Discarding an undertray?
Discarding an undertray?
Author
Discussion

Toaster Pilot

Original Poster:

14,867 posts

189 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
My Felicia has an undertray with horrifically rusted/chewed up screws holding it on - some of them will need drilling out to get it off I reckon.

Is it worthwhile trying to find new fasteners to put it back on after I've done some work on it or can I safely discard it without worrying about things getting damaged easily afterwards? It's been on there for 14 years after all so I guess it's there for a reason.

DJFish

6,018 posts

294 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
Unless it attaches to other trim parts the only risk is oil stains on your driveway, that and the loss of downforce from not having a flat floor, you may find the groundforce effect is diminished at high speeds....

That last bit might be bks...

Toaster Pilot

Original Poster:

14,867 posts

189 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
DJFish said:
downforce from not having a flat floor, you may find the groundforce effect is diminished at high speeds....

That last bit might be bks...
Massive concern to a 1.9 non turbo diesel that dairies won't use to deliver milk because it's too slow hehe

Oil stains however scratchchin

James_N

3,305 posts

265 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
My undertray came off years ago on the volvo! One of the screws was knackered and it started hanging off. I just ragged it off and carried on biggrin Least it makes oil changes easier!!

Repent

388 posts

204 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
One thing worth mentioning is that the airflow can be disrupted around the cooling system, as it can be designed to work within parameters aided/provided by the undertray dependant on model.

May not be the biggest concern on a 1.9 diesel though! All the same I'd personally keep it on there, largely for the aforementioned oil scenario.

Edited by Repent on Friday 16th August 03:03

Toaster Pilot

Original Poster:

14,867 posts

189 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
Repent said:
One thing worth mentioning is that the airflow can be disrupted around the cooling system, as it can be designed to work within parameters aided/provided by the undertray dependant on model.
Hmmm, might need to sort out the suspected cooling issue first then (the radiator fan doesn't seem to kick in when it should, which I have diagnosed as a faulty coolant temp sensor because it was disconnected when I got the car and the car won't start from warm when it is re-connected (assumedly the reason it was disconnected)

matchmaker

9,093 posts

231 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
My 1.8T with a bit more power hasn't had an undertray for years. No problems about cooling. As for oil stains - it didn't cover the sump anyway!

iwantagta

1,324 posts

176 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
My undertray made an excellent sled.
No damage to my sump in a couple of years without.

John D.

21,183 posts

240 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
I damaged one on a Clio 172. Ran it without with no problems for a couple of years after. I was worried stones/dirt flicked up towards the engine (cambelt was 'on show' from beneath for instance) would cause a problem somehow, but I consulted a mechanic and he said not to worry. Only difference it seemed to make was the bottom of the front bumper bodywork felt more flimsy as it lost some stiffness/support from being connected to the under tray.

Certainly made oil changes simpler too!

22rgt B Squadron

339 posts

168 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
When i ran a large taxi workshop we had Mondeos, Vectras and Skodas and due to being serviced every 6-8 weeks all undertrays were left off. Also included engine covers and anything else which got in the way, never had any issues.

Megaflow

11,660 posts

256 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
We have had a Volvo S40 T5 for nearly 5 years, which according to every service guide I look at, should have an undertray and there isn't one. No issues at all.

Dog Star

17,650 posts

199 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
Megaflow said:
We have had a Volvo S40 T5 for nearly 5 years, which according to every service guide I look at, should have an undertray and there isn't one. No issues at all.
Our first V70 didn't have one - evidently an option so I read on a forum. I got one off eBay - helps keep the engine clean (it got filthy last winter). Replacement V70 has one fitted.

Agreed that they are a total ball ache at oil change time though.

Captain Muppet

8,540 posts

296 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
Toaster Pilot said:
My Felicia has an undertray with horrifically rusted/chewed up screws holding it on - some of them will need drilling out to get it off I reckon.

Is it worthwhile trying to find new fasteners to put it back on after I've done some work on it or can I safely discard it without worrying about things getting damaged easily afterwards? It's been on there for 14 years after all so I guess it's there for a reason.
Either leave it off (there will be a tiny increase in drag as well as the other issue already mentioned) or cable tie it on.

Cable ties last forever and never rust. Lighter than bolts too.

LuS1fer

43,569 posts

276 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
Your engine will get dirtier and may be more prone to water ingress into the electrics. Aerodynamics may mean your fuel consumption increases very slightly.

anonymous-user

85 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
I tore the one off my Jaguar X300 on a gattle grid I hit at speed. It didn't seem to make any difference but it DID cause more belt squealing when driving through large puddles - presumably it was mostly there to stop water and muck splashing over the alternator/pumps etc at the front of the engine.

Not sure about a more modern car that has panels all the way underneath to control airflow though, but that hardly covers your old Fabia biggrin

djdestiny

6,542 posts

209 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
I couldnt refit mine on my S4 due to various modifications, it was running 500bhp and having no tray made no difference to engine temps, performance or anything else

Prof Prolapse

16,163 posts

221 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
LuS1fer said:
Your engine will get dirtier and may be more prone to water ingress into the electrics. Aerodynamics may mean your fuel consumption increases very slightly.
I'm with the above, it's not a massively important component but it is there for a reason.

I would just refit it. Worst case scenario is a set of roller type stud extractors for £20 from machine mart. If you're being a peasant, just drill some speed holes and use zip ties to secure.

15 minutes in either instance.

lance1a

1,337 posts

229 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
Usually fitted to comply with legislation regarding fuel efficiency. If you look at cars produced for the USA they have a lot more underbody trim than other countries to enhance this effect, but again...legislation.

trashbat

6,318 posts

184 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
LuS1fer said:
Your engine will get dirtier and may be more prone to water ingress into the electrics.
This would be my main concern, as well as (admittedly minimal) protection for the sump.

It also reduces noise, though not necessarily for the driver's perspective - more for those around.

RDB

334 posts

210 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
I would keep it on. Once you get the undertray off, drill a hole next to each existing fixing hole in the tray, then you'll be able to loop cable ties through each one to hold it on.

The undertray on my car has been fixed on using cable ties for about 3 years with no problems and it makes it easy to remove the next time.