RE: £100K Garage: Jamie Stokes
RE: £100K Garage: Jamie Stokes
Friday 14th November 2014

£100K Garage: Jamie Stokes

Half may have gone on a Lotus racer but there's plenty more besides in Jamie's selection



Name: Jamie Stokes
Previously owned: Peugeot 106, Land Rover Discovery Gen 1, Mitsubishi L200 Warrior (a proper handful in the wet, really), Nissan Navara, Mazda MX-5 NB 1.8is, Subaru Impreza WRX, VW Golf GTI Edition 30, Aston Martin V8 Vantage 4.3
Currently owned: Land Rover Freelander SD4, 1984 911 Carrera, Caterham 7 Academy Racer (soon to become Roadsport spec)
On the shortlist: "I've been toying with something Italian and mid-engined for a while now. I'm also a sucker for American muscle cars so the new Mustang is definitely on my radar, though I will wait until I can get something with a snake badge."



Renault Clio Williams
Cost:
£5,750
Balance: £94,250
Why I chose it: "I know it's becoming a bit of a feature staple to throw a classic hot hatch in at the end to mop up the rest of the budget, but this is my first choice. No garage is complete without a hot hatch and in my opinion this is one of the best. I'll admit it was a toss up between this and a V6; the Williams won out as it is slightly less likely to kill me."

Mitsubishi Lancer Evolution VI Tommi Makinen Edition
Cost:
£13,495
Balance: £80,755
Why I chose it: "How could I do a fantasy garage without at least one road going rally car? I may be showing my age slightly but when I was young these were dominating the WRC, with Tommi right at the top of his game. Since then I've been desperate to own one, in red, with the stickers. If I stumbled across a standard one when I had the spare cash I would buy it with no hesitations. But the longer I wait the more are getting messed with which is a shame."


Lotus Exige GT3
Cost:
£49,995
Balance: £30,760
Why I chose it: "Having just completed the Caterham Academy I've really got the racing bug. I'm not very good, but I've got the bug. This looks like an awesome way to step up to 'proper' racing cars as it's eligible for quite a few championships. And as if that's not enough the vendor has photographed it with a Harrier Jump Jet. As far as ways to make an already cool car cooler this vendor has nailed it."

Skoda Yeti 2.0 TDI 4x4
Cost:
£13,995
Balance: £16,765
Why I chose it: "My practical choice. Go anywhere, throw the dog in the back and so on. This will be the car that has to deal with all life can throw at it. It's hard wearing and unpretentious. I've never driven one but contemporary road tests said it was also a good steer and this one's a manual. Hopefully that will make for a win-win situation, so long as I can persuade the other half that it's OK to arrive in a Skoda."


Mini Cooper S JCW GP
Cost:
£12,995
Balance: £3,770
Why I chose it: "The ultimate of R53 Minis; do I need any more of a reason? OK then. I nearly bought one a couple of years ago and still want one. I love the uncompromising nature of cars like these, a GT3 for the hot hatch lover. I nearly put an R26.R in place of this but I've already got my favourite Renault on this list and they are still a load more money. Feel free to say how stupid this decision is..."

Mazda MX5 1.8i NB
Cost:
£3,000
Balance: £770
Why I chose it: "I need a convertible, and a motoring cliche (it is PistonHeads after all). This is close to the one I used to own, and it really did answer every question I asked of it. I loved it, easily the most fun I've had on the public roads and I can't think of a good reason not to have one back in my life again. This looks like it's in reasonable condition too.

"With the last £770, fuel would probably be useful but it would more likely go on some track time in my new race car. It would be embarrassing to be at the back of the field in that too."





Author
Discussion

matt1269

Original Poster:

598 posts

204 months

Friday 14th November 2014
quotequote all
Good selection!

vtecyo

2,122 posts

159 months

Friday 14th November 2014
quotequote all
Great choices other than the Clio (as well as the Mini?) and Lotus (personal meh)

Clivey

5,695 posts

234 months

Friday 14th November 2014
quotequote all
2 hot hatches and a Skoda Yeti? I think I'd rather just one hatch to do all the practical stuff and spend the rest on toys. I need to give the £100k garage a go sometime. biggrin

lindrup119

1,235 posts

173 months

Friday 14th November 2014
quotequote all
Great choices, wouldn't have gone for both the Clio and the Mini though, would have subbed one out for a barge.

dlockhart

434 posts

202 months

Friday 14th November 2014
quotequote all
lindrup119 said:
Great choices, wouldn't have gone for both the Clio and the Mini though, would have subbed one out for a barge.
I agree the lack of wafting in here means there's one of the things on my list unticked.

rickyquicky

54 posts

201 months

Friday 14th November 2014
quotequote all
vtecyo said:
Great choices other than the Clio (as well as the Mini?) and Lotus (personal meh)
Why not the Williams? smiles per pound its the best car in the selection, have you ever driven one?

I can understand the Mini - there's many alternatives for £13k.


mgbond

6,749 posts

262 months

Friday 14th November 2014
quotequote all
Not bad.

However I was looking at the Ginetta G40R cars and for a road going ready to race car at 30k I would have thought this was a better option than the Lotus. I'm sure the price also include a race season?

