MoT - can you ask them to show you a fault?
MoT - can you ask them to show you a fault?
Author
Discussion

Tampon

Original Poster:

4,637 posts

256 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
I am having the MoT done tomorrow at kwik fit due to it running out whilst in france and Kwik fit offering a £30 online booking Test ( gave me a booking and a email to show plod on the way home from dover).

Now when I have had my motorbikes done the fella lets me have a nose around with him and shows me any faults and usually offers a few tips on how to fix anything, which normally see him with a drink in his pocket at the end.

Whats the deal at Kwik fit ? if they find a fault can I asked to be shown it ? doubt they will let me in the garage to view. I will be repairing anything that pops up ( within reason) myself but cant imagine that there is much that could be wrong.

Just replaced the brake disk and pads, replaced the air suspension for damps and springs ( although secondhand) and just serviced it. Gone over the obvisous, selt belts, lights, number plates screen wash etc etc The handbrake is a bit pony but works when given a good yank. If they find something I was hoping they might show me whilst it is on the ramp, things like that just help when you are getting parts or planning a job back at home on the drive.




DuraAce

4,272 posts

191 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
Its law that you're allowed to observe the test isn't it?

Can't see why they wouldn't show you any fail items. Just ask them before they start the test.

Tampon

Original Poster:

4,637 posts

256 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
You can watch from the viewing area but that is in the office. I was kind of hoping that they would show me in the garage any issues. Hopefully they will. I will ask them, also it should hopeful stop any chancing by the tester to get some work for the company.

MGZTV8

599 posts

180 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
This isn't going to go well as this thread unfolds.....

You must be mad taking it to that bunch of cowboys but hey it's your money.

You may as well bend over now.....

Tampon

Original Poster:

4,637 posts

256 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
Unfortunately there weren't many other options when we realised friday evening in rural france 9 hrs before we set off to drive to england. At £30 it was the cheapest way of getting a booking confirmed quickley to make my drive home look legal and save me from a £60 fine.

If they take the piss I will take it too the local guys and get them to MoT it. I am not going to waste the £30 by not taking it there first.

Car is pretty straight, a 2002 55,000 mile 2.5 Subaru Legacy.

jock mcsporran

5,128 posts

304 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
To be honest, I haven't had too many issues with MOT's at Kwik Fit. I tend to wait while it's done. The only time something was flagged up was a wheel bearing. I asked them to show me so they put it back on the ramp and, sure enough, it was toast. Their price to replace was cheaper than I could get the parts for.
They even replaced a couple of bulbs for free to pass the car on another occasion.
I wouldn't really have them do work outside of the MOT though.

Mastodon2

14,346 posts

196 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
Tampon said:
You can watch from the viewing area but that is in the office. I was kind of hoping that they would show me in the garage any issues. Hopefully they will. I will ask them, also it should hopeful stop any chancing by the tester to get some work for the company.
They should show you, if they have any confidence in their ability and integrity they should be able to demonstrate a faulty item on the test. The key question though, do you know enough about what is and is not considered a fail to grade their work? As in, do you have the depth of knowledge to tell them they are wrong when they demonstrate a "fault", if you believe it should be a pass?

New POD

3,851 posts

181 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
Just make it clear that they won't be doing the work, and they won't be tempted to find any extra work other than legit.

Ian Geary

5,651 posts

223 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
I had my car mot'd by kwik fit this year. It was easy to book, slots available in a day or two and only £30. My 12 yo car sailed through .. Not a whiff of spurious quotes for fake work, and listening in on others they were the same. I had been expecting this and was pleasantly surprised. I would urge people not to dismiss their mots based on rumour and here say.

but previous greasy floor garages have shown me failures and would have expected this from kwikfit.

ian

valais

60,024 posts

186 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
In my experience kiwi fit vary massively from branch to branch. Some are excellent, as in, "checked your tyres, down to 4mm, you've easily got 5k left on those - oh and we topped up your washer bottle as well, no charge, silly thing for it possibly to fail on" through to the normal horror stories.

