Diesel Estate ~£4k?
Author
Discussion

Hob Nob

Original Poster:

23 posts

224 months

Sunday 23rd February 2014
quotequote all
So, thanks to some blind reversing woman, my daily snotter is likely to be written off, so it's replacement time.

In short, I need a diesel estate - up to £4k. I would prefer something a little bit interesting, but it does get used for travelling between 2 different offices, so needs to be frugal. Because it's not being used for the most fun driving, i'll give up on that side of things for comfort, MPG & cheap running costs.

In an ideal world, i'd like an auto, but i'd compromise on that if needs be. if it's got a towbar, even better, as it will save me the expense of getting one fitted.

The usual suspects seem to be stuff like a 320D, occasionally they pop up in sport form, with an auto box, some early A4 SLine's creep into that budget, or the late B5 Passat's.

Anything i'm missing? Anyone seen anything kicking around near the south coast? I don't really fancy driving to the other side of the country for such a car...

Chapmanesque

52 posts

151 months

Sunday 23rd February 2014
quotequote all
Hob Nob said:
Anything i'm missing?
Saabs are the obvious one: 9-5 or 9-3. Plenty of autos around, as well.

Alfa 156 Sportwagen if you're feeling brave. Skoda Octavia Estate (vRS maybe) if you're not?

Hob Nob

Original Poster:

23 posts

224 months

Sunday 23rd February 2014
quotequote all
Thought about Saab's, not so sure about that. Definitely not brave enough for an Alfa..

Volvo V50? Seen a few sport models kicking around for that sort of money?

I've got a good VAG Indy up the road from me, which may be swaying my decision somewhat. Hardly exciting, I know, but they are generally reliable if looked after, plus they have a reasonable image if needed for work.


Alfahorn

7,825 posts

237 months

Sunday 23rd February 2014
quotequote all
Chapmanesque said:
Hob Nob said:
Anything i'm missing?
Saabs are the obvious one: 9-5 or 9-3. Plenty of autos around, as well.

Alfa 156 Sportwagen if you're feeling brave. Skoda Octavia Estate (vRS maybe) if you're not?
Certainly not the Alfa if it's auto you're after. Is the Skoda available in auto?

Alfahorn

7,825 posts

237 months

Sunday 23rd February 2014
quotequote all

73mark

774 posts

156 months

Sunday 23rd February 2014
quotequote all
Alfahorn said:
You disappoint me no Alfa jester

eltax91

10,760 posts

235 months

Sunday 23rd February 2014
quotequote all
Octavia TDi. Buy one with the PD engine. They are bombproof.

Either the vrs for much poke or the L & K spec for toys and comfort

eltax91

10,760 posts

235 months

Sunday 23rd February 2014
quotequote all
Like this one:-

http://bit.ly/Mlq8lN

Alfahorn

7,825 posts

237 months

Sunday 23rd February 2014
quotequote all
73mark said:
You disappoint me no Alfa jester
Nah, they're st, I wouldn't recommend someone buy one of these. The next door neighbours, milk mans, daughter goes out with a bloke who drinks with another bloke who once spoke to someone who's sisters, boyfriends father once owned an Alfa had nothing but trouble with it. That bloke had worked in the motor trade for a hundred years and said the engines were designed by Lego apparently.

73mark

774 posts

156 months

Sunday 23rd February 2014
quotequote all
Alfahorn said:
73mark said:
You disappoint me no Alfa jester
Nah, they're st, I wouldn't recommend someone buy one of these. The next door neighbours, milk mans, daughter goes out with a bloke who drinks with another bloke who once spoke to someone who's sisters, boyfriends father once owned an Alfa had nothing but trouble with it. That bloke had worked in the motor trade for a hundred years and said the engines were designed by Lego apparently.
Now that is class, rofl

Alfahorn

7,825 posts

237 months

Sunday 23rd February 2014
quotequote all
73mark said:
Alfahorn said:
73mark said:
You disappoint me no Alfa jester
Nah, they're st, I wouldn't recommend someone buy one of these. The next door neighbours, milk mans, daughter goes out with a bloke who drinks with another bloke who once spoke to someone who's sisters, boyfriends father once owned an Alfa had nothing but trouble with it. That bloke had worked in the motor trade for a hundred years and said the engines were designed by Lego apparently.
Now that is class, rofl
biggrin

Hob Nob

Original Poster:

23 posts

224 months

Sunday 23rd February 2014
quotequote all
From the outside, that Jag looks quite a nice choice, the inside however, looks like an old Fiat Punto centre console frown

Struggling to look past £2-3k on a reasonable Passat at the moment. E46's seem a bit thin on the ground in the local area. They fit the bill with most of my wishlist covered, but i'm not driving all over the countryside looking for a new car.

sideways man

1,669 posts

166 months

Sunday 23rd February 2014
quotequote all
Thinking about an x type estate myself,to replace my fabia 1.9 pdi estate.
Although the diesel jag won't beat it on mpg I fancy some luxury motoring.


Edited by sideways man on Sunday 23 February 17:45

eltax91

10,760 posts

235 months

Sunday 23rd February 2014
quotequote all
Hob Nob said:
From the outside, that Jag looks quite a nice choice, the inside however, looks like an old Fiat Punto centre console frown

Struggling to look past £2-3k on a reasonable Passat at the moment. E46's seem a bit thin on the ground in the local area. They fit the bill with most of my wishlist covered, but i'm not driving all over the countryside looking for a new car.
What's the passat got that the Octavia doesn't?

FFRR7

31 posts

152 months

Sunday 23rd February 2014
quotequote all
I'm looking for much the same for my wife. Here are some that I've looked at in the same price range:

Mercedes e270/280/320 cdi
BMW e46 330d
Volvo v70 d5
A4 Avant 1.9 130
Mondeo ST TDCi
Saab 9-5 Aero
Honda Accord 2.2 Tourer

I prefer the Accord or 9-5, she prefers the Merc or Volvo. I bet we end up in a bloody MPV

Hob Nob

Original Poster:

23 posts

224 months

Monday 24th February 2014
quotequote all
eltax91 said:
Hob Nob said:
From the outside, that Jag looks quite a nice choice, the inside however, looks like an old Fiat Punto centre console frown

Struggling to look past £2-3k on a reasonable Passat at the moment. E46's seem a bit thin on the ground in the local area. They fit the bill with most of my wishlist covered, but i'm not driving all over the countryside looking for a new car.
What's the passat got that the Octavia doesn't?
Personally, I feel the Passat is a slightly nicer place to be? I know that's of course subjective.

Little update, kept my eyes on EBay last night for new listings, managed to jump on a 54 plate Passat 1.9tdi Highline, that's only done ~100k, with a full extensive history for £2k that was local. Silver with black leather, looks very tidy.

Well under budget, it sounds cheap for what it is so will have a good nose around it. Maybe I've got lucky and nabbed a bargain.

RizzoTheRat

28,916 posts

221 months

Monday 24th February 2014
quotequote all
eltax91 said:
What's the passat got that the Octavia doesn't?
I'd guess the Passat might have slightly better soundproofing than the Octavia, I don't find it a problem but my Octavia is a bit nosier than some other cars. Not sure the vRS is available in automatic but the L&K certainly is.

Mondeo's worth a look for a budget diesel estate.