2 garages, 2 shots each - still not fixed.
2 garages, 2 shots each - still not fixed.
Author
Discussion

Idontdrinkrsmoke

Original Poster:

126 posts

167 months

Wednesday 14th August 2013
quotequote all
Rotational rubbing noise from rear wheel.

I'm not looking for PH'ers to solve my problem I just want a bit of a moan.

Am I being unrealistic to expect this sort of issue to sorted fairly quickly by a qualified mechanic? Or is 4 attempts by 2 different mechanics considered acceptable?


Northernchimp

1,282 posts

163 months

Wednesday 14th August 2013
quotequote all
I did 20k with a drone nobody could diagnose on one corner, I was convinced it was a bearing. Routine tyre replacement and it went away. There was nothing visibly wrong with the tyre. Could literally be anything, or a tyre.

poing

8,743 posts

231 months

Wednesday 14th August 2013
quotequote all
Are they independent garages or marque specialists?

My local independent is great but I sometimes do some research myself if it's a slightly tricky problem and because they know me they listen and have a look. Sometimes though going to a specialist for that make of car can solve those tricky little issues that are unique to that car.

CB2152

1,555 posts

164 months

Wednesday 14th August 2013
quotequote all
Brake backplate? Some things can be a nightmare to diagnose, even for a specialist...

V8RX7

28,982 posts

294 months

Wednesday 14th August 2013
quotequote all
I'd say it depends what they are charging you.


rallycross

13,763 posts

268 months

Wednesday 14th August 2013
quotequote all
Look at
Wheel bearing ( noise will go away when loading/ turning on the other side)
Sticky brake calliper - test with foot gently on brake or hand brake
Tyre - directional tread pattern tyres often go off on rear, and 50p shape hard to see
Disk backing plate - corroded and leans against hub/disk on the corners

405dogvan

5,329 posts

296 months

Wednesday 14th August 2013
quotequote all
The problem a garage has, is...

1 - working-out what the problem MIGHT be based on your not entirely amazing description
2 - not spending your money on solutions which don't work because you'll get shirty-as-hell

Noises are, by far and away, the mechanics worst nightmare. People bring in cars which are 'buzzing' and 'rattling' and 'wubbing' and 'clinking' all the time, as if their vague and subjective description will somehow make a mechanic go "ah - that's your tramshins then".

What garages tend to do, based on your description of the noise, is safety inspect the car for possible worn/damaged/loose bits which might be causing the issue. That way, even if they don't solve the noise problem, they were jobs which needed doing anyway.

By doing that they can also say "we've checked your car and there is nothing obviously wrong - drive it some more and see if it's still there/gets worse - then maybe we can take another look".

Example: I know someone who took a car to a dealer 7 times for "a funny noise coming from the back of the car". The car was inspected more than twice, had it's rear brakes done, tyres rotated and a few other bits and bobs - the noise was still there, apparently.

So finally a mechanic was sent-out with the owner for a 1 hour test drive - during which the owner repeatedly referred to the noise. The mechanic could not hear a thing.

Then the owner turned-off their hearing aid...

Idontdrinkrsmoke

Original Poster:

126 posts

167 months

Wednesday 14th August 2013
quotequote all
CB2152 said:
Brake backplate? Some things can be a nightmare to diagnose, even for a specialist...
Yeah maybe I'm being a bit harsh. Suggestions from the garages have been:

brakes need cleaned
disc has a high spot
back plate
inboard shoes
wheel bearing

First 4 have either been done or ruled out so we are on to wheel bearing now for my next visit. Can't say I'm convinced.

VinceFox

20,566 posts

203 months

Wednesday 14th August 2013
quotequote all
Swap your wheels front to back.

Idontdrinkrsmoke

Original Poster:

126 posts

167 months

Wednesday 14th August 2013
quotequote all
[quote=405dogvan]The problem a garage has, is...

1 - working-out what the problem MIGHT be based on your not entirely amazing description
2 - not spending your money on solutions which don't work because you'll get shirty-as-hell

Noises are, by far and away, the mechanics worst nightmare. People bring in cars which are 'buzzing' and 'rattling' and 'wubbing' and 'clinking' all the time, as if their vague and subjective description will somehow make a mechanic go "ah - that's your tramshins then".

Fair point.

Although my noise can actually be heard by jacking the car up and spinning the wheel so each mechanic has been able to hear the problem for themselves.

VinceFox

20,566 posts

203 months

Wednesday 14th August 2013
quotequote all
Idontdrinkrsmoke said:
405dogvan said:
The problem a garage has, is...

1 - working-out what the problem MIGHT be based on your not entirely amazing description
2 - not spending your money on solutions which don't work because you'll get shirty-as-hell

Noises are, by far and away, the mechanics worst nightmare. People bring in cars which are 'buzzing' and 'rattling' and 'wubbing' and 'clinking' all the time, as if their vague and subjective description will somehow make a mechanic go "ah - that's your tramshins then".

Fair point.

Although my noise can actually be heard by jacking the car up and spinning the wheel so each mechanic has been able to hear the problem for themselves.
Hmm.

Car, year?

Idontdrinkrsmoke

Original Poster:

126 posts

167 months

Wednesday 14th August 2013
quotequote all
2003 BMW 320i sport touring

s m

24,494 posts

234 months

Wednesday 14th August 2013
quotequote all
Idontdrinkrsmoke said:
2003 BMW 320i sport touring
Handbrake mechanism has come away from backplate as the securing pins pulled through?

VinceFox

20,566 posts

203 months

Wednesday 14th August 2013
quotequote all
Just one side? If you take the wheel off and spin the hub does it still do it?

Most obvious is brakes but presumably this has been exhausted.

Idontdrinkrsmoke

Original Poster:

126 posts

167 months

Wednesday 14th August 2013
quotequote all
s m said:
Handbrake mechanism has come away from backplate as the securing pins pulled through?
Might be worth a look as handbrake feels a bit loose.

VinceFox

20,566 posts

203 months

Wednesday 14th August 2013
quotequote all
Idontdrinkrsmoke said:
s m said:
Handbrake mechanism has come away from backplate as the securing pins pulled through?
Might be worth a look as handbrake feels a bit loose.
That's a good call actually. Not sure why a garage wouldn't find that though.

Idontdrinkrsmoke

Original Poster:

126 posts

167 months

Wednesday 14th August 2013
quotequote all
VinceFox said:
Just one side? If you take the wheel off and spin the hub does it still do it?

Most obvious is brakes but presumably this has been exhausted.
Just one side and noise is still there when wheel is off and hub is spun.

s m

24,494 posts

234 months

Wednesday 14th August 2013
quotequote all
VinceFox said:
Idontdrinkrsmoke said:
s m said:
Handbrake mechanism has come away from backplate as the securing pins pulled through?
Might be worth a look as handbrake feels a bit loose.
That's a good call actually. Not sure why a garage wouldn't find that though.
It's quite common as the slot holes in the backplates enlarge with wear/rust and the pins can't hold all the handbrake flush to the backplate. The shoes then twist inside the 'top hat' part of the rear disc and rub as the disc rotates

Idontdrinkrsmoke

Original Poster:

126 posts

167 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
Idontdrinkrsmoke said:
Yeah maybe I'm being a bit harsh. Suggestions from the garages have been:

brakes need cleaned
disc has a high spot
back plate
inboard shoes
wheel bearing

First 4 have either been done or ruled out so we are on to wheel bearing now for my next visit. Can't say I'm convinced.
FFS! Car was in for wheel bearing today - apparently my driveshaft is fecked too! If this is a wind-up it's worked - big high fives all round, you got me.