Anyone go from RWD to FWD and regret it?
Discussion
Contemplating a Fiesta ST at some point and will be coming from an E36, wondered if anyone else has made a similar leap?
Seems to me with all the traffic and high fuel prices there's now more of an argument for a more nimble and light FWDer given RWD cars nearly always have a longer wheelbase plus more mechanicals to lug around. So I'm pondering whether these new highly regarded FWDers can be more fun more of the time, whereas a RWD only really having an advantage on that very rare occasion when you can 'make progress' to enjoy the more involving dynamics?
I'm mainly interested in seeing replies from those who've experience with this rather than the thread turning into a FWD vs RWD battle ;-)
Seems to me with all the traffic and high fuel prices there's now more of an argument for a more nimble and light FWDer given RWD cars nearly always have a longer wheelbase plus more mechanicals to lug around. So I'm pondering whether these new highly regarded FWDers can be more fun more of the time, whereas a RWD only really having an advantage on that very rare occasion when you can 'make progress' to enjoy the more involving dynamics?
I'm mainly interested in seeing replies from those who've experience with this rather than the thread turning into a FWD vs RWD battle ;-)
Yes, I've gone E46 M3 to Mk2 Focus ST and I can't wait to get back into a RWD car.
Z4M coupe is top of my list.
Edit: Main reason is day to day drivability (e.g. getting away quick to nip into a gap on a busy roundabout), FWD just doesn't inspire confidence in the same way.
Z4M coupe is top of my list.
Edit: Main reason is day to day drivability (e.g. getting away quick to nip into a gap on a busy roundabout), FWD just doesn't inspire confidence in the same way.
Edited by skahigh on Thursday 15th August 17:42
Wow, seems a pretty overwhelming result for RWD!
RobCrezz said:
I cant see anything to gain from going from a nice E36 328i to a Fiesta ST. Unless you mean the new one?
Yeah would be the new one, though might wait till they're on the used market. But even a new one is almost half the price of a 135i, makes it hard to justify the RWD (even second hand) with a bit more power (and a lot more weight).Ginja said:
Vaguely similar, went from an E39 540 to a Mondeo 2.2td, hated it, now back in a 335 - much happier 
Might that not be down to going from a very potent petrol to a diseasal though?
I regularly switch between them and prefer RWD every time. As far as ownership goes, in my early car owning days I had two FWDs (one road, one race) and a 4WD (Celica Carlos Sainz), but have been exclusively RWD since (traded the CS in for an MR2 and never looked back). FWD can be awesome in a little hatch, but ultimately even after playing in a truly capable FWD car for a week or two I can't wait to get back into a RWD car. For me it's just about balance, delicacy and composure, which regardless of the smiles and fun something like a Clio 197 can give, you don't get with anything other than RWD. IMHO of course 

Sold MR2, went for Fiesta. Really didn't like it. Decided that wasn't fair on FWD so went for an FTO. Really didn't like it. Tried 4WD in an Impreza and didn't like it.
Not been out of RWD since.
I hardly ever use the RWD dynamics, but it does me the power of good to know they're there when I want them!
Not been out of RWD since.
I hardly ever use the RWD dynamics, but it does me the power of good to know they're there when I want them!
roystinho said:
Surely it depends on the cars. If you came from a 116i into a MINI GP for instance, which would you rather drive?
Comparable cars are preferable where possible. The cars I'm interested in are both around 200bhp, but then it'd be interesting if someone did prefer their 116i to a MINI GP just because of RWD.If the type of car is that important then you could argue which wheels are driven doesn't seem to make much difference anyway.
Gassing Station | General Gassing | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


