Fully comprehensive cover for a test drive?
Discussion
I was browsing the classifieds for a particular make and model of car that the wife is looking to buy, and saw a decent looking example of one up for about the right sort of money (but no cheaper than comparable examples from dealers). Reading further into the spec all looked pretty good. But in the description the seller has said that he will entertain test drives only with proof of fully comprehensive insurance, and that third party is not acceptable.
The car is not hugely valuable <£10k, and this set me to thinking. Is this standard practice? Can you get single day test drive cover, and if so how much is it as a percentage of an annual policy? Or is the seller just being overly picky? TBH, as potential buyers, I suspect that this has put us off making the journey to see it.
The car is not hugely valuable <£10k, and this set me to thinking. Is this standard practice? Can you get single day test drive cover, and if so how much is it as a percentage of an annual policy? Or is the seller just being overly picky? TBH, as potential buyers, I suspect that this has put us off making the journey to see it.
Your own insurers might temporarily extend your policy onto another car, I had this once when my car was off the road long-term for warranty work & the manufacturer supplied a rental car but no insurance. Mine charged me a £16 documentation charge to issue the paperwork but that was it.
Does this not mean:
You need fully comp insurance on your own car, so your policy covers you 3rd Party on another fully insure vehicle? Providing you're over 25 years old, this is usually the case.
If you only had 3rd party insurance on your own policy, this wouldn't cover you to drive another persons car and be covered by your insurance?
I might be wrong, but its rather unusual for your own insurance company to cover you fully comp on another vehicle that's not your own?
You need fully comp insurance on your own car, so your policy covers you 3rd Party on another fully insure vehicle? Providing you're over 25 years old, this is usually the case.
If you only had 3rd party insurance on your own policy, this wouldn't cover you to drive another persons car and be covered by your insurance?
I might be wrong, but its rather unusual for your own insurance company to cover you fully comp on another vehicle that's not your own?
I would take it to mean fully comprehensive cover for the car you are testing. So the seller won't be out of pocket if you smash up his car on the test drive.
It is possible to arrange 1 day cover online with Avivva - I did this recently when I purchased an MR2. It cost £30 and also covered me to drive the car home.
It is possible to arrange 1 day cover online with Avivva - I did this recently when I purchased an MR2. It cost £30 and also covered me to drive the car home.
Ephraim said:
The car is not hugely valuable <£10k, and this set me to thinking. Is this standard practice? Can you get single day test drive cover, and if so how much is it as a percentage of an annual policy? Or is the seller just being overly picky? TBH, as potential buyers, I suspect that this has put us off making the journey to see it.
As a car owner yourself, I take it, how much of your own money would you be prepared to pay on your own car that someone else has crashed? 8k?, 4k?, 2k? £500?I'd guess you don't want to pay a penny of your own money out so hence the reason for fully comp insurance on a test drive.
CallorFold said:
Does this not mean:
You need fully comp insurance on your own car, so your policy covers you 3rd Party on another fully insure vehicle? Providing you're over 25 years old, this is usually the case.
If you only had 3rd party insurance on your own policy, this wouldn't cover you to drive another persons car and be covered by your insurance?
I might be wrong, but its rather unusual for your own insurance company to cover you fully comp on another vehicle that's not your own?
The seller specifically said that third party cover on his car from a comprehensive policy would not be acceptable.You need fully comp insurance on your own car, so your policy covers you 3rd Party on another fully insure vehicle? Providing you're over 25 years old, this is usually the case.
If you only had 3rd party insurance on your own policy, this wouldn't cover you to drive another persons car and be covered by your insurance?
I might be wrong, but its rather unusual for your own insurance company to cover you fully comp on another vehicle that's not your own?
no effort said:
As a car owner yourself, I take it, how much of your own money would you be prepared to pay on your own car that someone else has crashed? 8k?, 4k?, 2k? £500?
I'd guess you don't want to pay a penny of your own money out so hence the reason for fully comp insurance on a test drive.
I have, in the past, allowed potential buyers to test drive my cars with proof of third party insurance. Obviously, I would be annoyed if they then smashed my car to smithereens and walked away; but I accept that as one of the pitfalls of a private sale. I'd guess you don't want to pay a penny of your own money out so hence the reason for fully comp insurance on a test drive.