Tampon

Original Poster:

4,637 posts

256 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
Mastodon2 said:
The key question though, do you know enough about what is and is not considered a fail to grade their work? As in, do you have the depth of knowledge to tell them they are wrong when they demonstrate a "fault", if you believe it should be a pass?
Bit left field there don't you think?

As stated I would like them to show me the fault and why it is a fault to help me fix it later, not because I know more than them.

Tampon

Original Poster:

4,637 posts

256 months

Tuesday 20th August 2013
quotequote all
MGZTV8 said:
This isn't going to go well as this thread unfolds.....

You must be mad taking it to that bunch of cowboys but hey it's your money.

You may as well bend over now.....
Well I got a phone call yesterday saying the MoT tester was injured and they would have to send me to the Brentford branch. Popped along this morning, asked if they would show me any faults if they pop up, said that would not be a problem. Sat down with a free coffee, watched some tv, read a paper and it pass with no advisories.

The tester came in and chatted about the car for a minute, given the paperwork and sent home. Easy

All for £30. Have to say I was very impressed.

Janesy B

2,625 posts

217 months

Tuesday 20th August 2013
quotequote all
An MOT test is an MOT test, contrary to all that tinfoil hat nonsense.

eltax91

10,794 posts

237 months

Tuesday 20th August 2013
quotequote all
Glad it worked out for you OP. I think if you ask to see faults as they pop up, like you did, you earmark yourself as more than an average muppet and they don't bother trying it on with you.

So much of the mot is subjective of course, but honestly, a brand like kwik fit wouldn't risk it's reputation churning out false mot results. Far too much regulation kicking about and I would guess they are far more likely to be inspected as a 'name' in the industry.

Tampon

Original Poster:

4,637 posts

256 months

Tuesday 20th August 2013
quotequote all
On one of my bikes i bought cheap as a project, I chucked it in for a MoT as a off chance whilst doing her up. The carb would piss fuel when not running so I kept turning the tap off everytime he stopped the bike during the MoT (little garage where the veiwing area is marked on the floor 2 ft from the bike) well it failed on a weak horn and dim light due to a bad magneto not charging the battery but lovely guy said charge the battery at home and bring it back and it would pass!

Rode it home stuck the battery on charge, when straight back, lights and horn all worked well on the power of the charged battery (magneto still donald ducked)still pissing fuel and it passed.

Madness.

405dogvan

5,329 posts

296 months

Tuesday 20th August 2013
quotequote all
Janesy B said:
An MOT test is an MOT test, contrary to all that tinfoil hat nonsense.
Except that it isn't at all...

Ask ANY mechanic and they'll point you to a favoured test centre - most independant mechanics know the tester(s) and will even call them to discuss any issues (sometimes before the test takes place - *wink wink*!).

The MOT is a good earner - they keep all but a couple-of-quid of the fee and it's a VERY good business driver - but as with all things in business, competition pushes some people into exploiting the customer - e.g. for work which isn't essential or for failing a car they'd like to buy and fix themselves...

It sounds dodgy but it's how the system works - we're not even in the realm of the 'paid pass' here either (and that exists for sure) just the realm of people who aren't wasting other people's time and money for the sake of pointless paperwork against people who are really taking the piss.

Example: I know people who customize bikes - streetfighter-style and choppers mainly. To get an MOT they need to attach a whole bunch of st they'll just remove again 10 mins later. I know an MOT centre who'll "pretend it was on the bike" when it's in a box next to the bike. That sort of common sense is what we're talking about.

I also know that the local Kwik-Fit replaced a complete set of tyres for someone only 6 weeks after her husband had fitted a complete set of tyres. That ended-up in court and they LOST because Kwik-Fit's lawyers defended their operative as saying he could only "advise her" - it was her choice to say "yes" and she should have known better!>?!>