Small car with biggish engine and proper slushbox auto?
Small car with biggish engine and proper slushbox auto?
Author
Discussion

lufbramatt

Original Poster:

5,694 posts

165 months

Monday 9th September 2013
quotequote all
Had a request from my MIL to find her a car. Her Toyota Aygo (with funny multimode semi-auto gearbox) looks like it's on it's way to car heaven thanks to some unfathomable electrical fault with the gearbox preventing it from starting, so she's looking for a replacement car. Garage reckon between £800 and £2000 to fix it depending on what they find when they take it to bits, she's really pissed off with it. It's an 08 plate so about a year outside warranty. Low milage but I think 4 years of her 3 miles each way town commute have killed it.

Apparently her favourite car that she's owned was her Suzuki baleno. It was a 1.6 with a slushbox auto and went pretty well. She want's to replicate that but in a new car. She hated the gearbox on the Aygo, fussy about what gear it wanted to be in, would occasionaly forget to select first when stationary and gear changes are eye-gougingly slow.

I have already suggested she buy a bike, and we did do some trial rides last year, but a slipped disk in her neck put an end to that idea.

I've had a look and am stumped, can't think of anything in that sector that fits the bill. Ideas?

jkh112

23,947 posts

189 months

Monday 9th September 2013
quotequote all
Nissan note 1.6 auto (which is a traditional torque convertor box).

Krikkit

27,941 posts

212 months

Monday 9th September 2013
quotequote all
Generally small cars either won't fit or don't get specced with a proper slushbox any more. Usually they're awful single or (rarely) twin-clutch jobs.

Go back in time a bit and you might find something, but big engine could be tricky. How big? Lots of auto Subarus out there with big boxers.

mike13

796 posts

213 months

Monday 9th September 2013
quotequote all
I've got a 1.6 normal auto Nissan Note,can't fault it,38 to the gallon in town,loads of room

lufbramatt

Original Poster:

5,694 posts

165 months

Monday 9th September 2013
quotequote all
Krikkit said:
Generally small cars either won't fit or don't get specced with a proper slushbox any more. Usually they're awful single or (rarely) twin-clutch jobs.

Go back in time a bit and you might find something, but big engine could be tricky. How big? Lots of auto Subarus out there with big boxers.
Yep that's the conclusion I came to. You can get polos and fabias with the DSG gearbox and a 1.4 engine. but they're pricey.

Looks like the current BMW MINI's have a torque-converter auto? I gather early ones had a CVT.

Nissan Note looks like it might fit the bill, good suggestion, cheers.

Toltec

7,179 posts

254 months

Monday 9th September 2013
quotequote all
The Suzuki Swift had a slushbox auto, not sure if the current one has, tried one about six years ago. We went for a used 325i compact in the end.

lufbramatt

Original Poster:

5,694 posts

165 months

Monday 9th September 2013
quotequote all
Just had a look, looks like the Nissan note 1.6 auto isn't available new any more, just a 1.2 CVT jobbie.

Rickyy

6,618 posts

250 months

Monday 9th September 2013
quotequote all
Kia Venga?

Not too sure what type of box it is, but states 4-spd Auto with a 1.6 Petrol engine, 7 year warranty will offer peace of mind.

http://www.kia.co.uk/new-cars/range/compact-cars/v...

valais

59,909 posts

186 months

Monday 9th September 2013
quotequote all
Why does she need a big engine for such a short commute?

Also worth approaching Toyota customer services, they might wish to contribute.

skyrover

12,700 posts

235 months

Monday 9th September 2013
quotequote all


AMC gremlin... availible with 6.6 litre V8

Not bad for a little economy car smile

lufbramatt

Original Poster:

5,694 posts

165 months

Monday 9th September 2013
quotequote all
valais said:
Why does she need a big engine for such a short commute?

Also worth approaching Toyota customer services, they might wish to contribute.
Personal preference really and occasionally they need to visit relatives in Southampton or go on holiday, the Aygo hasn't been fun on the motorway. Her experience of a small engine car with a single-clutch robotised manual has been crap, so she want to go back to a car with a bit more torque and a normal torque-converter auto. But it seems no-one makes them any more. . . health issues from lots of chemo and radiotherapy means she can't comfortably drive a manual any more.

Loving the Gremlin biggrin Is that what they had in Wayne's World?

The Wookie

14,209 posts

259 months

Monday 9th September 2013
quotequote all
Yaris Hybrid? Doesn't fit your specific description but fits the bill of small, smooth auto and not horrendously gutless.

skyrover

12,700 posts

235 months

Monday 9th September 2013
quotequote all
Nope... that was an AMC Pacer which only came with a 5.0 litre V8 frown


wiliferus

4,224 posts

229 months

Monday 9th September 2013
quotequote all
What about the default choice of the masses - You can get a Ford Focus in 1.6, 1.8, or 2.0 with an Auto - Not sure what type of auto they are though. I'm sure a Ford beard will be along shortly to advise smile

dibblecorse

7,662 posts

223 months

Monday 9th September 2013
quotequote all
I'd echo the Mini route, we have an old 05 plate with the CVT and in all honesty it is fine, apparently the new auto box is even better, we have done regular runs to Cornwall from London in it and it pulls well, holds speed easily, fairly economical (we're averaging 35mpg based on receipts and miles) for its general use of which most of it is mixed commuting with the odd motorway run ...

valais

59,909 posts

186 months

Monday 9th September 2013
quotequote all
Look at a late spec Merc A - class as a used car (not the new shape). Not everyones cup of tea, but they have great visibility, wheel at each corner, small, easy to park and good load space, etc. My ageing mother loves hers.

ArsE92

21,386 posts

218 months

Monday 9th September 2013
quotequote all
5-door 130i?

What?!

You said small with big engine.

eltax91

10,786 posts

237 months

Monday 9th September 2013
quotequote all
What about a Honda with the CVT?

surveyor

18,705 posts

215 months

Monday 9th September 2013
quotequote all
I hate it with a passion, but this sounds like the life of my in-laws who have a Yaris with a CVT.

Works well, sips juice, is surprisingly nice inside. Just don't follow them as they drive like a Yaris driver drives.

A slushbox is just as able to break as a CVT.

lufbramatt

Original Poster:

5,694 posts

165 months

Monday 9th September 2013
quotequote all
ArsE92 said:
5-door 130i?

What?!

You said small with big engine.
haha a 1-er isn't exactly small though! It's a metre longer than an aygo :-O