Last thing my town needed was an Electric Car Charging Point
Last thing my town needed was an Electric Car Charging Point
Author
Discussion

Emeye

Original Poster:

9,781 posts

254 months

Saturday 17th August 2013
quotequote all
Today I found out in the most unfortunate way that they had turned the free car park opposite my local train station into a pay and display carpark - £25 fine if I pay in 14 days, fair cop for me being so dosy and not seeing the new signs.

What stunned me though, was that in the corner of the car park there was now an Electric Vehicle Charging Point.

Really? The last thing my small northern town of Stalybridge needs is an Eco-friendly statement of intent by Tameside Council.

With all the other issues the town has, I cannot understand why money would be allocated to this. Over the last ten years or so the town centre has died - all we are left with on the high street is huge bookies, Wetherspoons + other bargain booze pubs and hair dressers; along with a medium sized Tescos and a couple of other shops clinging on for dear life.

Now I don't know how these charging points are funded, and you'd get bored if I listed all the better ways the money could have been spent, but how about using it to subsidise or make the car parks free and attract people to shop in the town? Or maybe tidy up some litter every now and again?

Our roads are full of potholes, the pavements are falling apart and you can not sit down in my local park as all the benches and tables have been burnt out and never replaced!

I don't know anyone who owns an electric car, and I have never seen an electric car driving about around here, but I can guarantee the car geek in me would have noticed!

And another thing, I think there were 2 charging point spaces, so if two people do leave their Nissan Leaf of whatever electric cars on charge when they go into Manchester to work all day, what happens to the third electric car when it comes along?

The whole electric car thing baffles me - maybe if you live in a city centre they can make sense, even if the environmental arguments for them are bks, but not in a struggling little town that can barely keep its head above water.


Edited by Emeye on Saturday 17th August 20:30

BrownBottle

1,416 posts

167 months

Saturday 17th August 2013
quotequote all
Because PC.

Butter Face

35,157 posts

191 months

Saturday 17th August 2013
quotequote all
It's paid for by a government grant not by your local council if that makes you feel better.

Harrytsg

1,264 posts

193 months

Saturday 17th August 2013
quotequote all
If it makes you feel any better, we have loads of unused ones in London.

http://www.standard.co.uk/news/transport/shock-for...


Emeye

Original Poster:

9,781 posts

254 months

Saturday 17th August 2013
quotequote all
Butter Face said:
It's paid for by a government grant not by your local council if that makes you feel better.
I'd rather the government grant had been spent on ANYTHING else!

Getragdogleg

10,318 posts

214 months

Saturday 17th August 2013
quotequote all
Buy an electric car and take advantage of the free and unused facility.

Emeye

Original Poster:

9,781 posts

254 months

Saturday 17th August 2013
quotequote all
Getragdogleg said:
Buy an electric car and take advantage of the free and unused facility.
Should I start a what car thread?

s p a c e m a n

12,160 posts

179 months

Saturday 17th August 2013
quotequote all
Are these things free to use then, can I buy a plug and use them to power other things?

stevensdrs

3,265 posts

231 months

Saturday 17th August 2013
quotequote all
20 electric charging points in my town, all in the same car park and all connected to cars for the use of council employees. Most of then don't turn a wheel from one week to the next. One way or another we are all paying for this waste of money.

dapearson

4,456 posts

255 months

Saturday 17th August 2013
quotequote all
If your electric car went flat between your commute from home to the station, and would recharge enough for the return journey in 9 hrs, leaving enough time for a day's commute and work via train then fine i can see the point.

However, electric cars seem to take 15 hrs or so to charge, and i can't imagine it would do the batteries much good to give them less than a full charge, or to put them on charge unless nearly flat.

And if they do go flat between your home and the station, and can't make the return journey unless receiving a "top up" then surely that's leaving yourself open to being stranded?

FWIW i'd have an electric car in a heartbeat when they become properly usable and practical. An electric car with a big boot for trips to the tip, somewhere to throw in a mountain bike, something comfy for winter commutes = perfect.

Butter Face

35,157 posts

191 months

Saturday 17th August 2013
quotequote all
dapearson said:
If your electric car went flat between your commute from home to the station, and would recharge enough for the return journey in 9 hrs, leaving enough time for a day's commute and work via train then fine i can see the point.

However, electric cars seem to take 15 hrs or so to charge, and i can't imagine it would do the batteries much good to give them less than a full charge, or to put them on charge unless nearly flat.

And if they do go flat between your home and the station, and can't make the return journey unless receiving a "top up" then surely that's leaving yourself open to being stranded?

