Genuine parts or not?
Author
Discussion

greypianosflying

Original Poster:

86 posts

185 months

Tuesday 20th August 2013
quotequote all
Hi All.

My Ford Ka needs a new front wishbone. Would you pay £150 for a genuine ford wishbone, or use a non genuine one for £60?

For have quoted me £250 for the job all in, an indie £220 with for parts or £136 with pattern parts.

Not sure what to do! I rather like the handling of the Ka, so I'm worried about putting cheap parts in it.

The pattern parts the indie wants to use are made by First Line.

There again, the Ka is 5 years old and only worth 2k, so perhaps it doesn't warrant a £220 repair...

wemorgan

3,583 posts

209 months

Tuesday 20th August 2013
quotequote all
I'm surprised Ford are only £30 more. At that price I'd stick with OEM - they may even clean your car too wink

greypianosflying

Original Poster:

86 posts

185 months

Tuesday 20th August 2013
quotequote all
Yeah, it is a bit odd. Ford charge £50 more for labour, but they charge £20 less for the part, so overall they are only £30 more expensive.

If I went with the indie I would save another £28 MOT retest fee. (It failed the MOT).

So overall, £60 saving if I go for genunine parts, or £130 if I got for pattern parts over Ford.

mwstewart

8,613 posts

219 months

Tuesday 20th August 2013
quotequote all
Generally speaking most pattern part suspension components wear out a lot quicker than their OEM equivalents.

TheThing

960 posts

165 months

Tuesday 20th August 2013
quotequote all
Ive recently had bad expeiriences with pattern parts so id say stick with oem if you can afford it.

Jimbo.

4,238 posts

220 months

Tuesday 20th August 2013
quotequote all
greypianosflying said:
Hi All.

My Ford Ka needs a new front wishbone. Would you pay £150 for a genuine ford wishbone, or use a non genuine one for £60?

For have quoted me £250 for the job all in, an indie £220 with for parts or £136 with pattern parts.

Not sure what to do! I rather like the handling of the Ka, so I'm worried about putting cheap parts in it.

The pattern parts the indie wants to use are made by First Line.

There again, the Ka is 5 years old and only worth 2k, so perhaps it doesn't warrant a £220 repair...
Most of the time (£10 eBay ste aside), it's same factory, different doors for "non genuine" parts. Expensive, those Ford boxes!

And how on earth does a car being 5 y/o and "only" worth £2k not warrant such a repair? Jeez.

greypianosflying

Original Poster:

86 posts

185 months

Tuesday 20th August 2013
quotequote all
Jimbo. said:
Most of the time (£10 eBay ste aside), it's same factory, different doors for "non genuine" parts. Expensive, those Ford boxes!

And how on earth does a car being 5 y/o and "only" worth £2k not warrant such a repair? Jeez.
Well, it depends on how much longer you expect to keep the car.

HustleRussell

26,708 posts

191 months

Tuesday 20th August 2013
quotequote all
Jimbo. said:
Most of the time (£10 eBay ste aside), it's same factory, different doors for "non genuine" parts. Expensive, those Ford boxes!

And how on earth does a car being 5 y/o and "only" worth £2k not warrant such a repair? Jeez.
Not true. Occasionally, yes, but certainly not 'most of the time'.

'First line' is cheap nasty stuff. OEM or equivalent for me.

Andyjc86

1,149 posts

180 months

Tuesday 20th August 2013
quotequote all
It might be the way i'm reading it, but the ford quote appears to be for one, and the indi quote for both?

Ring up a motor factors and see what brands they have available, some are plain ste, first line being one of them

greypianosflying

Original Poster:

86 posts

185 months

Tuesday 20th August 2013
quotequote all
Indie quote is for one, as is the Ford.

The indie basically charges £20 more for the Ford part, yet is £50 cheaper in labour than Ford.

I would save on MOT retest fees if I went with the indie though.

DaveCWK

2,423 posts

205 months

Tuesday 20th August 2013
quotequote all
Genuine parts for me always unless the cheaper part is manufactured by a recognised oem-level supplier (Lemforder, Denso, Pagid etc)

greypianosflying

Original Poster:

86 posts

185 months

Tuesday 20th August 2013
quotequote all
Looks like I'll get it fixed at the Indie (who I've never had a bad experience with before). Tracking and Ford parts + fitting for £220.

Pretty steep. I should have fixed the issue myself before having it MOTd and saved £100.

Got to get them to fix it now though as I need the car on the road and I cant fix it myself for a few weeks.

I got it tested early, but I cant really drive it until I get the MOT passed. (It is a bit of a grey area, but if I had an accident I doubt the insurance company would be pleased!)

Podie

46,649 posts

306 months

Tuesday 20th August 2013
quotequote all
Buy the genuine part from Ford and get the indie to fit it.

Pattern parts often leads to problems - seen it time and time again. Buy cheap, but twice.

jamieduff1981

8,092 posts

171 months

Tuesday 20th August 2013
quotequote all
With the exception of some very specific known branded or custom made aftermarket parts for specific applications on specific cars, my experience of non OE parts has generally been poor.


mike9009

11,018 posts

274 months

Tuesday 20th August 2013
quotequote all
Jimbo. said:
Most of the time (£10 eBay ste aside), it's same factory, different doors for "non genuine" parts. Expensive, those Ford boxes!
.
Agreed it is often from the same factory, but what happens to the parts that don't quite meet Fords specification? This could be dimensional, mechanical proprties, rework allowances etc.

Mike

ModernAndy

2,094 posts

166 months

Tuesday 20th August 2013
quotequote all
The First Line part should be original equipment quality (different from fitted as original equipment). I'd buy the part yourself and get an Indy to quote you on labour only. First Line are a good company, I sell 6-figures of their parts a year with virtually no complaints.

jjones

4,492 posts

224 months

Tuesday 20th August 2013
quotequote all
ball joints are a good example, in my experience oem seem to last 6-8 years, pattern 2 years.

stick100

7,017 posts

199 months

Tuesday 20th August 2013
quotequote all
greypianosflying said:
Hi All.

My Ford Ka needs a new front wishbone. Would you pay £150 for a genuine ford wishbone, or use a non genuine one for £60?

For have quoted me £250 for the job all in, an indie £220 with for parts or £136 with pattern parts.

Not sure what to do! I rather like the handling of the Ka, so I'm worried about putting cheap parts in it.

The pattern parts the indie wants to use are made by First Line.

There again, the Ka is 5 years old and only worth 2k, so perhaps it doesn't warrant a £220 repair...
fk me if I charged them sort of prices I'd be in the Lamborghini forum not in general gassing lol

Limpet

6,629 posts

192 months

Tuesday 20th August 2013
quotequote all
Fitted a set of Quinton Hazell wishbones to my mum's StreetKa 3 yrs and about 28,000 miles ago. Fitted perfectly, and the car has just gone through another MOT with no problems. These were £30-something a side from my local factors.

The OE parts in this case are basically total crap. These arms, or more accurately the bushes in them are effectively a consumable. A known brand from a reputable outlet will be fine.

Edited by Limpet on Tuesday 20th August 21:57

stick100

7,017 posts

199 months

Tuesday 20th August 2013
quotequote all
Do your self a faver go on euro car parts website see how much that part costs then take a hard look at what is envolved in fitting it for fk sake it's two bolts and a ball joint bolt