Reliable workhorse
Author
Discussion

Hubris

Original Poster:

184 posts

166 months

Sunday 23rd March 2014
quotequote all
Right, I quite clear manufacturers of modern cars have no idea how to fix them when they go wrong. It's a case of plug into a laptop, read fault codes and hope the fault relates to the part that needs fixing/replacing.

More often than not, with today's, overly complicated electrics it is pure guesswork while the poor owner throws money in the "technician's" direction until they find out what's wrong.

After having my fingers (and wallet) burned by modern diesels, can anyone recommend me a simple, modern-ish (under 7 or so years old) N/A petrol family car that is:

a) Bulletproof reliability (this is a must)
b) Big boot for kid's crap
c) Reasonably economical (+35mpg minimum)

all under £6000 or so

To summarise: NO diesels, NO turbos, NO hybrids, NO gas guzzlers and no VAG cars, if possible.

Cheers.

surveyor

18,690 posts

213 months

Sunday 23rd March 2014
quotequote all
Your criteria is not possible to meet.

You need to compromise on either size, fuel, or mpg I reckon.

Nearest I can suggest is a Volvo V70 - but the Petrol's are mostly turbo'd, and 35 only achievable on a run.

Matt UK

18,084 posts

229 months

Sunday 23rd March 2014
quotequote all
Something German from the 80s (Merc 190e / e34 BMW 5 series)

Or something Japanese from the 90s.

Your purchase budget will go far.

roofer

5,136 posts

240 months

Sunday 23rd March 2014
quotequote all
You're criteria is boring, ahhm oot.

anonymous-user

83 months

Sunday 23rd March 2014
quotequote all
I run a 60k mile BMW 318i SE 4 door Saloon 2002 reg as my daily smoker

It has the 2.0l 16v Valvetronic engine and about 150hp

Loads of boot space

Great interior room

Looks perfectly fine and respectable

Its rattle and squeak free, 35mpg mixed driving

They can be bought for £2500 and imho are a bulletproof bargain


kiethton

14,644 posts

209 months

Sunday 23rd March 2014
quotequote all
Ford mondeo?

Either old shape (for well under half of budget) or one of the newer ones

Hubris

Original Poster:

184 posts

166 months

Sunday 23rd March 2014
quotequote all
Sorry, should have said mentioned - no saloons, either.

Nigel Worc's

8,121 posts

217 months

Sunday 23rd March 2014
quotequote all
Your quest is just about impossible I'm afraid.

You need to buy new, and possibly go for the Kia 7 year/100,000 mile, or the Hyundai 5 year unlimited warranties.

My mates son is staring at an £8K bill on his owned from new, just out of warranty, 3 year old, 60,000 mile, Mazda 6.

Or, you can go old, where the repairs are just cheaper.

Troubleatmill

10,210 posts

188 months

Sunday 23rd March 2014
quotequote all
Mondeo estate?

Fattyfat

3,310 posts

225 months

Sunday 23rd March 2014
quotequote all
Nigel Worc's said:
My mates son is staring at an £8K bill on his owned from new, just out of warranty, 3 year old, 60,000 mile, Mazda 6.

Or, you can go old, where the repairs are just cheaper.
What on earth could generate a 8k bill on a newish Mazda??

To think I was having a moan this week about a £273 bill on a 9 year old 120K Toyota

Edited by Fattyfat on Sunday 23 March 21:18

Deerfoot

5,240 posts

213 months

Sunday 23rd March 2014
quotequote all
Nigel Worc's said:
My mates son is staring at an £8K bill on his owned from new, just out of warranty, 3 year old, 60,000 mile, Mazda 6.
£8,000? What on earth has happened to generate a bill that size on a reasonably young car?

Matt UK

18,084 posts

229 months

Sunday 23rd March 2014
quotequote all
Nigel Worc's said:
My mates son is staring at an £8K bill on his owned from new, just out of warranty, 3 year old, 60,000 mile, Mazda 6.
Blimey, how close is that to a finacial write-off?

Jazzer77

1,533 posts

223 months

Sunday 23rd March 2014
quotequote all
Closest I can think of is a Honda Accord 2.0 Estate.
May get close to 35mpg with a sympathetic driver.

Ecosseven

2,364 posts

246 months

Sunday 23rd March 2014
quotequote all
2.0 Duratech Mondeo would be my choice.

Nigel Worc's

8,121 posts

217 months

Sunday 23rd March 2014
quotequote all
Deerfoot said:
Nigel Worc's said:
My mates son is staring at an £8K bill on his owned from new, just out of warranty, 3 year old, 60,000 mile, Mazda 6.
£8,000? What on earth has happened to generate a bill that size on a reasonably young car?
It's a diesel !

Screwed turbo, broken cams, lots and lots of engine issues, car is full Mazda service history, and yes, very very close to a financial write off.

Sorry for the hijack OP, as you've stated no diesels, I guess you've been here !

AnotherClarkey

3,698 posts

218 months

Sunday 23rd March 2014
quotequote all
Might be a bit premature to write off hybrids - a Prius is a very simple, bulletproof n/a petrol car.

pkrplyr

285 posts

212 months

Sunday 23rd March 2014
quotequote all
To get that kind of mpg from a family car, it's going to be pretty under powered.
Honda CRV ticks most of the boxes and you get about 31 mpg...


MondeoMan1981

2,457 posts

212 months

Sunday 23rd March 2014
quotequote all
You'll get a facelift mk3 Mondeo and plenty change for that. Both the 1.8 and 2.0 petrol will do you a good job.

eltax91

10,756 posts

235 months

Sunday 23rd March 2014
quotequote all
Jazzer77 said:
Closest I can think of is a Honda Accord 2.0 Estate.
May get close to 35mpg with a sympathetic driver.
Yep. I'm getting low 30's out of my 2.4

Dodsy

7,175 posts

256 months

Sunday 23rd March 2014
quotequote all
Nigel Worc's said:
It's a diesel !
Thats why I bought a 2007 V8 Jag wink £5k (and still climbing) of bills so far this year all paid for by Jaguar under warranty :-) It often pays to keep up with the warranty, it may cost a lot but as a car gets older it easily pays for itself