Strange car dilemma: Z4 3.0Si, E9X 330/335D/I, B7 A4 3.0TDI?
Strange car dilemma: Z4 3.0Si, E9X 330/335D/I, B7 A4 3.0TDI?
Author
Discussion

TroubledSoul

Original Poster:

4,669 posts

225 months

Thursday 15th August 2013
quotequote all
Maybe even a 2007ish Merc C320 CDI?

Looking to change cars. Got my E46 330cd up for sale now. I've been through a LOT of stuff in my head and thought long and hard up to this point. I'm now at a stage where I am ready to make a choice, but don't know which path to go down....

I've always fancied a Z4. I can't afford the M so I won't get hung up on that. I'd be looking at cars priced up to £8.5k. There are a couple of facelift cars around for that. I have enquired about a test drive on both a manual and an auto with paddles and await the outcome of that. Really would love a petrol again as the 330cd is a little dull if I'm honest. Economy looks very good on the Zed for what it is.

By the same token, I'd quite like an E9X 335i. Not many in budget though and all high miles. But great looking in coupe form and still tempting in M-Sport saloon/touring form.

The 335D seems like the best of everything rolled together into a capable package, but same limitations at this price point as the 335i.

Audi A4 3.0 TDI Quattro.... love the way this looks. Don't know if it's still the case that these are understeer machines with poor steering feel, or if Audi have revised things somewhat?

Merc is an outside shout... don't know much about them at all, be it C Class or CLK.

Not really a fan out autos, but could live with a good sports auto that lets me change gear myself via paddles or moving the stick. Diesel is the overriding thought, due to mileage being at least 15k a year, possibly a bit more depending on where contracts fall. But I do find the 330cd engine isn't very inspiring. It's good, no doubt about that, but it doesn't get me going. I fear the same will happen with any of the diesel options above, but may have to just bite the bullet in pursuit of a slightly younger, less miles on the clock car.

If I could, I'd have an Elise or a 996 911, quite frankly. But it's just not the right time.

Opinions welcome?

TroubledSoul

Original Poster:

4,669 posts

225 months

Thursday 15th August 2013
quotequote all
Looks like I have got a test drive Saturday of a manual Z4.

TroubledSoul

Original Poster:

4,669 posts

225 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
Nobody loves me.

Forever alone.

Actus Reus

4,312 posts

186 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
You could get a 986 Boxster for that money - better car, for my money, than the Z4.
ETA: though of all the cars you suggest, having never driven one, the 335d is the one I'd have for the money, given the mileage you'll do.

TroubledSoul

Original Poster:

4,669 posts

225 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
Actus Reus said:
You could get a 986 Boxster for that money - better car, for my money, than the Z4.
ETA: though of all the cars you suggest, having never driven one, the 335d is the one I'd have for the money, given the mileage you'll do.
Would love one, but 27mpg combined kills it. I'm actually wavering now over the Z4 purely because it is only 30 or so combined....

z4goon

51 posts

160 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
FWIW it's not too hard to get 40mpg on a motorway journey with the cruise set to 70 on my 3.0i Z4.


J4CKO

47,101 posts

231 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
For me, the potential engine issues put me off the Boxsters and onto the Z4, I know the Boxster is a better sports car but the Z4 is quite good on fuel for a 3.0 sports car and the mechanicals are pretty tried and trusted, being they are shared with pretty much every other BMW model. My thinking is that if the engine does eat itself (unlikely) they are available for a grand or less second hand whereas Boxster engines are at a premium and are more likely to have issues anyway, I know that shouldnt be the whole decision but the Z4 fits in more with my luck profile !


jamieduff1981

8,092 posts

171 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
What makes you think a 335d will go about its' business in a significantly different way to the 330d you find dull?

Seek

1,237 posts

231 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
J4CKO said:
For me, the potential engine issues put me off the Boxsters and onto the Z4, I know the Boxster is a better sports car but the Z4 is quite good on fuel for a 3.0 sports car and the mechanicals are pretty tried and trusted, being they are shared with pretty much every other BMW model. My thinking is that if the engine does eat itself (unlikely) they are available for a grand or less second hand whereas Boxster engines are at a premium and are more likely to have issues anyway, I know that shouldnt be the whole decision but the Z4 fits in more with my luck profile !
Exactly the thought process that I went through. Pretty much any BMW specialist can service it.

