Replacing an E46 M3
Discussion
What the hell do people move on to after owning an E46 M if their pockets aren't exactly bulging? I can't think of any car below 20k that offers anything that the E46 doesn't, but I need a change.
Any thoughts?
So far I've been contemplating the CLK55 AMG, 2003 model, WRX STI anywhere from 2003-early 2006, an evo 5-8, and that's about where my list of potential cars ends currently. I know these turbo nutter cars wont be as fun/fast as the m3 standard but they have tuning potential which could keep me entertained for a longer time.
I don't care about practicality, I just need something ideally under 15k that will entertain me as much as the M3 did without ruining my wallet. I know some compromises will need to be made which is fine - I don't need 4 seats or very much practicality, MPG isn't an issue as my commute is walkable if needed.
I'd love a TVR but have no idea which particular models are considered reliable, if any at all?
So the question remains, what car will offer as much excitement as my M3, be under 15,000 to buy, be at least relatively reliable and not cost as much as a Nissan GTR to run?
Any ideas welcome chaps
Any thoughts?
So far I've been contemplating the CLK55 AMG, 2003 model, WRX STI anywhere from 2003-early 2006, an evo 5-8, and that's about where my list of potential cars ends currently. I know these turbo nutter cars wont be as fun/fast as the m3 standard but they have tuning potential which could keep me entertained for a longer time.
I don't care about practicality, I just need something ideally under 15k that will entertain me as much as the M3 did without ruining my wallet. I know some compromises will need to be made which is fine - I don't need 4 seats or very much practicality, MPG isn't an issue as my commute is walkable if needed.
I'd love a TVR but have no idea which particular models are considered reliable, if any at all?
So the question remains, what car will offer as much excitement as my M3, be under 15,000 to buy, be at least relatively reliable and not cost as much as a Nissan GTR to run?
Any ideas welcome chaps

Agree the E46 M3 is a tough car to replace as its very good at many things, for something a little different maybe a Z4M Coupe they feel a little bit more special with just the two seats, a TVR Chimaera are proven with the Rover V8 in it & at your budget you would get a very good one.
What about a 645i/650i lovely V8 to enjoy but maybe a little bit too much of a cruiser after the M3.
What about a 645i/650i lovely V8 to enjoy but maybe a little bit too much of a cruiser after the M3.
I wouldn't recommend the CLK as a replacement or the M3. You will be sorely disappointed! It's a great car in its own right, but a completely different proposition.
For Under 20k I really have no idea; most things feel soft or heavy compared to the E46.
Can you stretch to 25k for a good 997 Carerra? It's about the only thing I can think of.
Edit: Read the practicality requirement again. I'd save a little while and get into an Exige for around £21k.
For Under 20k I really have no idea; most things feel soft or heavy compared to the E46.
Can you stretch to 25k for a good 997 Carerra? It's about the only thing I can think of.
Edit: Read the practicality requirement again. I'd save a little while and get into an Exige for around £21k.
Edited by mwstewart on Thursday 13th March 11:37
mwstewart said:
I wouldn't recommend the CLK as a replacement or the M3. You will be sorely disappointed! It's a great car in its own right, but a completely different proposition.
For Under 20k I really have no idea; most things feel soft or heavy compared to the E46.
Can you stretch to 25k for a good 997 Carerra? It's about the only thing I can think of.
This is my problem, im struggling to justify getting myself a 15k car let alone a 20k one - and all I want is a car I can drive in where I wont be saying 'I wish I was in the M3 still..' but its proving next to impossible to find an alternative For Under 20k I really have no idea; most things feel soft or heavy compared to the E46.
Can you stretch to 25k for a good 997 Carerra? It's about the only thing I can think of.
I think the 997 would be a bit too much of a stretch for me to be honest, although I did come to the same conclusion about the 997 being the logical choice. The only car so far that ive thought of that could genuinely keep me entertained is a pretty highly tuned Evo or STI. Different kind of drive I know but maybe some mad turbo torque will distract me from the more subtle pleasures of how the M3 drives? Its a difficult situation to be in for me.
If you can live with the downgrading in interior and ride quality I would recommend a late Subaru WRX STI PPP or the latest Evo.
A lot more raw than the M3 but you can tick the 4wd FI box and they are HUGE fun!
I'm pretty sure a Boxster Spyder is prob out of the price range, unfortunately as is a Caymen R (which is one of the best cars I've ever driven).
A lot more raw than the M3 but you can tick the 4wd FI box and they are HUGE fun!

