyment.

I sometimes think about 50 mpg+ again, but I know I would very quickly get fed up.

TREMAiNE

4,164 posts

180 months

Tuesday 13th August 2013
quotequote all
Whilst I've only personally owned petrol, I have gone from a petrol that attained 35mpg+ to a car that, at best, gets 20mpg...

Its horrible to adjust to but you make up for it in FUN!

eztiger

836 posts

211 months

Tuesday 13th August 2013
quotequote all
fjord said:
I've also kept a close eye on VXR8's. As a bit of a dream car, i'd love one, but i know thats just a stupid fking idea biggrin
Do this.

Don't think that helps - but you brought them up smile

Depends on the type of driving you'll do - I'm not convinced there would be a *huge* difference between the vxr8 running costs and a 335i. Certainly within the limits of a good bit of man maths.

Sam.F

1,145 posts

231 months

Tuesday 13th August 2013
quotequote all
The 30d and 35d are more fun than the 20d but if it's driving fun you're interested in they might not suit. My Dad had a 335d coupe and it was fast in a lazy sort of way (great weapon for A-road overtaking) but dull to drive on twisty roads. If you can bear to drive gently day to day the petrol ones will return mid-high 30s mpg on a run which will largely cancel out any "leisure" driving you might do.

Escy

4,132 posts

180 months

Tuesday 13th August 2013
quotequote all
macp said:
Completely get where your coming from its a real pisser.We bought an audi a3 sportback tdi and its been great but now the dmf is getting noisy and it regularly goes into limp mode resulting in zero boost.We are going to have to spend some serious cash on it soon.So we have to ask ourselves was it really worth buying a diesel?
Same thing happened to my Golf Mk5 GT TDI, knew I should have got a GTI

aka_kerrly

12,506 posts

241 months

Tuesday 13th August 2013
quotequote all
Escy said:
macp said:
Completely get where your coming from its a real pisser.We bought an audi a3 sportback tdi and its been great but now the dmf is getting noisy and it regularly goes into limp mode resulting in zero boost.We are going to have to spend some serious cash on it soon.So we have to ask ourselves was it really worth buying a diesel?
Same thing happened to my Golf Mk5 GT TDI, knew I should have got a GTI
But they both have DMF.

Although I agree with the general view that for what a diesel saves you in fuel it can easily negate any saving with one large bill from a failing DMF, DPF, EGRs, injectors and fuel pumps to name a few.

bracken78

996 posts

237 months

Tuesday 13th August 2013
quotequote all
I have a E91 2006 330i and on the MPG front my best is 31.4 and worst 25.3 with an average of 27.92 over about 12,000 miles.

300bhp/ton

41,030 posts

221 months

Tuesday 13th August 2013
quotequote all
fjord said:
I like the 320, but its just a bit boring and not much fun.
Edited by fjord on Monday 12th August 22:05
You need to ask yourself if you really believe a bit more power and an autobox will really make the same car any more fun?

Ok the E9x is bigger and more refined than the e46. So a bit more power, an autobox in something less fun and more comfy?

I'm not saying it isn't the right choice to make, but if the change in vehicle is based purely on fun factor, then I'm not sure this is the way to go.

Maybe a tidy 130i would be a better mix? MPG in the 30's and a good engine/chassis combo.

whitecobra

46 posts

182 months

Tuesday 13th August 2013
quotequote all
I went from a direct injection petrol doing 38mpg to the focus st 225 that's doing 22mpg. I've noticed going through my bank statement I'm visiting the station much more often but when I work out how much "extra" I'm using it's not that much more. Especially when you consider an equally specced car with a diesel engine would have probably cost at least £1k more that's plenty of Petrol money you've saved smile

willisit

2,188 posts

262 months

Tuesday 13th August 2013
quotequote all
Just done it myself, too. Went from a 320d to a Corsa VXR (yes, I know - they couldn't be any more dissimilar). However, it's akin to going from a bus to a Westfield.. to me anyway. I hated diesel and did 50k in one.. BMWs are lovely cars but the engines just suck the soul away. Now, I seem to have lost nothing and don't really care about the fuel. I think I'm doing mid-30s to the gallon (the diesel on a bad day) so I'm happy for now.