Other considerations were:
- Z4 3.0 available as Coupe - which is much preferable to a softtop when parking in public places
- Z4 Coupe is not much of a price premium over the softtop, which isnt the case with a Cayman vs Boxster
- as a company car it's special enough to be noticed but doesn't invoke as much jealousy as a "Porsche"
- Z4 design is pretty timeless which allows the car to be reasonably representative for more years than a repmobile without looking "old"

Actus Reus

4,312 posts

186 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
I don't think there's a huge difference between engine issues on the Porsche vs. other common issues on the BM. Have a read around the Porsche forum (a thread entitled 'I bought some poverty pork'). However, the mpg kills it for sure (though I see 31mpg on a run from my 3.4 Cayman S). That said, buying a Z4 for 15k miles a year seems an odd idea to me - maybe the mpg is OK, but the cabin is pretty small (read: cramped), and the ride is pretty firm. The 3-series is the car I'd have, and, to be honest, I'd probably keep what you've already got.

chris_freebie

957 posts

270 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
Actus Reus said:
You could get a 986 Boxster for that money - better car, for my money, than the Z4.
ETA: though of all the cars you suggest, having never driven one, the 335d is the one I'd have for the money, given the mileage you'll do.
I'm sorry what? wink

chris_freebie

957 posts

270 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
What about a 335i Coupe..........

TroubledSoul

Original Poster:

4,669 posts

225 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
Actus Reus said:
I don't think there's a huge difference between engine issues on the Porsche vs. other common issues on the BM. Have a read around the Porsche forum (a thread entitled 'I bought some poverty pork'). However, the mpg kills it for sure (though I see 31mpg on a run from my 3.4 Cayman S). That said, buying a Z4 for 15k miles a year seems an odd idea to me - maybe the mpg is OK, but the cabin is pretty small (read: cramped), and the ride is pretty firm. The 3-series is the car I'd have, and, to be honest, I'd probably keep what you've already got.
Used to do the same in a Hawkeye Impreza STi, and this car wasn't too firm(God I miss that car...). Nor is the current E46 with Bilstein B12 shocks and Eibach Springs. I should also mention that next summer my car will take me on another Euro/Ring trip and will do many Yorkshire Dales runs throughout its time with me.

Being able to do these runs with good economy is awesome, and the current car isn't bad. I just want a bit more. A bit more fun and involvement.

Very tempted by the 335i Coupe, but there aren't many about without moon miles for £8.5k or below. It's the same with the 335d unfortunately. I've looked at the 330D a little bit, despite knowing I'd be annoyed at not having a 335D and there don't seem to be many nice manual cars around in M Sport trim for my price range. E90 330D looks nicer inside and seems pretty decent on power and economy, even better (as you'd expect) than the E46.

123D 3 door keeps coming into my thoughts as the economy quoted is amazing for the performance, but not sure I'd like a 4 cylinder diesel.....

Z4 seems a great performance/economy compromise, although 30mpg combined is bothering me in the back of my mind. I just miss having a fun car. But if I get the wrong car next, I'll regret it.

Prof Prolapse

16,163 posts

221 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
Actus Reus said:
I don't think there's a huge difference between engine issues on the Porsche vs. other common issues on the BM.
I think you're mistaken personally.

The 3.0 litre engine on the BMW is a very time tested unit. Even if it fails just think about the number of 130s, 330s, 530s, etc. all sharing that same engine. The consequence of any failure is considerably less financially than the Porsche because of economies of scale. The Z4 also shared a lot of components with the e46 which reduces wear and tear costs even further. Aside from eating rear springs (£40 each and 15 minutes to fit) Z4s are solid cars.

I think the Porsche is the better car all around, but £8.5 grand will get you a rough Boxster. It will also get you a very good Z4.

I made the decision for the Z4 over the Boxster for exactly this reason.

I'm flogging mine if you're interested.

300bhp/ton

41,030 posts

221 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
TroubledSoul said:
Opinions welcome?
What exactly is the strange car dilemma??

