Servicing costs: worth the cost of an authorised dealer?
Servicing costs: worth the cost of an authorised dealer?
Author
Discussion

SVS

Original Poster:

3,824 posts

302 months

Thursday 15th August 2013
quotequote all
What are people's views on using a local garage vs. an authorised dealer for annual servicing? The quote from my local garage is half the price of my authorsed dealer. How much do you think it matters to have a FSH from an authorised dealer? Will the local garage do anything less?

confused

Engineer1

10,486 posts

240 months

Thursday 15th August 2013
quotequote all
It depends, bt if you want any manufacturer goodwill then a full dealer service history goes a long way to helping convince the manufacturer.

Johnnytheboy

24,499 posts

217 months

Thursday 15th August 2013
quotequote all
My Ford dealer throws a year's AA membership into the deal every year. Sure, my local indy garage (whom I trust implicitly) would be cheaper, but the 'value' of a Ford service stamp and a year's recovery I need to buy anyway makes up for it.

decadent

2,572 posts

206 months

Thursday 15th August 2013
quotequote all
I've mostly alway stuck my car in at the main dealer. Mainly becuase i don't know of a decent garage and I want the stamps in the service book.

I've no idea whether they are actually any better servicing the car than a third party garage would be though!


funkyrobot

18,789 posts

259 months

Thursday 15th August 2013
quotequote all
Engineer1 said:
It depends, bt if you want any manufacturer goodwill then a full dealer service history goes a long way to helping convince the manufacturer.
I agree with this. Any car can throw a big bill. I think keeping the servicing etc at main dealers gives you good leverage, if a problem arises.

Spuffington

1,355 posts

199 months

Thursday 15th August 2013
quotequote all
I have a four year old E60 BMW. It stays within the dealer network for two reasons:

- it's under Extended Warranty and stipulated that it gets looked at by a dealer
- the propensity for you to get "goodwill" from the dealer if they know the car

The second point is contentious and those who believe in "Stealer" concept will dispute it, but time and time again I've had the dealer fight on my behalf for goodwill payments or just replace parts which aren't covered by a warranty because they know the sum total of my business to them is worth it. It works both ways IMO and for a premium / expensive motor, it makes sense.

Yes, for a four year old Fiesta I'd think differently perhaps.

Ozzie Osmond

21,189 posts

277 months

Thursday 15th August 2013
quotequote all
Ozzie's guide

  • Years 1 to 4: Main dealer. Modern cars need very little attention in their early years and the cost differential is outweighed by the value of that FMDSH and any goodwill repairs.
  • After year 4: Talk to the main dealer, cry a little, tell him you'd like to stick with them but the car isn't worth much so you're thinking about looking elsewhere: - he will offer suitably discounted rates so stick with it (even if they no longer do the "free valet").
  • After year 8: You'll probably be heading for a reputable independent.
How about the "all makes" oily rag under the railway arches? No. Just no.

Lee540

1,586 posts

175 months

Thursday 15th August 2013
quotequote all
I like to use an independent that specialises in a particular marque..

My 15 year old BMW 4.4 V8 was serviced at a BMW specialist and my 4 year old Audi is serviced at an VAG specialist.. simples.. smile

Krikkit

27,943 posts

212 months

Thursday 15th August 2013
quotequote all
Ozzie Osmond said:
...even if they no longer do the "free valet"
That's got to go into the PH vernacular. hehe

Toaster Pilot

14,867 posts

189 months

Thursday 15th August 2013
quotequote all
Kia have me until year 7 only because I don't want to give them any excuse not to meet a warranty claim - the servicing costs are high for a shopping cart on wheels though.

Granted I am within my rights to go elsewhere providing genuine parts are used but I'm sure they could find something wrong if (x,y,z massive part) was to go wrong and need warranty replacement, like the gearbox did 5000 miles ago.

New POD

3,851 posts

181 months

Thursday 15th August 2013
quotequote all
New Pod's Rules:

Trust no-one.

Buy only cars you can afford to scrap, and service it yourself.

Fix it yourself.

If you can't fix it yourself, remind yourself that you trust no one, and learn how to fix it yourself, or scrap it.

Delmonte

7 posts

159 months

Thursday 15th August 2013
quotequote all
Engineer1 said:
It depends, bt if you want any manufacturer goodwill then a full dealer service history goes a long way to helping convince the manufacturer.
This is what people don't realise!

New POD

3,851 posts

181 months

Thursday 15th August 2013
quotequote all
Delmonte said:
Engineer1 said:
It depends, bt if you want any manufacturer goodwill then a full dealer service history goes a long way to helping convince the manufacturer.
This is what people don't realise!
Unless they don't give a st.

mercfunder

8,535 posts

204 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
New POD said:
New Pod's Rules:

Trust no-one.

Buy only cars you can afford to scrap, and service it yourself.

Fix it yourself.

If you can't fix it yourself, remind yourself that you trust no one, and learn how to fix it yourself, or scrap it.
rolleyes

SVS

Original Poster:

3,824 posts

302 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
If you're out of manufacturer's warranty, does manufacturer's goodwill matter? (I've an old car.)

jamieduff1981

8,092 posts

171 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
New POD said:
New Pod's Rules:

Trust no-one.

Buy only cars you can afford to scrap, and service it yourself.

Fix it yourself.

If you can't fix it yourself, remind yourself that you trust no one, and learn how to fix it yourself, or scrap it.
That's not really all that practical if you own several cars and any of them are nice.

