Dilemma - What would you do?
Dilemma - What would you do?
Author
Discussion

ST86Dave

Original Poster:

289 posts

155 months

Saturday 26th April 2014
quotequote all
So as of next month, I'll be moving to Cambridgeshire, due to a new job at existing company, which includes nice pay rise and company car.

So.... with about 2 years left on the ST, I'm debating whether to:

Keep the ST, and just play around with mods with the extra cash once finance is paid.

Get an RS

Look at something completely different M3/C63

I love the ST and since it will no longer be a daily driver, it can be properly looked after and used on weeekends only, but its had 44k put on it in 2 1/2 years, the paintwork needs a good seeing to, and there are a few niggles, suspension, potentially driveshaft issues which will need seeing to. The cabin rattles like hell and I would really like something a bit more standout than a PB FL ST. It's not getting any younger either, but it's had a fair amount of money spent on it (RS clutch, block mod) and would seem silly to waste it.

RS seems like the natural progression, but I'm not sure I like it as much as the ST, I see them every now and again and they really do turn my head but then when I look at them on AutoTrader and such like I'm not 100% sure that i like the styling, i guess the only way to find out is to go and look at one properly, even drive it. Do they suffer the same build quality/cabin rattle issues and the ST? The plus side is I know the running costs aren't that much different to the ST, and it's a car I'm fairly familiar with.

M3/C63's are cars I've always loved, look and sound fantastic, but running costs are naturally an awful lot more, as well as the up front cost, and I'm not sure I could justify the extra outlay if I'm only using it on weekends.

Thoughts/alternatives?

Thanks

Dave

belleair302

7,008 posts

236 months

Saturday 26th April 2014
quotequote all
Keep the ST and improve it, or get a real weekend toy or a track day wonder.....I would stay away from C63's etc unless you are ready for what may be serious running costs on something that wont get used that often. There are better ways to spend any spare money than with mechanics and servicing bills.

ST86Dave

Original Poster:

289 posts

155 months

Saturday 26th April 2014
quotequote all
belleair302 said:
Keep the ST and improve it, or get a real weekend toy or a track day wonder.....I would stay away from C63's etc unless you are ready for what may be serious running costs on something that wont get used that often. There are better ways to spend any spare money than with mechanics and servicing bills.
Go wrong do they?

Fantuzzi

3,297 posts

175 months

Saturday 26th April 2014
quotequote all
Buy a proper weekend car sell the st.


ST86Dave

Original Poster:

289 posts

155 months

Saturday 26th April 2014
quotequote all
Fantuzzi said:
Buy a proper weekend car sell the st.
Like?

HaloGen8

1,413 posts

158 months

Saturday 26th April 2014
quotequote all
Cut losses with ST

Buy a Caterham for the weekend.

Job done.

ST86Dave

Original Poster:

289 posts

155 months

Saturday 26th April 2014
quotequote all
HaloGen8 said:
Cut losses with ST

Buy a Caterham for the weekend.

Job done.
A two seater is not an option. Want something fairly practical, ie four seats and a boot big enough for golf clubs.

Codswallop

5,258 posts

223 months

Saturday 26th April 2014
quotequote all
ST86Dave said:
Fantuzzi said:
Buy a proper weekend car sell the st.
Like?
I'm guessing Fantuzzi meant something like an Elise, VX220, Caterfield/ other lairy track refugee.

It would certainly be what I would do if I had a sensible car for daily duties.

Mastodon2

14,323 posts

194 months

Saturday 26th April 2014
quotequote all
ST86Dave said:
Like?
Like a Caterham, or better yet, a bike. That's fun taken care of, without spending on something that will have enormous running costs.

Ved

3,949 posts

204 months

Saturday 26th April 2014
quotequote all
Company car or is there an option for a car allowance?

Tickle

6,449 posts

233 months

Saturday 26th April 2014
quotequote all
ST86Dave said:
HaloGen8 said:
Cut losses with ST

Buy a Caterham for the weekend.

Job done.
A two seater is not an option. Want something fairly practical, ie four seats and a boot big enough for golf clubs.
Elise or Caterham would of been my first thoughts

Cant the company car fit the clubs and 3 passengers in?

ST86Dave

Original Poster:

289 posts

155 months

Saturday 26th April 2014
quotequote all
Company car. And I want to keep it for company purposes only. It's not special enough to use for social and domestic lol

ryandoc

276 posts

184 months

Saturday 26th April 2014
quotequote all
If funds permit keep the weekend driver ST. I've got a daily driver and weekend car which I've have 4.5 years and because I'm not driving it every day is the main reason I've kept it so long as I buzz to get into it.


ST86Dave

Original Poster:

289 posts

155 months

Saturday 26th April 2014
quotequote all
ryandoc said:
If funds permit keep the weekend driver ST. I've got a daily driver and weekend car which I've have 4.5 years and because I'm not driving it every day is the main reason I've kept it so long as I buzz to get into it.
Whats your weekend car?

Clivey

5,681 posts

233 months

Saturday 26th April 2014
quotequote all
ST86Dave said:
A two seater is not an option. Want something fairly practical, ie four seats and a boot big enough for golf clubs.
E46 M3?

You can now get "value service" on them from BMW dealers, so not as expensive as you might think.

ST86Dave

Original Poster:

289 posts

155 months

Saturday 26th April 2014
quotequote all
Clivey said:
E46 M3?

You can now get "value service" on them from BMW dealers, so not as expensive as you might think.
I quite like the look of them, but they sound horrible imo.

Mastodon2

14,323 posts

194 months

Saturday 26th April 2014
quotequote all
ST86Dave said:
I quite like the look of them, but they sound horrible imo.
Are your ears broken?

ST86Dave

Original Poster:

289 posts

155 months

Saturday 26th April 2014
quotequote all
Mastodon2 said:
Are your ears broken?
No, but not everyone has the same taste...

danjama

5,728 posts

171 months

Saturday 26th April 2014
quotequote all
Get a Subaru Impreza or Mitsubishi Lancer of some sort.

ST86Dave

Original Poster:

289 posts

155 months

Saturday 26th April 2014
quotequote all
danjama said:
Get a Subaru Impreza or Mitsubishi Lancer of some sort.
Not keen on jap cars, servicing and running costs aren't much better than german and the interior quality are a long way behind