The vendor in this case, is totally at liberty to set whatever pre-requisites he wishes on test drives in his car, and was good enough to state the case in his ad, thus saving us all some wasted time. But i was curious as to whether this was a common thing these days, as it's the first time I've ever seen it.
no effort said:
As a car owner yourself, I take it, how much of your own money would you be prepared to pay on your own car that someone else has crashed? 8k?, 4k?, 2k? £500?
I'd guess you don't want to pay a penny of your own money out so hence the reason for fully comp insurance on a test drive.
I understand why people might wish for a buyer to have fully comprehensive cover, but to be honest if you are of this mindset then I suspect you'd be better of PXing your car instead.I'd guess you don't want to pay a penny of your own money out so hence the reason for fully comp insurance on a test drive.
Unless you have a hugely desirable/expensive model, placing a restriction like this is going to limit who will view the car and make it more difficult to sell.
Devil2575 said:
Out of interest, does anyone have any experience, either directly or through someone they know of a car being crashed on a test drive?
Yep....but with the owner behind the wheel!!! A colleague of mine was viewing an S2000 when the owner lost control on a slip road joining the A13. Fair bit of damage sustained.
...Needless to say he didn't buy it

Not applicable as (you'd assume) the owner was insured, but an amusing story nonetheless.
People seem to do it with bikes allot. Personally I don't want to spend £40-£50 getting insurance on a car I may not want to buy, so I don't touch them.
If people want to do that its up to them but personally I would just ask them if they had some insurance (to cover me legally) and leave it at that. If someone crashed my car it's up to them to sort out the payment. Much easier to sue them for any damage if they don't pay than have to fanny about with a third parties insurance company.
If people want to do that its up to them but personally I would just ask them if they had some insurance (to cover me legally) and leave it at that. If someone crashed my car it's up to them to sort out the payment. Much easier to sue them for any damage if they don't pay than have to fanny about with a third parties insurance company.
When I sold my 330i and my 944 I wanted to see proof of 3rd party insurance but the purchasers had a Z3 2.8i and a Maserati 3200 GT respectively, so I was reasonably confident they could drive.
When I sold my Z4 M Coupe I insisted on fully comprehensive insurance and I gave some suggestions in my advert about who to use and offered to knock the cost of the insurance off the asking price (up to £100) if they bought. This has the very desirable effect of weeding out the idiots who want to turn up, drive your car to help them make a decision and buy something else entirely.
As it goes, the very nice (M3 owning) chap that bought it was happy to do so without even driving it. So the first time he drove it was once the money was in my bank. It had full BMW warranty though, so he probably felt confident in the event of any issues.
If you are serious about buying a car a day's worth of insurance is small price to pay to a) get a decent length of test drive and b) cover yourself from being sued. You could get rear ended while stationary - who pays then if you don't have insurance? As a result I bought insurance for my recent Alpina purchase which I then just extended to cover me for a year. Easy.
I'm surprised more people don't ask for it to be honest.
When I sold my Z4 M Coupe I insisted on fully comprehensive insurance and I gave some suggestions in my advert about who to use and offered to knock the cost of the insurance off the asking price (up to £100) if they bought. This has the very desirable effect of weeding out the idiots who want to turn up, drive your car to help them make a decision and buy something else entirely.
As it goes, the very nice (M3 owning) chap that bought it was happy to do so without even driving it. So the first time he drove it was once the money was in my bank. It had full BMW warranty though, so he probably felt confident in the event of any issues.
If you are serious about buying a car a day's worth of insurance is small price to pay to a) get a decent length of test drive and b) cover yourself from being sued. You could get rear ended while stationary - who pays then if you don't have insurance? As a result I bought insurance for my recent Alpina purchase which I then just extended to cover me for a year. Easy.
I'm surprised more people don't ask for it to be honest.
I tried to get a day's cover to test drive the Cerb on my daily driver policy which is with Direct Line.
They refused on the basis that the owner had a policy for that car and I would need to be added as a temporary named driver to his policy.
They did not want anything to do with the prospect of a crash and uncertain liabilities between 2 policies on the same car. I don't have any experience of other insurers who will insure another car which is already insured under another policy.
They refused on the basis that the owner had a policy for that car and I would need to be added as a temporary named driver to his policy.
They did not want anything to do with the prospect of a crash and uncertain liabilities between 2 policies on the same car. I don't have any experience of other insurers who will insure another car which is already insured under another policy.
Gassing Station | General Gassing | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


