Ford Fiesta TDCi vs Clio 1.5 dCi 90 vs Pug 208 1.4 HDi
Ford Fiesta TDCi vs Clio 1.5 dCi 90 vs Pug 208 1.4 HDi
Author
Discussion

IATM

Original Poster:

3,948 posts

178 months

Thursday 15th August 2013
quotequote all


Hi All,

I am looking for some advice and experiences on the following three cars. I am essentially looking for a car for the wife but also this will be a car that is going to be a wee workhorse and be kept for life until it dies.

I would like to know if anyone has experiences of any of the above cars and general running costs including real world MPG's. A key thing is general reliability of these engines; I understand the cars are new however the engines to some extent have been in previous models and cars.

Below are examples of what I have been looking at, the clio's in general I have heard great things about past and present however seem to command a 3k premium over the other two! Which is surprising to me?

The fiesta is lower down on my list due to hearing bad things about long term reliability of the smaller TDCI engines - however I would really like to know from all of you.

Also just to give you an idea of the usage: it really will be 50/50 - I need it to be nippy enough and frugal enough in town but also it will be on the motorway quite a few times on a 50mile commute so needs to be comfortable, stable and frugal on motorway too.

Thanks

Ps. Does anyone have a scooby exactly what the difference is in the HDI and e-HDI pug range - the website they have is not exactly clear! just mentions start stop but that cannot explain the 13MPG benefit!




http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2013...

http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2013...

http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2013...



IATM

Original Poster:

3,948 posts

178 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
Anyone frown

LuS1fer

43,569 posts

276 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
Does your mileage justify a diesel premium and increased cost of fuel?

I had a Renault 1.5 diesel hire car and it was a nice car and drive train.....for a diesel.

If there is a £3k premium, I'd buy a petrol myself.

joewilliams

2,004 posts

232 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
Not much help I'm afraid, but I've been driving a petrol Fiesta for the last three weeks and have been very impressed by it. It's a great little chassis, we've fitted three kids in the back, and the interior is decent quality.

IATM

Original Poster:

3,948 posts

178 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
LuS1fer said:
Does your mileage justify a diesel premium and increased cost of fuel?

I had a Renault 1.5 diesel hire car and it was a nice car and drive train.....for a diesel.

If there is a £3k premium, I'd buy a petrol myself.
Sorry the 3k premium is for the clio of the other two derv options (208, Fiesta). The petrol is not that much cheaper tbh and considering I am looking to keep the car for life I feel it would be cost effective.

Superhoop

4,919 posts

224 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
If you've heard about long term reliability of the Fordm 1.4 Tdci engine, then the same must apply to the Peugeot 1.4 Hdi - They might be called by different names, but they're the very same engine

LuS1fer

43,569 posts

276 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
I get 32mpg from my Mk 6 Fiesta ST. I still think diesels have hidden costs at the higher mileages and offer a worse driving experience and think too many people fall for the "con" of diesel.

On the Clio point, the hire car was quite impressive and "grown-up" but I still had far more fun in a petrol 1.4 Fiesta.

dci

665 posts

172 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
I own a 1.5 dci clio, it's a good little car. It's currently averaging 60.0 mpg but I do have a heavy right foot, taking my time on my run to work I've seen 75 mpg which is part dual carriageway and part B roads and roundabouts. Anyone normal will probably see about 68-70 mpg without a problem.

Reliability wise it's been no hassle in the 35k miles I've driven it or the 73k miles before I had it. It feels like it's ready for another 100k (cue me sitting on the side of the A470 this evening). It doesn't have a DMF to go wrong or a DPF to clog up.

It's got an ok sized boot for a small hatchback and it carts my golf clubs or fishing gear around quite well. Fits people in the back too if they are under 6ft tall.

Richard

IATM

Original Poster:

3,948 posts

178 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
dci said:
I own a 1.5 dci clio, it's a good little car. It's currently averaging 60.0 mpg but I do have a heavy right foot, taking my time on my run to work I've seen 75 mpg which is part dual carriageway and part B roads and roundabouts. Anyone normal will probably see about 68-70 mpg without a problem.

Reliability wise it's been no hassle in the 35k miles I've driven it or the 73k miles before I had it. It feels like it's ready for another 100k (cue me sitting on the side of the A470 this evening). It doesn't have a DMF to go wrong or a DPF to clog up.

It's got an ok sized boot for a small hatchback and it carts my golf clubs or fishing gear around quite well. Fits people in the back too if they are under 6ft tall.

Richard
Hi Richard,

That is exactly what I was looking to find out - one of my managers at work has a clio and she has had it 11 years and has only even done routine work on it and have never let her down no matter what unlike her BMW (she says).

If you don't mind me ask, what model of Clio do you have and year.

Thanks

tezzer

984 posts

217 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
Wife's got a 1,4 fiesta, cracking little thing, had it from new, on an 07 plate. Approaching 80,000 miles now, and driven carefully, returns the best part of 70mpg (on the computer).

Reliability wise, apart from a EGR valve, touch wood, nothing, apart from the usual, exhause, a spring, discs, etc.

Gotta be worth a look.

ajh38

904 posts

181 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
If you go down the 208 route I'd be looking at the Active spec as the minimum (Bluetooth, USB, Multifunction Screen & alloys) and the 1.2 petrol. There's nothing wrong with the 1.4 diesel but the 1.2 is genuinely fun and although the diesel is £0 ved the 1.2 is still only £20.
Going for the petrol would probably also let you go for the upgrade in spec for similar money.

ajh38

904 posts

181 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
The e-hdi in the 1.4 is also egc gearbox so semi auto. Unless you need it I wouldn't bother.

dci

665 posts

172 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
IATM said:
Hi Richard,

That is exactly what I was looking to find out - one of my managers at work has a clio and she has had it 11 years and has only even done routine work on it and have never let her down no matter what unlike her BMW (she says).

If you don't mind me ask, what model of Clio do you have and year.

Thanks
No problem..

It's a 2006 Clio III 1.5 dci dynamique 86 bhp

redtwin

7,518 posts

213 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
We have a Fiesta an '03 1.4 TDCI in the family approaching 114K miles. Early on it suffered from a leaky power steering rack, but I think there was a bad batch at the time as the dealer was well aware of the prob.

It has had nothing more than regular engine servicing and consumable (brakes, belts, tyres etc) replacements since. Lately I noticed the clutch not feeling as it should, could be worn, or could be the concentric slave. It is having a new clutch and concentric put in tomorrow in the hopes of solving that.

I don't drive the car very often (Step daughter is keeper) so can't comment on fuel economy. The interior and exterior trim is a bit fragile so our car has various bits replaced, missing or stuck back on with glue.

All in all a decent little car that will probably only be replaced as something bigger is needed. When that time comes I may just get rid of my Accord and keep the little Fiesta. £35 v £270 VED and double the MPG having nothing to do with that of course. wink

Wife has a newer '11 plate Fiesta, but that has the 1.4 TDCI not the 1.6 you are looking at. Engine aside, it is a really nice car, very roomy (for a small hatchback) and easy to drive. I remember at the time we bought it, the salesman saying that the 1.6 econetic was not such a good buy as the other trim levels offered more for the money. I think that could well have been them having a 1.4 to sell v having to order in a 1.6.

Edited by redtwin on Friday 16th August 17:43