I'm pretty sure a Boxster Spyder is prob out of the price range, unfortunately as is a Caymen R (which is one of the best cars I've ever driven).
968 CS?
Depends which of the M3 qualities you wish to keep the most. An Impreza or Evo would be lots of fun, but I'd imagine they'd be less involving to drive than an M3, and also will not be as nice to sit in. I loved my Blobeye Impreza, but eventually I got tired of the 90's Jap interior
If I had another I think I'd take a good look at the hatch.
Spend a bit more and maybe find a 996 Turbo?
As you say - it's a tough one!
Depends which of the M3 qualities you wish to keep the most. An Impreza or Evo would be lots of fun, but I'd imagine they'd be less involving to drive than an M3, and also will not be as nice to sit in. I loved my Blobeye Impreza, but eventually I got tired of the 90's Jap interior
If I had another I think I'd take a good look at the hatch.Spend a bit more and maybe find a 996 Turbo?
As you say - it's a tough one!
HorneyMX5 said:
A mate of mine recently sold his E46 M3 Cab and stepped into a Cayman and is so far very happy.
The only thing concerning me about this is the lack of an LSD on the cayman models. I'm not sure how much I'd notice this in real driving or if its just me worrying. I have a horrible habit of getting bored of cars very fast so I want to maximise the chance I can have this one for more than a year.TTwiggy said:
Lotus Exige?
I think the best option would be something from Porsche. That budget gets you into a very good 996. Stretch it a little and you could be looking at a 996 turbo.
Exige is a great shout.I think the best option would be something from Porsche. That budget gets you into a very good 996. Stretch it a little and you could be looking at a 996 turbo.
Only problem with 996 Turbo, 911's etc is it's all a bit effortless.....not sure I'd put them in the 'exciting' bracket when moving away from the M3.....don't get me wrong, they are super fast but can you really enjoy the power without risking major points or disqualification??
I'm in the same boat and I'm not seeing anything below £25k that is very tempting.
£25k - £30k seems to be the entry point for significant upgrades to the E46 M3.
On the short list are:-
E92 M3 - More thirsty, not that special inside
C63 - More thirsty, much better interior from 2012 but out of range
997.1 - Reliability issues, want PDK
GTR - Running costs and car huge
XKR 5.0 - Very tempting, maybe too cramped
Vantage - Beautiful but no quicker in 4.3 guise, running costs
GranSport - Running costs again.
I'd need the replacement as a daily driver, 4 seats would be nice but not a necessity. I've got the funds now, just need to get around to sorting some test drives.
£25k - £30k seems to be the entry point for significant upgrades to the E46 M3.
On the short list are:-
E92 M3 - More thirsty, not that special inside
C63 - More thirsty, much better interior from 2012 but out of range
997.1 - Reliability issues, want PDK
GTR - Running costs and car huge
XKR 5.0 - Very tempting, maybe too cramped
Vantage - Beautiful but no quicker in 4.3 guise, running costs
GranSport - Running costs again.
I'd need the replacement as a daily driver, 4 seats would be nice but not a necessity. I've got the funds now, just need to get around to sorting some test drives.
crispyshark said:
Exige is a great shout.
Only problem with 996 Turbo, 911's etc is it's all a bit effortless.....not sure I'd put them in the 'exciting' bracket when moving away from the M3.....don't get me wrong, they are super fast but can you really enjoy the power without risking major points or disqualification??
996 C2 is very similar in terms of performance to the OPs existing M3, just a very different car to own & drive. I test drove a couple of E46 M3's & they just didn't get under my skin, absolutely love my 996 though & have owned it longer than any other car in 26 years of driving Only problem with 996 Turbo, 911's etc is it's all a bit effortless.....not sure I'd put them in the 'exciting' bracket when moving away from the M3.....don't get me wrong, they are super fast but can you really enjoy the power without risking major points or disqualification??

I have a VX220 NA, which obviously I think you would be a little bit disappointed pace wise coming from the M3.
But I would suggest looking for an NA that has a supercharger conversion or buying an NA & getting it supercharged. They normally put out about 250bhp for a stage 2 & the SC'd engine is supposed to be a much better drive than the VX220 Turbo.
Think costs are roughly £3k to get somebody to supercharge it for you. Head over to VX220.org if you require any further information.
But I would suggest looking for an NA that has a supercharger conversion or buying an NA & getting it supercharged. They normally put out about 250bhp for a stage 2 & the SC'd engine is supposed to be a much better drive than the VX220 Turbo.
Think costs are roughly £3k to get somebody to supercharge it for you. Head over to VX220.org if you require any further information.
solidlad84 said:
Does anyone have any experience of VX220s? Seems a much cheaper alternative to any of the Lotus offerings.
They're very much like the Elise, somewhere between the S1 and S2 in terms of refinement. Two engines available - a 2.2 N/A lump with about 140bhp and a 2.0 turbo with 200ish. In terms of handling, they're not quite as sharp as the Elise (although some relatively minor modifications rectify that) but they're still a damned slight better than almost anything else on the road. The N/A engine is a nice enough lump but not especially fast; the 2.0 turbo is fast but it's not as nice an engine. The turbo also had a slightly softer suspension setup than the N/A, for some reason. There is a VXR version with a more powerful (but apparently better setup) version of the turbo lump which also has some suspension and wheel modifications to make it drive much more like an Elise out of the box.
Like the Elise, they're not a car for perfectionists. They squeak and rattle and tend to leak if you don't keep the windows adjusted right. They suffer from much the same issues as the Elise (minus the engine specific ones, obviously) - nothing serious but quite a few niggles.
ETA: One thing the Elise/VX220/Europa will not do, is drive like a front engined car. They have enormous amounts of traction and a relatively light nose, meaning that if you're ham-fisted with one, it'll just under-steer. Whilst it's possible to power-slide one, it would be rather missing the point. They need to be driven delicately to get the best out of them.
Edited by kambites on Thursday 13th March 12:47
Gassing Station | General Gassing | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



