Genuine parts or not?
Discussion
Hi All.
My Ford Ka needs a new front wishbone. Would you pay £150 for a genuine ford wishbone, or use a non genuine one for £60?
For have quoted me £250 for the job all in, an indie £220 with for parts or £136 with pattern parts.
Not sure what to do! I rather like the handling of the Ka, so I'm worried about putting cheap parts in it.
The pattern parts the indie wants to use are made by First Line.
There again, the Ka is 5 years old and only worth 2k, so perhaps it doesn't warrant a £220 repair...
My Ford Ka needs a new front wishbone. Would you pay £150 for a genuine ford wishbone, or use a non genuine one for £60?
For have quoted me £250 for the job all in, an indie £220 with for parts or £136 with pattern parts.
Not sure what to do! I rather like the handling of the Ka, so I'm worried about putting cheap parts in it.
The pattern parts the indie wants to use are made by First Line.
There again, the Ka is 5 years old and only worth 2k, so perhaps it doesn't warrant a £220 repair...
Yeah, it is a bit odd. Ford charge £50 more for labour, but they charge £20 less for the part, so overall they are only £30 more expensive.
If I went with the indie I would save another £28 MOT retest fee. (It failed the MOT).
So overall, £60 saving if I go for genunine parts, or £130 if I got for pattern parts over Ford.
If I went with the indie I would save another £28 MOT retest fee. (It failed the MOT).
So overall, £60 saving if I go for genunine parts, or £130 if I got for pattern parts over Ford.
greypianosflying said:
Hi All.
My Ford Ka needs a new front wishbone. Would you pay £150 for a genuine ford wishbone, or use a non genuine one for £60?
For have quoted me £250 for the job all in, an indie £220 with for parts or £136 with pattern parts.
Not sure what to do! I rather like the handling of the Ka, so I'm worried about putting cheap parts in it.
The pattern parts the indie wants to use are made by First Line.
There again, the Ka is 5 years old and only worth 2k, so perhaps it doesn't warrant a £220 repair...
Most of the time (£10 eBay sMy Ford Ka needs a new front wishbone. Would you pay £150 for a genuine ford wishbone, or use a non genuine one for £60?
For have quoted me £250 for the job all in, an indie £220 with for parts or £136 with pattern parts.
Not sure what to do! I rather like the handling of the Ka, so I'm worried about putting cheap parts in it.
The pattern parts the indie wants to use are made by First Line.
There again, the Ka is 5 years old and only worth 2k, so perhaps it doesn't warrant a £220 repair...
te aside), it's same factory, different doors for "non genuine" parts. Expensive, those Ford boxes!And how on earth does a car being 5 y/o and "only" worth £2k not warrant such a repair? Jeez.
Jimbo. said:
Most of the time (£10 eBay s
te aside), it's same factory, different doors for "non genuine" parts. Expensive, those Ford boxes!
And how on earth does a car being 5 y/o and "only" worth £2k not warrant such a repair? Jeez.
Well, it depends on how much longer you expect to keep the car.
te aside), it's same factory, different doors for "non genuine" parts. Expensive, those Ford boxes!And how on earth does a car being 5 y/o and "only" worth £2k not warrant such a repair? Jeez.
Jimbo. said:
Most of the time (£10 eBay s
te aside), it's same factory, different doors for "non genuine" parts. Expensive, those Ford boxes!
And how on earth does a car being 5 y/o and "only" worth £2k not warrant such a repair? Jeez.
Not true. Occasionally, yes, but certainly not 'most of the time'.
te aside), it's same factory, different doors for "non genuine" parts. Expensive, those Ford boxes!And how on earth does a car being 5 y/o and "only" worth £2k not warrant such a repair? Jeez.
'First line' is cheap nasty stuff. OEM or equivalent for me.
Looks like I'll get it fixed at the Indie (who I've never had a bad experience with before). Tracking and Ford parts + fitting for £220.
Pretty steep. I should have fixed the issue myself before having it MOTd and saved £100.
Got to get them to fix it now though as I need the car on the road and I cant fix it myself for a few weeks.
I got it tested early, but I cant really drive it until I get the MOT passed. (It is a bit of a grey area, but if I had an accident I doubt the insurance company would be pleased!)
Pretty steep. I should have fixed the issue myself before having it MOTd and saved £100.
Got to get them to fix it now though as I need the car on the road and I cant fix it myself for a few weeks.
I got it tested early, but I cant really drive it until I get the MOT passed. (It is a bit of a grey area, but if I had an accident I doubt the insurance company would be pleased!)
Jimbo. said:
Most of the time (£10 eBay s
te aside), it's same factory, different doors for "non genuine" parts. Expensive, those Ford boxes!
.
Agreed it is often from the same factory, but what happens to the parts that don't quite meet Fords specification? This could be dimensional, mechanical proprties, rework allowances etc.
te aside), it's same factory, different doors for "non genuine" parts. Expensive, those Ford boxes!.
Mike
greypianosflying said:
Hi All.
My Ford Ka needs a new front wishbone. Would you pay £150 for a genuine ford wishbone, or use a non genuine one for £60?
For have quoted me £250 for the job all in, an indie £220 with for parts or £136 with pattern parts.
Not sure what to do! I rather like the handling of the Ka, so I'm worried about putting cheap parts in it.
The pattern parts the indie wants to use are made by First Line.
There again, the Ka is 5 years old and only worth 2k, so perhaps it doesn't warrant a £220 repair...
fMy Ford Ka needs a new front wishbone. Would you pay £150 for a genuine ford wishbone, or use a non genuine one for £60?
For have quoted me £250 for the job all in, an indie £220 with for parts or £136 with pattern parts.
Not sure what to do! I rather like the handling of the Ka, so I'm worried about putting cheap parts in it.
The pattern parts the indie wants to use are made by First Line.
There again, the Ka is 5 years old and only worth 2k, so perhaps it doesn't warrant a £220 repair...
k me if I charged them sort of prices I'd be in the Lamborghini forum not in general gassing lolFitted a set of Quinton Hazell wishbones to my mum's StreetKa 3 yrs and about 28,000 miles ago. Fitted perfectly, and the car has just gone through another MOT with no problems. These were £30-something a side from my local factors.
The OE parts in this case are basically total crap. These arms, or more accurately the bushes in them are effectively a consumable. A known brand from a reputable outlet will be fine.
The OE parts in this case are basically total crap. These arms, or more accurately the bushes in them are effectively a consumable. A known brand from a reputable outlet will be fine.
Edited by Limpet on Tuesday 20th August 21:57
Gassing Station | General Gassing | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



