Buying a new car when theres no 'need'?
Buying a new car when theres no 'need'?
Author
Discussion

maxp

Original Poster:

178 posts

217 months

Tuesday 13th August 2013
quotequote all
Im 28 now, and remember when I was 'young' (17), reading about the mk5 golf gti and wanting it more than anything.

Ive got a mk1 focus (2002) 2 litre which is a fine car, and although probably worth no more than £1500, it just works (albeit abit squeaky and rough around the edges).

I can get the 7k needed for a nice model, but i've never been in a position to buy a 'new' car, when the current one is still in decent health.

I've only spoken to the other half who thinks the idea is idiotic as I should be putting the money to better use (read mortgage etc), so thought I would turn to PH for their thoughts?


Tonsko

6,299 posts

246 months

Tuesday 13th August 2013
quotequote all
Realistically, you generally only lose money on cars. So if you want to afford to lose money on a car, go buy it. If you would rather reduce your mortgage (or invest it some other way) do that. Head over heart I guess. Without wishing to sound rude, in your case it might be better to go with head.

Captain Muppet

8,540 posts

296 months

Tuesday 13th August 2013
quotequote all
If you're going to spend several thousand pounds on a car you don't need then at least pick an interesting car.

However if a mk5 GTi has been your life long dream and you don't mind your other half being smug/angry when it continues to lose money then go for it. I'm pretty sure my dream cars don't make sense to most people either.

Zed 44

1,290 posts

187 months

Tuesday 13th August 2013
quotequote all
I have a similar problem but I'm at the other end of the scale ie. retired, no financial commitments, etc. but to buy the car of my dreams - a second hand GTR would substantially wipe out half of my savings, not to mention the running costs.

My head says you're crazy. You live in an area surrounded by Nissan Micras driving slowly. Your friends collect butterflies and watch birds. And you only drive 6k miles a year.

My heart says. Time is running out.confused

Snowboy

8,028 posts

182 months

Tuesday 13th August 2013
quotequote all
If you're asking us, then you can't afford it.
Probably.

I have no idea about your salary or lifestyle.
But, I think that dropping that much money into a mundane daily drive hatch is a waste.
IMO if you want a bit of fun motoring put £1500 into a little sports car.
Mx5, mgf, etc.
You'll get a lot more fun from that, and it will cost a lot less.

maxp

Original Poster:

178 posts

217 months

Tuesday 13th August 2013
quotequote all
Snowboy said:
If you're asking us, then you can't afford it.
Probably.

I have no idea about your salary or lifestyle.
But, I think that dropping that much money into a mundane daily drive hatch is a waste.
IMO if you want a bit of fun motoring put £1500 into a little sports car.
Mx5, mgf, etc.
You'll get a lot more fun from that, and it will cost a lot less.
I have my motorbike for the real thrills, so im not too fussed about driving something thats the last word in performance.

Still, im suprised by the responses towards the mk5 gti, I thought it would be more popular on PH!

Garvin

5,667 posts

208 months

Tuesday 13th August 2013
quotequote all
This is Pistonheads. If you want sensible, value for money advice I would suggest you are on the wrong forum - try mumsnet or similar. If you want a Mk5 GTi and can afford it, go do it. As Zed 44 has said "time is running out"!

My Evil Twin

460 posts

164 months

Tuesday 13th August 2013
quotequote all
Zed 44 said:
I have a similar problem but I'm at the other end of the scale ie. retired, no financial commitments, etc. but to buy the car of my dreams - a second hand GTR would substantially wipe out half of my savings, not to mention the running costs.

My head says you're crazy. You live in an area surrounded by Nissan Micras driving slowly. Your friends collect butterflies and watch birds. And you only drive 6k miles a year.

My heart says. Time is running out.confused
obvously not knowing you or your personal situation... but if i was in a situation where I could afford to buy a car like that for cash.. and still have cash in the bank..

then do it.
even if you only keep it for 1 year.. sell it for 85% of what you paid for it.. you will still have savings..

my plan would be to retire n get a v12 E type.. but in 2 decades when i retire there prob' wont be any petrol left to run it (n it will prob be WAY out of my price range by then), but I guess I can just put it in the living room n look at it.

b0rk

2,412 posts

177 months

Wednesday 14th August 2013
quotequote all
A car that does anything more carry you and your stuff from point A to point B is a discretionary purchase if you haven't got this yet go off to mumsnet to be advised on best personal transport device. It will probably be pink with yellow spots or a Chelsea tractor.

