Why don't cars have...
Author
Discussion

300bhp/ton

Original Poster:

41,030 posts

221 months

Wednesday 21st August 2013
quotequote all
...

Recently I've seen a lot of speed traps while commuting to and from work, this got me thinking, with all the speed cameras and "zero tolerance" approach, why don't car makers help out the drivers a little more?

Maybe this has been done already, although I've not seen it.


In essence I'd like 6 easy to read and reach buttons from the drivers seat. These buttons should have default values for the vehicles intended market, but should be configurable, either by a dealer or by the on board computer most cars have these days.

Buttons 1 through 3 should be speed 'Limiters'. Set as 20mph, 30mph and 40mph.

This means, every time you enter a 30 zone, all you need to do is hit the "30" button and the car will prevent you exceeding this speed, this isn't cruise control as you can still slow and braking won't deactivate the mode. But what it would do is allow you to drive at a legal safe speed without needing to glue your face to your speedo and then forget to actually look were you are driving or for potential hazards.

Being as such a system would require user interaction to activate it, there would be no downside if you didn't want to use it.



Buttons 3 to 6 are a similar idea, but are pre-set cruise control speeds. Say 50mph, 60mph and 70mph. So when on dual carriage ways if it's clear enough to use cruise control you can simply hit one of these buttons and the car will do the rest. This is not really any different to regular cruise control, it just saves you having to faff about setting it at the "right" speed.

Rawwr

22,722 posts

265 months

Wednesday 21st August 2013
quotequote all
BMW, Peugeot and Mercedes definitely already offer speed limiters and cruise in the same system. Although not with the Fisher Price 'My First Car' buttons you desire.

mnkiboy

4,409 posts

197 months

Wednesday 21st August 2013
quotequote all
Why are 6 buttons easier than one button that says 'SET', as in regular cruise control?

B.J.W

5,877 posts

246 months

Wednesday 21st August 2013
quotequote all
Why not solve the problem altogether and get the car to drive for you as well.....



DaveH23

3,355 posts

201 months

Wednesday 21st August 2013
quotequote all
Why put extra tech in to cars that will only add weight, costs and complications when you already have your eyes and control of your right foot.

Bear Phils

891 posts

167 months

Wednesday 21st August 2013
quotequote all
Because cruise control is easy to use and similar enough to this system that it isn't worth the extra time and money.

Gaspode

4,167 posts

227 months

Wednesday 21st August 2013
quotequote all
My Honda CRV offers both cruise and limit controls, adjustable up and down in 1mph increments.

Snowboy

8,028 posts

182 months

Wednesday 21st August 2013
quotequote all
I had the same thought many years ago.
A set of limiters based on the speed limits.

As an idea it's reasonable.
But it solves a problem that should not exist; a driver should know their speed.
If you can't avoid speeding without these buttons then you shouldn't have a licence.

anonymous-user

85 months

Wednesday 21st August 2013
quotequote all
Wouldn't you forever be taking your eyes of the road to press buttons? Plus inevitably you'd forget and get a speeding ticket anyway smile

GetCarter

31,329 posts

310 months

Wednesday 21st August 2013
quotequote all
I find that the Mk 1 eyeball is very good at this wink

Debaser

8,698 posts

292 months

Wednesday 21st August 2013
quotequote all
Main reason would be lack of customer demand, and as always cost is a factor.

Regular speed limiters seem to satisfy current requirements.

anonymous-user

85 months

Wednesday 21st August 2013
quotequote all
Because before you know it, your car will simply refuse to pass an 30mph sign going more than 30mph! This tech would be incredibly easy to fit, and will probably happen at some point.

Mr Will

13,719 posts

237 months

Wednesday 21st August 2013
quotequote all
Why not just link it to the GPS and have one on/off button?

I believe BMW were actually trialling an even better system a while back. Not a speed limiter per se but a system that detected the speed limit of the road and simulated a notch in the throttle pedal travel which would rise and fall to maintain the appropriate speed as long as you kept the pedal on it. In the event that "emergency acceleration" was required, you could just push past the notch and go as fast as required.

Not sure what ever became of it, but it sounds ideal to me.

Polrules

394 posts

265 months

Wednesday 21st August 2013
quotequote all
Quite a lot of cars already have a system that does exactly this - on mine the limiter/cruise control is activated on a rocker switch on the steering wheel, very easy...


callmedave

2,686 posts

176 months

Wednesday 21st August 2013
quotequote all
Doesnt the new Focus have (speed) sign recognition thingy?

Not sure how it works, if its just a warning feature or restricts top speed?

C.A.R.

3,994 posts

219 months

Wednesday 21st August 2013
quotequote all
Because drivers are supposed to pay attention to what they're doing?

slinky

15,704 posts

280 months

Wednesday 21st August 2013
quotequote all
Polrules said:
Quite a lot of cars already have a system that does exactly this - on mine the limiter/cruise control is activated on a rocker switch on the steering wheel, very easy...

The same system is installed on the QashQai

300bhp/ton

Original Poster:

41,030 posts

221 months

Wednesday 21st August 2013
quotequote all
Snowboy said:
I had the same thought many years ago.
A set of limiters based on the speed limits.

As an idea it's reasonable.
But it solves a problem that should not exist; a driver should know their speed.
If you can't avoid speeding without these buttons then you shouldn't have a licence.
I don't agree with this. I think it is far more important to be looking at the road, the pavement and for other hazards than constantly checking to see if you are 1mph over the limit or not.

Not too mention most don't actually offer sufficient control not to sway an mph or two up or down, even when you think you are driving at a constant speed.

And to top it all, lots of cars don't even offer usable or accurate enough dials.

300bhp/ton

Original Poster:

41,030 posts

221 months

Wednesday 21st August 2013
quotequote all
Polrules said:
Quite a lot of cars already have a system that does exactly this - on mine the limiter/cruise control is activated on a rocker switch on the steering wheel, very easy...

But don't you have to actively go and set these and then activate/deactive them in a more contrived way? Admit the only one I've really used was on a p38a Range Rover.

DaveCWK

2,423 posts

205 months

Wednesday 21st August 2013
quotequote all
Can't think of anything worse than a speed limiter. How will I gun it to make the lights? wink
Standard cruise control is adequate if your feeling lazy.