FWIW i'd have an electric car in a heartbeat when they become properly usable and practical. An electric car with a big boot for trips to the tip, somewhere to throw in a mountain bike, something comfy for winter commutes = perfect.
15 hours to charge? Where have you read that?

iphonedyou

10,424 posts

188 months

Saturday 17th August 2013
quotequote all
dapearson said:
If your electric car went flat between your commute from home to the station, and would recharge enough for the return journey in 9 hrs, leaving enough time for a day's commute and work via train then fine i can see the point.

However, electric cars seem to take 15 hrs or so to charge, and i can't imagine it would do the batteries much good to give them less than a full charge, or to put them on charge unless nearly flat.

And if they do go flat between your home and the station, and can't make the return journey unless receiving a "top up" then surely that's leaving yourself open to being stranded?

FWIW i'd have an electric car in a heartbeat when they become properly usable and practical. An electric car with a big boot for trips to the tip, somewhere to throw in a mountain bike, something comfy for winter commutes = perfect.
Surely the batteries aren't stuck in the 80s anymore. I'd be very surprised if the manual said owners should drive around the block until the battery is nearly flat, or around the country should the battery be 70% charged and they need 100% for a long journey the following day.

Ray Luxury-Yacht

8,918 posts

247 months

Saturday 17th August 2013
quotequote all
Lol.

Local councils = not fit for purpose, out of touch, shadowy autocrats making unilateral decisions unrelated to common sense, behind the safety of closed doors...

My local city has similar problems - some of the main roads into town are so bad now, they resemble a BMX track. Local traders are all struggling, and the council helps by levering he price of (what few) parking spaces remain in town up to silly prices.

Then levying another 'BID' charge to businesses in addition to business rates, (that is compulsory and backed up by the threat of court action) that basically brings no further benefits to traders other than providing some more nice hanging baskets rolleyes

The town centre itself desperately needs some investment in roads and facilities in order to encourage people to shop in town, rather than use other towns and retail estates.


The killer - despite all these obvious issues hindering the city and it's businesses and transport into - they suddenly think it would be a great idea to renovate a 100-year old railway viaduct, 3 miles away from the city, to bring it back to life as a cyclepath. At a cost to local council tax and business rate payers of - ONE MILLION POUNDS!!!

If I despaired about it too much, I think my head would explode with the pressure of it all.

I are continuously dissapoint.


McWigglebum4th

32,414 posts

235 months

Saturday 17th August 2013
quotequote all
Any idea how much one costs to install?


moribund

4,423 posts

245 months

Saturday 17th August 2013
quotequote all
Apparently so much that you could regenerate a town centre for the same amount.

cptsideways

13,900 posts

283 months

Saturday 17th August 2013
quotequote all
Most of them don't charge for juice either & the parking is often free too!


You can buy a plug & lead for a quid & trail it into the grill, no-one will be the wiser hehe

Gruber

6,313 posts

245 months

Saturday 17th August 2013
quotequote all
I'm involved in the supermarket-building business and we're increasingly finding Councils making us put a few of these charging points in our new car parks. The use of them by customers is, as you'd expect, spectacularly low.

It's just the latest green fad.

I can understand why, theoretically, it seems like a good plan, but the current reality is somewhat different.


Ray Luxury-Yacht said:
Then levying another 'BID' charge to businesses in addition to business rates, (that is compulsory and backed up by the threat of court action) that basically brings no further benefits to traders other than providing some more nice hanging baskets rolleyes
BIDs only come into existence if more than half the local businesses within the BID zone vote for it. It's not unilaterally levied by the Council. These work much better in the States. They've never really gained traction over here.

Technomatt

1,085 posts

164 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
Emeye said:
Butter Face said:
It's paid for by a government grant not by your local council if that makes you feel better.
I'd rather the government grant had been spent on ANYTHING else!
They do.....

The Govt has to give up to a £5000 grant off each electric car purchase because they are just uselessly overpriced. laugh

valais

60,028 posts

186 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
Gruber said:
I'm involved in the supermarket-building business and we're increasingly finding Councils making us put a few of these charging points in our new car parks. The use of them by customers is, as you'd expect, spectacularly low.

It's just the latest green fad.

I can understand why, theoretically, it seems like a good plan, but the current reality is somewhat different.
I guess it's an effort to break the cycle of non-adoption. "I'm not buying one, there is nowhere to charge it".

The infrastructure takes a long time to get to critical mass. I think any govt is "seeding" that infrastructure to get the ball rolling...?

McWigglebum4th

32,414 posts

235 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
Technomatt said:
They do.....

The Govt has to give up to a £5000 grant off each electric car purchase because they are just uselessly overpriced. laugh
Were you abused as a child by an electric car?