TroubledSoul said:
Strange car dilemma

Herbs

5,132 posts

260 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
TroubledSoul said:
Used to do the same in a Hawkeye Impreza STi, and this car wasn't too firm(God I miss that car...). Nor is the current E46 with Bilstein B12 shocks and Eibach Springs. I should also mention that next summer my car will take me on another Euro/Ring trip and will do many Yorkshire Dales runs throughout its time with me.

Being able to do these runs with good economy is awesome, and the current car isn't bad. I just want a bit more. A bit more fun and involvement.

Very tempted by the 335i Coupe, but there aren't many about without moon miles for £8.5k or below. It's the same with the 335d unfortunately. I've looked at the 330D a little bit, despite knowing I'd be annoyed at not having a 335D and there don't seem to be many nice manual cars around in M Sport trim for my price range. E90 330D looks nicer inside and seems pretty decent on power and economy, even better (as you'd expect) than the E46.

123D 3 door keeps coming into my thoughts as the economy quoted is amazing for the performance, but not sure I'd like a 4 cylinder diesel.....

Z4 seems a great performance/economy compromise, although 30mpg combined is bothering me in the back of my mind. I just miss having a fun car. But if I get the wrong car next, I'll regret it.
The difference between 30mpg & 35mpg for 15,000 is only £440 odd quid or £8 per week - don't get hung up on it.

This is from someone who is using a Z4M as a daily averaging 23MPG.... wink

Actus Reus

4,312 posts

186 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
Prof Prolapse said:
I think you're mistaken personally.

The 3.0 litre engine on the BMW is a very time tested unit. Even if it fails just think about the number of 130s, 330s, 530s, etc. all sharing that same engine. The consequence of any failure is considerably less financially than the Porsche because of economies of scale. The Z4 also shared a lot of components with the e46 which reduces wear and tear costs even further. Aside from eating rear springs (£40 each and 15 minutes to fit) Z4s are solid cars.

I think the Porsche is the better car all around, but £8.5 grand will get you a rough Boxster. It will also get you a very good Z4.

I made the decision for the Z4 over the Boxster for exactly this reason.

I'm flogging mine if you're interested.
Sorry - I wasn't talking engine problems on the Z4, rather suspension issues.

I agree to a point though - I don't think an £8.5k Box need be rough though - if you wait a month or so, and shop around there will be decent 986s for that wedge. There will, however, be 3 good Z4s for every good Box.

I'd still rather have a 3-series diesel for the amount of miles postulated, but that's just my personal preference.

Prof Prolapse

16,163 posts

221 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
Actus Reus said:
Sorry - I wasn't talking engine problems on the Z4, rather suspension issues.
Agree with your other points, ultimately it's preference. I don't regret not buying a Porsche.

What suspension issues though?

As I said, the suspension components are largely shared with the e46. They cost very little given their performance. I've just changed wishbones, ARB bushes, droplinks and all bushes on my car simply because it was a few minutes out of spec. It was probably the easiest suspension change of my life due to easy access and premium bolts (big ones!) being used. It also cost less than £150 with no need for compressors.

If you're referring to the rear springs, as I said before, these cost £40 for the OEM spec (I believe it's Sachs) springs. They take literally 15 minutes a side to fit (it's one bolt). Infact I'm fairly confident I could do it in under 5 with the wheel off and someone fat to stand on the hub.




Actus Reus

4,312 posts

186 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
Well at those prices I must admit, they're not much to worry about - for some reason I was under the impression they'd be rather more expensive than that (bearing in mind I'm clueless, so be using my local stealer/indie).

As to cost - I'm sure I read on here, recently, that Z4Ms are available for not a lot more than the standard 3 litre cars (I suspect the Si models though?)

Prof Prolapse

16,163 posts

221 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
You won't get those prices from BMW I shouldn't think. But Sachs supply the springs (IIRC) and many suspension components to BMW, so you can cut out the middle man. Same goes for a few other pattern parts.

That's the trade off with the Porsche (and Z4m which doesn't even share the same rear subframe as the boggo Z4!) bespoke components although make for a better car, mean bigger bills when it comes to working on them.

You pays your money you makes your choice etc.