Personally I've started using a main dealer for the Jags, and use TVR Ecosse for the, err, TVR. I enjoy tinkering but I don't especially enjoy repair work under duress. Now that my income can support my expected standards, I prefer to give the cars to people who ought to know their specific needs and peculiarities.


Backstreet garages are less and less attractive the more complex/sophisticated cars become. When your car gets software updates or needs an OEM diagnostic computer to read fault codes from DSC systems, transmission control modules etc etc a backstreet generic garage is of pretty limited use really. They're fine for some things, but they can't do the holistic "looking after" of a modern car they way they could have 30 or even 20 years ago.

jamieduff1981

8,092 posts

171 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
SVS said:
If you're out of manufacturer's warranty, does manufacturer's goodwill matter? (I've an old car.)
In my experience, yes. Ford Duratec V6s had a habit of spitting out conrods due to spun big end bearings. They denied there was ever a problem but quietly redesigned the oil sump to include baffling etc when the capacity was updated from 2544cc to 2495cc around 2001 or so.

I was a keen member of the online based owners' club for Ford Cougars in my 20s and although it wasn't prolific, there was a steady stream of V6s throwing conrods outside of warranty. Some were replaced with 2nd hand engines obviously, but I can think of a few club mates who went for new engines having persuaded Ford to cough up half the bill out of "good will".

Of course, we owners at the time would have preferred that the design issue was formally recognised and the cars recalled, but I guess a few goodwill gestures to particularly terrior-like owners is much cheaper.

Spuffington

1,355 posts

199 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
jamieduff1981 said:
SVS said:
If you're out of manufacturer's warranty, does manufacturer's goodwill matter? (I've an old car.)
In my experience, yes. Ford Duratec V6s had a habit of spitting out conrods due to spun big end bearings. They denied there was ever a problem but quietly redesigned the oil sump to include baffling etc when the capacity was updated from 2544cc to 2495cc around 2001 or so.

I was a keen member of the online based owners' club for Ford Cougars in my 20s and although it wasn't prolific, there was a steady stream of V6s throwing conrods outside of warranty. Some were replaced with 2nd hand engines obviously, but I can think of a few club mates who went for new engines having persuaded Ford to cough up half the bill out of "good will".

Of course, we owners at the time would have preferred that the design issue was formally recognised and the cars recalled, but I guess a few goodwill gestures to particularly terrior-like owners is much cheaper.
Absolutely agree with this. I've had many an occasion where cars have been well outside the official warranty period but parts have been replaced / issues rectified on a "goodwill basis" because the car had spent its life under the relevant manufacturers "umbrella" or care.

New POD

3,851 posts

181 months

Saturday 17th August 2013
quotequote all
jamieduff1981 said:
New POD said:
New Pod's Rules:

Trust no-one.

Buy only cars you can afford to scrap, and service it yourself.

Fix it yourself.

If you can't fix it yourself, remind yourself that you trust no one, and learn how to fix it yourself, or scrap it.
That's not really all that practical if you own several cars and any of them are nice.

Personally I've started using a main dealer for the Jags, and use TVR Ecosse for the, err, TVR. I enjoy tinkering but I don't especially enjoy repair work under duress. Now that my income can support my expected standards, I prefer to give the cars to people who ought to know their specific needs and peculiarities.


Backstreet garages are less and less attractive the more complex/sophisticated cars become. When your car gets software updates or needs an OEM diagnostic computer to read fault codes from DSC systems, transmission control modules etc etc a backstreet generic garage is of pretty limited use really. They're fine for some things, but they can't do the holistic "looking after" of a modern car they way they could have 30 or even 20 years ago.
I was being a little tongue in cheek, because every time I have 'had' to use a professional, be it main dealer, independent, or back street, I always feel like I've been mugged.

Or rather, If I haven't been mugged then the standard of work is no better than mediocre.

Garvin

5,667 posts

208 months

Saturday 17th August 2013
quotequote all
As in all things in life, it depends! For new cars that will be sold on/px'd in 3 or so years time then main dealer stamps in the book will always help the cause particularly if you intend buying through that dealer again.

For an older car then a trusted local independent is the way to go as they are a lot cheaper and, lets face it, for servicing items - oil/filter, brake fluid, coolant changes, replacement brake pads etc they would have to be pretty dire not to be able to cope. If you want OEM parts, not pattern parts, used to protect warranty etc. just tell them and they're happy to comply although they will obviously charge for them.

As for fault reading then unless it's a specific problem i.e. not really servicing, most independents can read standard codes and sort things out. If it really is a model specific problem then there is always the option of putting it into a main dealer if you have to but this is more repair territory than servicing and I've not seen any stamps in service books stating the major repairs that may have been done to a vehicle!

I use a local independent for servicing and he does everything 'by the book' - even changes the pollen filters each year which, I have to say, I've seen plenty of vehicles with FSH from main dealers where these particular filters haven't been touched for years!! He will service the air con using a specialist, as some main dealers do, but at £75 all in for a full aircon service (and I mean full service - check all system pressures, leak test, switch and compressor operation and regas) is as cheap and as good as it comes and not to be confused with the KF version of just regassing!

I do not believe, for a car over 5 years old, that a main dealer FSH maintains the vehicle value any more than a good independent FSH does. Over five years or so the difference in servicing costs could end up somewhere between £500 & £1000 - is the resale value really this different for otherwise identical cars?