A quandary. Sorry!
Author
Discussion

surveyor

Original Poster:

18,707 posts

215 months

Thursday 15th August 2013
quotequote all
Time to change car. Have between 6 and 7k to spend, preferably closer to the 6.

Must be capable of towing 2000 kg, and have a long seated desire for 4wd.

Other half will be doing most of the using and is more style contious than me.

Thinking at the moment of an x5, or an early leggy FFRR. Bit concerned on the latter, but love the styling. My safe preference is a high spec disco 2, but the fact that they are obviously dated means I'm getting pushback from other half.

So what would you do?

infradig

978 posts

238 months

Thursday 15th August 2013
quotequote all
I was in a similar position earlier this year,looked at a lot of nasty ,smokey X5s and our budget was a couple of grand more. Any X5 diesel with a decent spec and provable history is like rocking horse st and all the ones we could afford either had no nav/ leather or were photographed outside a backstreet terrace in Leicester in the ad!
Wife wouldn't have an old FF RR(Phil Mitchell drives one !) Touraegs are a good compromise and we came close to buying a 2.5 manual until the indie dealer wouldn't put a legal tyre on it.
Ended up with a Freelander 2, which has been great,most non-car people think its a RangeRover ( just a bit further away,Dougal) and its not overly chavvy ,it's nice to drive,cruises at 90 whilst still doing 35mpg. Ours is an 07 Fully loaded HSE but I've seen a few GS and XS's within your budget and they're hardly bare metal and plastic seats.
In theory they can tow 2 tonnes but I think you'd only want to do that with an auto as the clutches don't have a great reputation.
Downsides include Gaylander jibes from real Land Rover drivers and my wife reckons you only see old people driving them( Prince Philip has one!) . I parked ours next to my brothers RR classic and its a couple of inches shorter and lower but a little bit wider.

The Moose

23,710 posts

240 months

Thursday 15th August 2013
quotequote all
I'd have thought in terms of reliability, you'd be hard pushed to best a landcruiser.

Great cars. Great for towing

surveyor

Original Poster:

18,707 posts

215 months

Thursday 15th August 2013
quotequote all
I'm not buying a car just for towing. That's a small part of it's life. I've tried to like the jap cars, and just don't.

Freelander is an interesting shout.

I've contemplated buying at auction, to try and stretch my budget a tad.

KTF

10,735 posts

181 months

Bill

58,933 posts

286 months

Thursday 15th August 2013
quotequote all
That budget would get you a very good D2, get ACE and a £200 remap and they're a surprisingly good drive.

surveyor

Original Poster:

18,707 posts

215 months

Thursday 15th August 2013
quotequote all
Bill said:
That budget would get you a very good D2, get ACE and a £200 remap and they're a surprisingly good drive.
DO they not all have ACE?

infradig

978 posts

238 months

Thursday 15th August 2013
quotequote all
KTF said:
Grand Cherokee: http://www4.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/201...

Smaller Cherokee: http://www4.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/201...

Cant be any less reliable than a LR wink

X-Trail: http://www4.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/201...

All random examples picked from AT.
Grand Cherokee's are good but strangely cramped for the size and fuel consumption you have to endure. I've got a 300c with the same engine and its great but in the Jeep it uses about 25% more fuel and the interior plastics make the Chrysler feel like an Audi.

As for reliability any Japanese 4x4 is going to be ten times better than anything from Solihull , but in this country Land Rovers outsell them in every segment by up to 500 to 1 (FF and Amazon) since when did logic play a part in car choice?

Bill

58,933 posts

286 months

Thursday 15th August 2013
quotequote all
surveyor said:
DO they not all have ACE?
Nope. I can't member off hand what level spec it was standard on but it was an option for all others. Look for four brake-sized pipes on the chassis in the front off-side wheel arch. It's also worth checking the reservoir in the engine bay because leaks can ruin the pump etc which is expensive to fix.

surveyor

Original Poster:

18,707 posts

215 months

Thursday 15th August 2013
quotequote all
KTF said:
I think the Gran Cherokee has the mercedes v6 diesel, which I would not touch. Once bitten.

Bill said:
surveyor said:
DO they not all have ACE?
Nope. I can't member off hand what level spec it was standard on but it was an option for all others. Look for four brake-sized pipes on the chassis in the front off-side wheel arch. It's also worth checking the reservoir in the engine bay because leaks can ruin the pump etc which is expensive to fix.
I'd limit myself to a minimum of ES. I like toys!

infradig

978 posts

238 months

Thursday 15th August 2013
quotequote all
Bill said:
Nope. I can't member off hand what level spec it was standard on but it was an option for all others. Look for four brake-sized pipes on the chassis in the front off-side wheel arch. It's also worth checking the reservoir in the engine bay because leaks can ruin the pump etc which is expensive to fix.
I think it was only standard on the ES and maybe some special editions, Metropolis etc. it was optional across the range even on models without air suspension. I've driven Disco 2's with and without ACE and have to agree that the ACE equipped cars corner amazingly flat and level and a decent 200bhp chipped TD5 can cover ground at a surprising rate,as long as its not full of kids and passenger seat speed limiter- you're still perched up pretty high and passengers get thrown around,a lot..
My local Land Rover indie charges £300 to remove knackered ACE and about the same to ditch the air and replace with coils.

Risotto

3,934 posts

243 months

Thursday 15th August 2013
quotequote all
Don't know a great deal about them (or towing) but what about one of these? Stylish, just about in budget & could be had in 4wd diesel guise...




Edited by Risotto on Thursday 15th August 23:27

motorhole

692 posts

251 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
Fan of the X-Trail. Bit of a used car bargain, very underrated. 2.2 Dci doesn't feel underpowered and is actually quite car like to drive. Rear seats fold down for a completely flat load space right up to the front seat backs. Practical and even big enough for me to sleep in. Can even do a little bit of the rough stuff.

Not the best looking 4x4 tbh, bit for a utility vehicle, looks come a long way down the list imo.

R26Andy

404 posts

192 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
The E83 X3 3.0d and 3.0sd have 2000kg towing capacity.

3.0sd will also do 0-60 in 6.5 seconds (but not at the same time).