Has the mid-powered petrol been squeezed out of the market?
Discussion
So I've noticed recently the majority of new cars sold seem to fit in the following categories:
- The entry level petrol, because its the cheapest to buy
- The diesel, because its the cheapest to run
- The performance petrol, because its the fastest
Now that's all well and good but to me it seems the mid-power petrol models simply aren't selling, and this appears to be reflected in the used market. If you think about it when was the last time you saw a new-ish BMW 328i, Golf GT TSI or Monedo 2.0 Ecoboost? Is there no market for these models and will they soon be extinct? It seems a shame given the ammount of development that goes into them. I suspect its just a UK thing but interested to hear what others think.
- The entry level petrol, because its the cheapest to buy
- The diesel, because its the cheapest to run
- The performance petrol, because its the fastest
Now that's all well and good but to me it seems the mid-power petrol models simply aren't selling, and this appears to be reflected in the used market. If you think about it when was the last time you saw a new-ish BMW 328i, Golf GT TSI or Monedo 2.0 Ecoboost? Is there no market for these models and will they soon be extinct? It seems a shame given the ammount of development that goes into them. I suspect its just a UK thing but interested to hear what others think.
It also doesn't help that the people who can afford brand new cars will also be regularly watching the scaremongering on the news about how prices with escalate indefinitely meaning that a large percentage of people will naturally opt for the cheap to run "safe" diesel.
Also at this moment in time people are terrified of losing money on anything they buy in case they need to sell it and Diesels, due to their reputation would hold their value better.
As you say the market has almost been broken down into the 3 market types that you describe. This might also be partially down to the advances in Diesel engines over the last decade or so, which now means that the performance gap between the Diesels and the mid-range petrol's is not as big as it once was, so the diesel cars are now seen as a much healthier compromise between performance and economy.
Also at this moment in time people are terrified of losing money on anything they buy in case they need to sell it and Diesels, due to their reputation would hold their value better.
As you say the market has almost been broken down into the 3 market types that you describe. This might also be partially down to the advances in Diesel engines over the last decade or so, which now means that the performance gap between the Diesels and the mid-range petrol's is not as big as it once was, so the diesel cars are now seen as a much healthier compromise between performance and economy.
I think Dave7692 nailed it. No matter how well off you are (trust fund types excluded) you'd be in a very rare group to want a mid-size petrol with your own cash.
Big Petrol Barges have the stigma (?) of losing cash faster than there diesel brethren.
The performance v economy debate is stacked in the favour of diesels (Our next daily will be a diesel)
Plus you’re kind of stumped by what’s in the market. For every 530D \ 535D you'll find 1000's of 520D's (I imagine this is due to them being the most tax efficient for company buyers).
It's a shame as I'd love to try the 328 as I reckon it would be a great successor to the 330i
Outside of an AMG I can't recall the last time I saw a petrol C class.
Big Petrol Barges have the stigma (?) of losing cash faster than there diesel brethren.
The performance v economy debate is stacked in the favour of diesels (Our next daily will be a diesel)
Plus you’re kind of stumped by what’s in the market. For every 530D \ 535D you'll find 1000's of 520D's (I imagine this is due to them being the most tax efficient for company buyers).
It's a shame as I'd love to try the 328 as I reckon it would be a great successor to the 330i
Outside of an AMG I can't recall the last time I saw a petrol C class.
It's a good point OP, take for example the BMW F20 1-series... if you wanted something cheaper to run you'd get a 118d or 120d, if you wanted the fast petrol you'd get the M135i. The 125i doesn't really fit as it's not that much cheaper than the M135i if you want the petrol, and much more uneconomical to run than the d if you want something economic to run.
i fear you right its combination of
tuning options
pricing structure
statistics(economy performance tax insurance)
on the BMW angle they make a 118 petrol as well another rare engine the 125d until recently was quite rare
im sure ive read alot of these engines are purely down to a map no doubt many map them as its cheaper then buying that output to start with
tuning options
pricing structure
statistics(economy performance tax insurance)
on the BMW angle they make a 118 petrol as well another rare engine the 125d until recently was quite rare
im sure ive read alot of these engines are purely down to a map no doubt many map them as its cheaper then buying that output to start with
I would have to say yes. I hardly ever see any petrol cars at all unless they are performance models or 15+ years old. I can see why people make the decision to buy diesel due lower road tax and higher (official) mpg for a given performance level. The average new car buyer doesn't know or care about the downsides (horrible noise, nasty smoky exhaust, heavy front end, dubious long term reliability and horrifically expensive parts, slower warm up etc etc) and doesn't drive in a manner where petrol power would give any advantage so for them the argument is very one sided.
For the used car buyer this poses a conundrum as in a few years there will be hardly any petrol cars under 15 years old available to buy and I don't think that buying a diesel with all the expensive gubbins to go wrong is a financial viable idea.