If you have got this concept buy whatever you can afford / justify to your brain, man maths may be needed to invent justification reasons for others. Should your chariot of choice be a mk5 gti then so be it, but check the cambelt has been done and if dsg that the box has been serviced every 40k, these items will make your wallet cry if not done.

GavinPearson

5,715 posts

282 months

Wednesday 14th August 2013
quotequote all
OP - There's no 'need' to have hair cut at an expensive salon, or have mani pedis, handbags, shoes or buy the latest fashion items.

Just think how much money you could save if restraint was exercised on all of the above by the collective wives, girlfriends etc of PHers.

As cars age their reliability decreases. The art of cheap motoring is moving a car on before it becomes a money pit, that is unless you are handy with spanners and know the guys at the local breakers yard.

It's good that the 'other half' is concerned about money, but you jointly need to exercise restraint.

It's also a good idea if you buy an interesting car to let your 'other half' use it, so when you want to buy the next and better one, she's making it a priority that you get it.

Personally I wouldn't buy the 7K car, I'd keep the existing car and buy a fast and cheap weekend toy that has depreciated a lot like a Jaguar XJR. It would blow the Golf into the weeds and could also be used when the existing car goes in for repairs.

Maybe the XJR is not for you but I am sure you can find something which appeals and converts your other half to the virtues of motoring in something PHworthy.

Benbay001

5,895 posts

188 months

Wednesday 14th August 2013
quotequote all
Of all cars marketed as "sporty" i cant think of many id rather own less than a fast Golf.

Wait, what is the quick version of the X6 called?

meggysaurus

227 posts

166 months

Wednesday 14th August 2013
quotequote all
Could always buy a snotter an turn it into a cheap track day car like TG

Xaero

4,063 posts

246 months

Wednesday 14th August 2013
quotequote all
Why not rent one, or take a few for a test drive, and see if it lives up to expectation?

Of course it might exceed expectation and encourage you to buy, so maybe not hehe

SidewaysSi

10,742 posts

265 months

Wednesday 14th August 2013
quotequote all
I am only slightly older than you and have justified 3 cars, none of which I need. If you crave a Golf, just get it. They are very sensible and pretty cheap so its hardly like you are going too crazy. 7k added to the mortgage will do bugger all anyway...And yes, a GTI is very fine but not the last word in PHNess!

Mound Dawg

1,931 posts

205 months

Wednesday 14th August 2013
quotequote all
When I was young and stupid I wanted a Chevy Camaro and found myself with enough money to buy one. A girl I worked with told me that buying one was a good idea because in 5 years time I'd have kids/house etc. so if I didn't do it then I'd regret it forever. I'll never know if she was right because I did buy one, drove it for 18 months and didn't regret it for a minute.

Life isn't a rehearsal, you don't get another "go" when it's over so you need to do things when you get the chance.

But a Mk5 Golf? Seriously?

Escy

4,132 posts

180 months

Wednesday 14th August 2013
quotequote all
Just get one, life's too short and it's not like it's a crazy car to get. Even if you only own it 6 months and then sell to put the money into a mortgage. Better to have owned one briefly

jamieduff1981

8,092 posts

171 months

Wednesday 14th August 2013
quotequote all
As above - it's your life and nobody knows your own finances as you do. If a Golf is genuinely your dream car and you can afford it then crack on.

Ultimately a Golf is just an ordinary modern heavy hatchback though, so the PH reception towards them perhaps isn't quite what some would expect. Good enough car for what the base model is, but the "sporty" ones aren't very sporty. I guess a Golf doesn't really qualify as dream material for many people though?

Still, as dream cars go it's very attainable and I think many could envy that aspect, so if you don't mind spending the money, go for it.

philmots

4,666 posts

291 months

Wednesday 14th August 2013
quotequote all
Depends how much you've got...

If 7k is half your mortgage deposit then don't do it.. If you can spend the 7k and still have a nice deposit then do it.

Remember if its your dream car you'll always be buying bits for it to keep it nice.. Eg new bits of trim, new mats, wheel refurb etc. all adds up!

SidewaysSi

10,742 posts

265 months

Wednesday 14th August 2013
quotequote all
Escy said:
Just get one, life's too short and it's not like it's a crazy car to get. Even if you only own it 6 months and then sell to put the money into a mortgage. Better to have owned one briefly
My problem with owning a car for a period is the inevitable withdrawal symptoms when it is gone. Unless you replace it with something better, you will have feelings of regret, sad
ness and incurable misery..

deltashad

6,731 posts

228 months

Wednesday 14th August 2013
quotequote all
If you want something in life then you have to strive to get it.

That's why we work. Without goals and dreams we would al be a bit boring.