Lotus Exige V6 v Porsche 911
Lotus Exige V6 v Porsche 911
Author
Discussion

SidewaysSi

Original Poster:

10,742 posts

263 months

Saturday 22nd March 2014
quotequote all
Drove an Exige V6 today and been left stunned at its abilities. I know this has been said before but the car really is utterly superb. Brilliant steering and awesome chassis which copes so well with rutted roads whilst providing agile, roll free handling.

Performance is so strong throughout the rev range and it has plenty of low down torque. Gearchange is as good as anything out there, it looks stunning and really is everyday useable. Is there a more complete sports road car on sale? Not been in a 991 but not sure how it can be any better, particularly as it is knocking on double the price.

Lotus, I salute you...biggrin

chrispmartha

23,490 posts

158 months

Saturday 22nd March 2014
quotequote all
Must say I find this post strange, it's not really a V type thread if you haven't driven the other car you mention.

SlipStream77

2,153 posts

220 months

Saturday 22nd March 2014
quotequote all
Exige and 911 are totally different cars too.

edc

9,641 posts

280 months

Saturday 22nd March 2014
quotequote all
Evora perhaps more comparable to a 911.

chrispmartha

23,490 posts

158 months

Saturday 22nd March 2014
quotequote all
Anyway just to humour the OP I would imagine the 911 is far more luxurious inside plus has 2 extra seats, that's 2 things more it can offer.

kambites

71,466 posts

250 months

Saturday 22nd March 2014
quotequote all
The 911 isn't really a sports car these days, it's a GT. As such, comparing the Exige to the 911 is a bit meaningless - they're good at different things.

chrispmartha

23,490 posts

158 months

Saturday 22nd March 2014
quotequote all
kambites said:
The 911 isn't really a sports car these days, it's a GT. As such, comparing the Exige to the 911 is a bit meaningless - they're good at different things.
Quite, I wonder what other un similar cars the OP hasn't driven that he thinks the lotus is better than?

John D.

20,997 posts

238 months

Saturday 22nd March 2014
quotequote all
kambites said:
The 911 isn't really a sports car these days, it's a GT. As such, comparing the Exige to the 911 is a bit meaningless - they're good at different things.
GT3/RS?

Suppose you can have two Exige V6 for that kind of outlay though!


Ozzie Osmond

21,189 posts

275 months

Saturday 22nd March 2014
quotequote all
I had been waiting patiently for Lotus to come up with a proper 2-seat sportscar and was very excited to drive Exige V6.

Plus points
  • astounding performance from that Toyota engine
  • astounding handling
  • better looking than Evora
Minus points
  • very awkward to get in and out
  • appalling rear visibility
  • very cramped interior
Afterwards I drove straight to the Porsche dealer, tried their latest cars and bought one. Doesn't have the extreme performance of the Lotus but, for my requirements, much more suitable as a car. The Lotus is IMO more of a trackday special.

John D.

20,997 posts

238 months

Sunday 23rd March 2014
quotequote all
Ozzie Osmond said:
I had been waiting patiently for Lotus to come up with a proper 2-seat sportscar
They don't call you Ozzie 'Patience of a Saint' Osmond for nothing.

kambites

71,466 posts

250 months

Sunday 23rd March 2014
quotequote all
John D. said:
kambites said:
The 911 isn't really a sports car these days, it's a GT. As such, comparing the Exige to the 911 is a bit meaningless - they're good at different things.
GT3/RS?

Suppose you can have two Exige V6 for that kind of outlay though!
Three, probably. hehe

veevee

1,458 posts

180 months

Sunday 23rd March 2014
quotequote all
Ozzie Osmond said:
I had been waiting patiently for Lotus to come up with a proper 2-seat sportscar...
About time they made one of those!

Ozzie Osmond

21,189 posts

275 months

Sunday 23rd March 2014
quotequote all
That's a fair point! biggrin

As you may have gathered from my earlier post I had been really looking forward to arrival of Exige V6 and having a go in it. I thought the "convertible" model shown at Geneva (?) a couple of years ago looked astounding, without the boy-racer wing etc. Anyway, I guess I was hoping for something more in the direction of an Evora with more sensible packaging and better styling. In the event Lotus kept the Exige more in the "track" direction than I'd expected.

Exige V6 must be one of the quickest road-legal cars available for sale at any price. Unfortunately my road car needs aren't met by a road-legal racer. One day I'd still like to own a Lotus road car - let's hope they can get sorted out. It's a long time since they launched a car which brings the customers flocking to the door.

SidewaysSi

Original Poster:

10,742 posts

263 months

Sunday 23rd March 2014
quotequote all
chrispmartha said:
kambites said:
The 911 isn't really a sports car these days, it's a GT. As such, comparing the Exige to the 911 is a bit meaningless - they're good at different things.
Quite, I wonder what other un similar cars the OP hasn't driven that he thinks the lotus is better than?
This was meant more as a thought than anything particularly definitive. After driving it, I left thinking that for the traditional enthusiast that it provides a pretty compelling package and for me it was not a track day refugee at all.

It was perfectly comfortable, quiet and perfectly practical, providing a big boot was not needed. I even found it reasonably easy to get in and out. IMO it could easily be used as a daily driver and something that could easily deliver on a Euro trip.

It was this usability that meant I was thinking whether any improved NVH etc that a 911 would probably provide was really necessary for someone who enjoys driving as the Exige was simply sublime on the road.

chrispmartha

23,490 posts

158 months

Sunday 23rd March 2014
quotequote all
SidewaysSi said:
This was meant more as a thought than anything particularly definitive. After driving it, I left thinking that for the traditional enthusiast that it provides a pretty compelling package and for me it was not a track day refugee at all.

It was perfectly comfortable, quiet and perfectly practical, providing a big boot was not needed. I even found it reasonably easy to get in and out. IMO it could easily be used as a daily driver and something that could easily deliver on a Euro trip.

It was this usability that meant I was thinking whether any improved NVH etc that a 911 would probably provide was really necessary for someone who enjoys driving as the Exige was simply sublime on the road.
Well fair enough but it is rather odd to mention a car that isn't similar or competing in the same market.

I would have thought a cayman was closer to it than a 911

GC8

19,910 posts

219 months

Sunday 23rd March 2014
quotequote all
I prefer apples to oranges, although I haven't ever eaten an orange yet...

SidewaysSi

Original Poster:

10,742 posts

263 months

Sunday 23rd March 2014
quotequote all
GC8 said:
I prefer apples to oranges, although I haven't ever eaten an orange yet...
Agreed. However if you have had a few mandarins in your time you may have a reasonable idea what to expect.

SidewaysSi

Original Poster:

10,742 posts

263 months

Sunday 23rd March 2014
quotequote all
chrispmartha said:
Well fair enough but it is rather odd to mention a car that isn't similar or competing in the same market.

I would have thought a cayman was closer to it than a 911
Absolutely. However it could also be argued that an Exige does provide something for ex 997 customers.