For the used car buyer this poses a conundrum as in a few years there will be hardly any petrol cars under 15 years old available to buy and I don't think that buying a diesel with all the expensive gubbins to go wrong is a financial viable idea.
Its a depressing topic.
Speaking as someone who regularly buys at the "slightly above a shed" price range, you can see even at this point in the market there is a lack of anything mid range and petrol.
The diesel car has spread its sooty tentacles down here too I'm afraid.
Its a shame because I quite fancy a mid range petrol E60 5 series, maybe next year. They seem a lot of car for the money provided you can find one....
Speaking as someone who regularly buys at the "slightly above a shed" price range, you can see even at this point in the market there is a lack of anything mid range and petrol.
The diesel car has spread its sooty tentacles down here too I'm afraid.
Its a shame because I quite fancy a mid range petrol E60 5 series, maybe next year. They seem a lot of car for the money provided you can find one....
I think one of the major reasons there are so few mid range petrols about is because a lot of new cars seem to be company cars or leased, which tends to limit your choices. Leasing rates also tend to be the best/ most competative for diesels, so more get rented out.
For what it's worth, both of my parents have mid range petrols (Mazda 6 and Mondeo 2.0), so there are some about.
For what it's worth, both of my parents have mid range petrols (Mazda 6 and Mondeo 2.0), so there are some about.
Yup, you're not wrong.
I'm one of the very few to buy a new F30 gen 328i petrol.
Owing to a change in jobs, I'll be doing a lot more mileage so probably reaching threshold where a derv becomes sensible.
To sum it up, dealers (including BMW) don't really want to touch my petrol BMW with a bargepole! Not liquid stock was how one dealer referred to it!
I'm one of the very few to buy a new F30 gen 328i petrol.
Owing to a change in jobs, I'll be doing a lot more mileage so probably reaching threshold where a derv becomes sensible.
To sum it up, dealers (including BMW) don't really want to touch my petrol BMW with a bargepole! Not liquid stock was how one dealer referred to it!
A lex said:
Only in the UK.
In a lot of places in continental Europe the car tax regime is the opposite to the UK, with diesel being punitively charged.
Therefore the majority of private sales go to petrol models, with the spread right across the range.
We have a MINI Cooper, it sits right in the middle of the petrol engine range power wise.
2.0TSi VAGs are ten a penny, much more so than the TDi variants.
This is interesting. How does it work? Do they still look at CO2 emissions but then slap on an extra diesel tax? In a lot of places in continental Europe the car tax regime is the opposite to the UK, with diesel being punitively charged.
Therefore the majority of private sales go to petrol models, with the spread right across the range.
We have a MINI Cooper, it sits right in the middle of the petrol engine range power wise.
2.0TSi VAGs are ten a penny, much more so than the TDi variants.
On what basis do they justify it? Particulate/soot etc issues in built areas or something?
I think the OP is spot on - the fact is (in the UK at least), for the vast majority of new car buyers the modern diesel, exemplified by the 320d/520d, is plenty punchy enough, with great fuel economy and low running costs. Virtually no-one will buy a petrol unless you're after the hot models.
A great shame for used car buyers in the UK in year to come.
Petrol cars will come to be quite sought after and relatively expensive just because they'll be so f
king rare!V88Dicky said:
There were 3, manual 3.0 X-types for sale in the entire UK (under 60k miles), when I bought mine back in March. Well worth the search and travel mind you! 
I'd imagine it's the manual bit of that, rather than the petrol that resulted in the rarity. X-Type 3 litre is an excellent car though. 
braddo said:
I think the OP is spot on - the fact is (in the UK at least), for the vast majority of new car buyers the modern diesel, exemplified by the 320d/520d, is plenty punchy enough, with great fuel economy and low running costs. Virtually no-one will buy a petrol unless you're after the hot models.
People are interested in saving a few quid on road tax, but perhaps many aren't aware their journey patterns don't suit the diesel they've bought. My commute is only about 5 miles now and I do a lot of town driving during the week. I don't actually mind diesel but am aware of the issues so I'm considering a newish petrol estate with a bit of go. Octavia VRS estate is about the only optionI can see that isn't too expensive to run or too weedy, but there are very few around. 320i BMW is more common for example but is on the gutless side and doesn't have good reliability record.
A lot of new cars now are leased too (mine included). Generally lease companies lease diesels cheaper than petrols. I currently run a Ibiza FR 1.6TDI as a daily. The petrol 1.2 TSI would have been £50 a month more to lease, use more fuel and be no faster.
In non performance cars I hate to admit it but I'm a diesel convert.
That said my next car will be a quick petrol when I'm financially better off.
In non performance cars I hate to admit it but I'm a diesel convert.
That said my next car will be a quick petrol when I'm financially better off.
Gassing Station | General Gassing | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


