Why do we tolerate unnecessary roadworks in the UK?
Why do we tolerate unnecessary roadworks in the UK?
Author
Discussion

Perec

Original Poster:

28,176 posts

253 months

Wednesday 14th August 2013
quotequote all
Waiting for the umpteenth time at three-way temporary traffic controls in Radcliffe on Trent today I pondered why there had been, for two days, a small hole in the pavement, with no one working in it, and three-way controls causing delays. So I called Severn Trent Water, whose number was on the signage.

"Oh that's because we haven't got round to filling the hole in yet", came the reply, "the work's all done, but we just haven't backfilled the hole".

So I suggested they do it sooner rather than later, due to the delays being caused by the temporary lights.

An hour and a half later a man with a shovel and some tarmac rocked up to finish the work.

Roll on six o clock tonight and the traffic controls were still there, traffic backing up a mile onto the main A52, so I called again.

"Those aren't our road works" was the reply this time.

"Yes they are, which is why your number is on the signage and why you sent someone out to finish them off after I called this morning", I replied.

"Oh, we'll look into it", said Severn Trent.

Ten minutes ago, I got a call back: "You're right, they are our works and we'll pick up the lights tonight. They'll be gone by morning, thanks for bringing it to our attention".

Now, it was quite apparent that no one else had bothered taking Severn Trent to task. But how many hours have all those queuing people had wasted over the past two days? How many times is this sort of thing repeated across the UK every day?

It seems that road users are extremely non-questioning; they see temporary lights and assume they should be there and that the body responsible for putting them there is on the ball. Often this is not the case. We must lose millions of hours nationally every year because utility companies and others digging up the road cannot be bothered to finish work quickly and restore traffic flow as soon as possible. When we are trying to get the economy back on track and our roads are as busy as they are becoming, having lazy and incompetent people in control of road works and traffic controls is not something we can afford.



Fozziebear

1,840 posts

171 months

Wednesday 14th August 2013
quotequote all
I give it a week until they return. It took them a week to fix the collapsed manhole cover on the same stretch a few months back. Just wait till the school holidays finish, I'm sure the RSPCA junction needs redoing wink the sooner they dual the stretch from saxondale to Gamston the better

kooky guy

582 posts

197 months

Thursday 15th August 2013
quotequote all
This is one of my pet hates. There is a particular stretch of road of road on my route to work that seems to be dug up by Southern gas networks on an almost monthly basis.

First the gang comes out (at least a day in advance of the digging up crew) to set up the temporary lights, making sure to make to disable the traffic sensors and set them to completely counter the normal flows of traffic.

Eventually a small hole appears, although nobody is ever seen doing anything to it, although you might occasionally see a van parked there with a couple of sleeping workmen in it, presumably to guard the hole.

Eventually the hole will be filled in and usually a couple of days later the traffic lights will be moved to a site a bit further down the road where the process will be repeated.

It does seem to be the making good gang that seem to be the slowest part of this process. It wouldn't be so bad if they could set the temporary traffic lights up properly.

Grr.

iphonedyou

10,425 posts

188 months

Thursday 15th August 2013
quotequote all
OP, I doubt it was your phone call that made them act. Just coincidence that they happened to backfill and remove lights when they did.

Captain Muppet

8,540 posts

296 months

Thursday 15th August 2013
quotequote all
iphonedyou said:
OP, I doubt it was your phone call that made them act. Just coincidence that they happened to backfill and remove lights when they did.
What?

Perec said:
Ten minutes ago, I got a call back: "You're right, they are our works and we'll pick up the lights tonight. They'll be gone by morning, thanks for bringing it to our attention".

Lawbags

1,074 posts

159 months

Thursday 15th August 2013
quotequote all
I can't work out how they prioritise re-surfacing etc.
I mean, local to me, one of the roads is so bad that for about 100yards, you can't really drive as close to the kerb as you should. It's been like this for so long,that moss etc is growing, and grass is coming up through the cracks and pot holes.
In rush hour, there is normally about 10-15 cars queued up to pass it

Yet half a mile away, a bit of road that was pretty flawless and smooth, has been properly re-done. Not just this scattering of stones they usually do, but a full blown dig up and re-tarmac.

Makes no sense to me!

Perec

Original Poster:

28,176 posts

253 months

Thursday 15th August 2013
quotequote all
iphonedyou said:
OP, I doubt it was your phone call that made them act. Just coincidence that they happened to backfill and remove lights when they did.
I think it was my phone call that got the hole back-filled and I know it was my call that got the lights removed (though to be fair I haven't been that way today so haven't checked they've gone).

It isn't the first time this has happened. On several previous occasions I have chased up utility companies whose road works were causing me delays and they have sorted it out swiftly. The last time some temporary traffic lights were set to be left up over a bank holiday weekend, on the main exit from our village. I called up the emergency number, who contacted the regional manager chap who agreed to get them removed. They were gone within a couple of hours (about 9pm on the Friday as I recall).

I am not sure what impact it would have if more people bothered to chase these things up. It might make the road works disappear quicker, but then it might make matters worse. At present the companies seem quite taken aback when I call them, if it happened all the time perhaps they would become desensitised to it.





anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 15th August 2013
quotequote all
"Land closed to protect workforce" - what.....at 3am?
fking liars.

Prawo Jazdy

5,037 posts

245 months

Thursday 15th August 2013
quotequote all
I read an article yawning on about how congestion causes delays and costs millions, and managed motorways will prevent this. Unfortunately, managed motorway installation makes delays an absolute certainty, and also costs millions.

TameRacingDriver

20,663 posts

303 months

Thursday 15th August 2013
quotequote all
These temporary lights have been spreading like cancer here in the Newcastle area. It seems almost impossible to complete a journey now without these god forsaken things. Never any fker doing any work either.

I remember one journey I did late at night about 3 weeks ago, I encountered no fewer than 5 sets on one journey, as well as roadworks on the main dual carriageway, result = journey that should have taken 20 minutes took double, at 11pm.

I fking hate traffic lights anyway, but by the end of that journey I almost had to be stopped by Mrs TRD from deliberately plowing into one with my car.

I bet the councils love them though, they like installing traffic lights when not needed and increasing journey times, so they'll love this, the tree-hugging, car-hating wkers.

Driving in this country is, 90% of the time, deeply unpleasant IMO.

hedges88

690 posts

176 months

Thursday 15th August 2013
quotequote all
I worked for 2 years in an industrial estate in St Albans (Valley road for anyone who knows it)

Everyone in the office complained daily about how bad the road surface was leading to and on the estate, massive cracks and potholes wrecking all of our cars.

So I did the unthinkable that no man had done before (in our office at least!) and I called the highways agency. They gave me a reference number so I could keep checking on the progress. Within 4 months the entire road had been resurfaced!!

Im sure they had more calls than just mine, but ringing and letting them know was worth it IMHO

It's probably the same with roadworks that are unfinished or appear to not be progressing, just give them a call like the OP

forzaminardi

2,298 posts

218 months

Thursday 15th August 2013
quotequote all
Old story here - people might have a legitimate complaint, but instead of taking positive action and wondering what might help solve the problem, too often they prefer to just moan about it to each other and online.

Well done to the OP and others piping up for taking the initiative!