A 7k E46 M3 - Will much come close?
A 7k E46 M3 - Will much come close?
Author
Discussion

APanda

Original Poster:

1,391 posts

178 months

Thursday 15th August 2013
quotequote all
It's that time again. I've been procrastinating/browsing the classifieds for the last couple of months (as I'm sure most of us do) and have finally decided I will replace my stop-gap car with a proper one that I'll hopefully keep for a while.

Originally I was looking at 3.0 Z4's and Boxster S' but for whatever reason there's something they lack but I can't quite put my finger on what that 'something' is. Anyone else know what I mean?

I know it will be tough to get this for £7000 but I think I've found it in an E46 M3 Coupé.

In my head, I can't think of anything else that comes close for performance, etc etc. I'm not saying there isn't, I'm open to all options at the moment.

So, will someone please prove me wrong for £7000?

I'll add: I'll only do about 5k a year in it so it's really a toy that'll go to the odd meeting a couple of times a month. The tricky bit is convincing the OH that a 340BHP RWD machine is a reasonable car. And sorry this is another what car thread biggrin.

Prof Prolapse

16,163 posts

221 months

Thursday 15th August 2013
quotequote all
I honestly don't think much does. A friend was trying to get me to buy one on Saturday for this reason. Read a buyers guide and get it bought.


Crusoe

4,126 posts

262 months

Thursday 15th August 2013
quotequote all
ppp pack subaru and higher power evo's are faster on your average uk road if speed is what you are after.

Honestherbert

592 posts

178 months

Thursday 15th August 2013
quotequote all
Lots of jap turbo stuff but the bm will be a better everyday car smile they do most things well but not what I would want as a weekend fun car. I guess it depends what your main areas are that you want in a car? outright speed or sts n giggles? practicality? etc etc..

Codswallop

5,260 posts

225 months

Thursday 15th August 2013
quotequote all


Monaro.

It's a different kind of fun to an M3, and has a V8.

J4CKO

47,108 posts

231 months

Thursday 15th August 2013
quotequote all
Im in a similar quandary, always wanted an M3 but have found the delights of open top motoring, I like the Z4 Cab, I like the M3 Coupe but want an open top, I think the M3 Coupe looks a bit of a Dogs Dinner and the Z4M is too expensive to buy and run.


Eddh

4,656 posts

223 months

Thursday 15th August 2013
quotequote all
E39 M5.

JackReacher

2,293 posts

246 months

Thursday 15th August 2013
quotequote all
A 350Z gets close but isn't quite there. I went for one over a E46 M3 as I was put off by the far higher running costs and also the fact that finding a tidy M3 at around £7k was not going to be an easy task.

Contigo

3,141 posts

240 months

Thursday 15th August 2013
quotequote all
Codswallop said:


Monaro.

It's a different kind of fun to an M3, and has a V8.
Not as good chassis though is it.

MikeyMike

587 posts

232 months

Thursday 15th August 2013
quotequote all
Plenty that will match or even surpass the M3 in terms of performance at that price point but I can't think of anything that combines the M3's combination of performance, practicality, quality of build and finish and dare I say it kudos/image, other than a 996 Carrera. But I dare say a 7k e46 M3 is probably a more reliable prospect than a 7k 911.

It's on my shortlist along with the e39 M5.

Coldfuse

518 posts

225 months

Thursday 15th August 2013
quotequote all
I'm fairly sure that the 350Z and the M3 are in different leagues...

APanda

Original Poster:

1,391 posts

178 months

Thursday 15th August 2013
quotequote all
Codswallop said:


Monaro.

It's a different kind of fun to an M3, and has a V8.
This was something I've been thinking about a little but didn't look into that much. When you say a different sort of fun, what do you mean?


J4CKO said:
Im in a similar quandary, always wanted an M3 but have found the delights of open top motoring, I like the Z4 Cab, I like the M3 Coupe but want an open top, I think the M3 Coupe looks a bit of a Dogs Dinner and the Z4M is too expensive to buy and run.
I also like open top motoring but as you say I find the M3 cab looks a bit dodgy. Also, I've heard you can really feel the extra weight and less rigidity in the body.

Honestherbert said:
Lots of jap turbo stuff but the bm will be a better everyday car smile they do most things well but not what I would want as a weekend fun car. I guess it depends what your main areas are that you want in a car? outright speed or sts n giggles? practicality? etc etc..
Jap turbos was my first port of call. An Impreza without any sort of modification comes back as ~500 more to insure than an M3 for me. Strange I know, as at one point E46 M3's were the hardest thing to insure on the road IIRC.


I'm open to almost leftfield options too. For instance an Audi S4 comes in way down the insurance scale for some reason.

ETA: I need, in order of preference - Fun, speed, chuckability, reliability, looks (I like styling, bit vain I know), practicality, running costs, What other people think.

Edited by APanda on Thursday 15th August 12:58

northwest monkey

6,370 posts

220 months

Thursday 15th August 2013
quotequote all
J4CKO said:
Im in a similar quandary, always wanted an M3 but have found the delights of open top motoring, I like the Z4 Cab, I like the M3 Coupe but want an open top, I think the M3 Coupe looks a bit of a Dogs Dinner and the Z4M is too expensive to buy and run.
M3 Convertible?



http://www.elmtreecarsales.co.uk/used-cars/bmw-m3-...

JackReacher

2,293 posts

246 months

Thursday 15th August 2013
quotequote all
Coldfuse said:
I'm fairly sure that the 350Z and the M3 are in different leagues...
300bhp RWD coupe, same league, but different ends of the table IMO

Codswallop

5,260 posts

225 months

Thursday 15th August 2013
quotequote all
APanda said:
Codswallop said:


Monaro.

It's a different kind of fun to an M3, and has a V8.
This was something I've been thinking about a little but didn't look into that much. When you say a different sort of fun, what do you mean?
I've only ever been a passenger in a E46 M3 SMG, but it did not feel all that fast or special from the passenger seat. Granted it is a very limited experience of the car, so I cannot form a complete opinion of it. From the reviews I have read of the car, I always got the impression that it was a car that was only really special when it was driven at 10/10ths, otherwise it was little different to a 330ci.

The Monaro is undoubtedly a worse car in many respects, but I personally enjoy the flexibility of the engine, the sounds it makes, and the playful chassis. Early CV8 models like that one have relatively skinny tyres for the performance the car has, which means it moves about underneath you when pushing on. A bit like a V8 powered Toyota GT86 I suppose. It just feels playful and fun, and I enjoy the heavy weight clutch and gearshift.

I also get the impression that an M3 is more fragile than the pig iron Monaro, so running costs should be lower.

Depends what you want/ like in a car. Only way is to try both an decide for your self.

TREMAiNE

4,164 posts

180 months

Thursday 15th August 2013
quotequote all
Codswallop said:


Monaro.

It's a different kind of fun to an M3, and has a V8.
THIS!

Dream car!

famfarrow

814 posts

185 months

Thursday 15th August 2013
quotequote all
As said above the upper Subaru's and Evo's will match it for speed on our roads but everything else... No

161BMW

1,876 posts

196 months

Thursday 15th August 2013
quotequote all
Here is an unusual alternative
CLK 55 AMG

Matt UK

18,084 posts

231 months

Thursday 15th August 2013
quotequote all
Eddh said:
E39 M5.
yes

BRMMA

1,908 posts

203 months

Thursday 15th August 2013
quotequote all
161BMW said:
Here is an unusual alternative
CLK 55 AMG
I think that's a good call, not as great dynamically as the M3 but a great engine that sounds superb with some very simple exhaust mods