Dale487

1,469 posts

153 months

Friday 14th November 2014
quotequote all
Clio & Mini are both fab hot hatches - completely understand why they are both there.

The EVO is the best of they ever made.

And the Skoda covers every day to day eventuality - I'd have one in my £100K garage too.

lindrup119

1,235 posts

173 months

Friday 14th November 2014
quotequote all
I'd probably swap the Mini and the MX-5 for something a la:





Evo in that shape is a top choice though.

jmesgotav8

99 posts

180 months

Friday 14th November 2014
quotequote all
There is no barge in here because I have no need or want for one. I guess I just don't get the whole barge attitude, as far as I'm concerned anything with cruise control and a radio is perfect for the motorway. And both the mini and the yeti have those.


jmesgotav8

99 posts

180 months

Friday 14th November 2014
quotequote all
Should probably point out this is my 100k garage...

Rumblestripe

4,093 posts

192 months

Friday 14th November 2014
quotequote all
Good choices. Especially approve of the Yeti as the "tick all the boxes pretty good at everything" everyday motor. I'd lose the mini though (not a fan) and see if I could stretch the budget to a Honda S2000 or a Porsche Boxster for my open air fix.

smithyithy

7,920 posts

148 months

Friday 14th November 2014
quotequote all
jmesgotav8 said:
There is no barge in here because I have no need or want for one. I guess I just don't get the whole barge attitude, as far as I'm concerned anything with cruise control and a radio is perfect for the motorway. And both the mini and the yeti have those.
I can see that. I don't like big cars, and would happily skip any barges / SUV's to just have a garage full of hot hatches and little sports cars smile

smilo996

3,859 posts

200 months

Friday 14th November 2014
quotequote all
It is an interesting list. Can see the logic of the MX5, Lotus, Mitsub and the Clio.

Cannot see the logic of the Mini, much too bouffant, Chelsea and given the rest of the list excess to requirements.

The Yeti, other and better alternatives available from within the Audi Group, other German companies and even further afield.

Well argued, varied and thought provoking choices which is the point!

RoadRunner220

1,312 posts

223 months

Friday 14th November 2014
quotequote all
Very good choices, I'd be happy with that garage.

mnx42

215 posts

193 months

Sunday 16th November 2014
quotequote all
I like your choices. I wouldn't have a barge in my £100K garage either. Williams, Mini GP, Yeti, Makinen all would be in mine.

Edited by mnx42 on Sunday 16th November 11:56

Marchutch

133 posts

156 months

Sunday 16th November 2014
quotequote all
smilo996 said:
It is an interesting list. Can see the logic of the MX5, Lotus, Mitsub and the Clio.

Cannot see the logic of the Mini, much too bouffant, Chelsea and given the rest of the list excess to requirements.

The Yeti, other and better alternatives available from within the Audi Group, other German companies and even further afield.

Well argued, varied and thought provoking choices which is the point!
I'll take you out in my GP on track some time if you want. You'll see just how 'bouffant' and 'Chelsea' it really is. Don't knock it till you've tried it.....

JMF894

6,627 posts

185 months

Sunday 16th November 2014
quotequote all
Lose the MX5. A sportscar should be loud, aggressive, rather hirsute and a little bit scary with a big engine. Everything the Mazda is not.

Lose the Mini because it is an oxymoron. Just like the Renault R26R etc, I will never, ever understand the point of going to all that trouble with what is, and always will be a front drive hatch. Once you ditch the rear seats you are missing the point entirely with a 'hot hatch'. Given the original price of these stripped out minimalist front drivers surely a true petrolhead is able to choose any manner of rear engined/mid engined/rear drive combos that have a proper pedigree?

And get a barge cos surely any true enthusiast wants enough cars to cover every eventuality. We all want to waft effortlessly with reserves of power when the right occasion presents itself.

Me? A TVR Sag, an S8, a Cayman S and some fuel.

Sorted.

Jimbo


daytona365

1,773 posts

194 months

Sunday 16th November 2014
quotequote all
Could have saved 95k and just bought the Clio. Possibly the only car here with any merit......Yeh, I know, the Lotus. Completely overrated.

Marchutch

133 posts

156 months

Monday 17th November 2014
quotequote all
JMF894 said:
Lose the Mini because it is an oxymoron. Just like the Renault R26R etc, I will never, ever understand the point of going to all that trouble with what is, and always will be a front drive hatch. Once you ditch the rear seats you are missing the point entirely with a 'hot hatch'. Given the original price of these stripped out minimalist front drivers surely a true petrolhead is able to choose any manner of rear engined/mid engined/rear drive combos that have a proper pedigree?
If you are talking about buying them new then I sort of agree. But at second hand prices, these sorts of cars offer affordable fun (and lots of it!) to people who cannot afford to run more expensive machines. As a general rule, a well sorted rwd car would typically cost more than a well sorted fwd car.

Granted, they were probably driven by people who owned them because they could afford them, rather than because they knew how to drive them properly close to the limit, but the number of very expensive rwd cars I have overtaken at track days is testament to how much fun you can have in a little car like this, without breaking the bank :-)