Best convertible £15,000-£20,000
Best convertible £15,000-£20,000
Author
Discussion

PompeyPaul

Original Poster:

519 posts

214 months

Monday 9th March 2015
quotequote all
So that time of year is coming....

What would you consider the best convertible for £15,000-£20,000?

Needs to look good, have good perfomance and sound nice. Also 100% relaible as a daily for motorway and town driving, circa 12,000 miles per year. Also a bonus is a retractable hardtop such as the SLK AMG, to make i more pleasant all year round.

I have previously had an MX5 and want somnething different before that is suggested. Elise not practical enough / comfortable enough as a daily.

Initial thoughts are:

SLK AMG
BMW 135i
BMW Z4M
Porsche Boxster (but likely to be gen 1 with bore score risk)

Anyone that can make comment about the above, especially with experience of owning or driving mulitple would be great. Any other suggestions also be interested to hear.

kambites

71,718 posts

252 months

Monday 9th March 2015
quotequote all
If you're after a wonderfully characterful cruiser, the SLK is a fabulous thing.

If you're after a drivers' car which can also be used as a comfortable cruiser when required, the Boxster is impossible to beat, IMO.

The SLK's chassis is pretty good but I really couldn't get on with the gearbox for fun driving.



ETA: The Z4M sits somewhere between the two in both respects.

Edited by kambites on Monday 9th March 10:14

Al U

2,395 posts

162 months

Monday 9th March 2015
quotequote all
You will get the priciest examples of an S2000 for under the lower end of your budget, with the exception of a Z4M (and even then I'd much prefer the coupe) or an SLK55 I'd prefer it to anything on your list. Values appear to be going north too. I am biased though. FWIW I am doing 52 miles a day in mine on the m25 with no problems, got the hardtop on at the moment but it will be coming off at the end of the month.

gracey

11 posts

249 months

Monday 9th March 2015
quotequote all
I owned a MX5 mk 1 with the 1800 engine, for the money it was a blast.
It was stolen and written off, I then went the whole hog and bought a seal grey Boxster S with metropole blue leather and blue roof. Never used the stereo as the sound from the flat 6 behind your head was phenomenal. Couldn't believe the looks the car got too despite it being 10 years old.

Nothing wrong with the car but needed a change, took the risk and bought an SL55. Again the sound of the V8 is priceless.

Would certainly have another Boxster, plus has the advantage of two boots!!

d3llams

121 posts

157 months

Monday 9th March 2015
quotequote all
It doesn't have to be german to be reliable you could consider a Nissan 370Z http://www.pistonheads.com/classifieds/used-cars/n... it has a muscle car brute but it still won't sound like the SLK AMG


derin100

5,217 posts

274 months

Monday 9th March 2015
quotequote all
I've just bought a very nice Z4 3.0Si. One would be well under your budget. I'd also considered a Z4M but after much thought decided that the 3.0Si was a better option for me. The cheaper purchase price (about £5K less than an M) and running costs (longer service intervals, fuel consumption and no M road tax) but still strong performance were the main attractions.

I took it for a drive through the roads around the Snowdonia National Park at the weekend. I'm also glad that I made this choice performance-wise as it was easily fast enough to quickly run out of road (and in my case driver ability) before it ran out of performance. As an ex-CSL owner I know that realistically in the U.K, on public roads (rather than a track), the M-car's performance are largely wasted.

I know that figures on paper don't paint the whole picture but with a 0-60 time of 0.7s slower than the M...just a thought worth considering as an alternative?


illmonkey

19,842 posts

229 months

Monday 9th March 2015
quotequote all
derin100 said:
I've just bought a very nice Z4 3.0Si. One would be well under your budget. I'd also considered a Z4M but after much thought decided that the 3.0Si was a better option for me. The cheaper purchase price (about £5K less than an M) and running costs (longer service intervals, fuel consumption and no M road tax) but still strong performance were the main attractions.

I took it for a drive through the roads around the Snowdonia National Park at the weekend. I'm also glad that I made this choice performance-wise as it was easily fast enough to quickly run out of road (and in my case driver ability) before it ran out of performance. As an ex-CSL owner I know that realistically in the U.K, on public roads (rather than a track), the M-car's performance are largely wasted.

I know that figures on paper don't paint the whole picture but with a 0-60 time of 0.7s slower than the M...just a thought worth considering as an alternative?

+1. The Z4M is fantastic, but I think I drove my slower than the 3.0 I had previously. You could push on in the 3.0 on the roads, but in the M, it was just too much. Although the noise and the way it lifted on full chat from some lights etc, brilliant.

krisdelta

4,673 posts

232 months

Monday 9th March 2015
quotequote all
The Z4M is a cracking choice, but I'd want to drive the SLK55 if the idea of a throbbing V8 tickles you thus. I miss the noise of a V8, but the Z4MR counters nicely by being mentally quick, if you so choose. smile Values for both are on the up - so probably not a bad shout, whichever way you go.

jep

1,183 posts

240 months

Monday 9th March 2015
quotequote all
If the folding metal roof is only a bonus and not a requirement, I'd be very tempted to go for a 4.2 RS4. My neighbour used to have one and the V8 burble in a morning when he drove off was just lovely.

Edited for spellingpaperbag

Edited by jep on Monday 9th March 19:23

walm

10,644 posts

233 months

Monday 9th March 2015
quotequote all
jep said:
If the folding metal roof is only a bonus and not a requirement, I'd be very tempted to go for a 4.2 RS4. My neighbour used to have one and the V8 burble in a morning when he drive off was just lovely.
As the sun comes out I am seriously regretting not going for the RS4 soft-top.
They seem almost depreciation proof too.
And with the drop in petrol prices the 18mpg seems less of an issue!

PompeyPaul

Original Poster:

519 posts

214 months

Monday 9th March 2015
quotequote all
Great response already - thanks guys.

Not really considered a 370z and don't really know a lot about them.

I must admit I am thinking the AMG should be the first to be tested. Be hard to beat that noise!

krisdelta

4,673 posts

232 months

Monday 9th March 2015
quotequote all
walm said:
jep said:
If the folding metal roof is only a bonus and not a requirement, I'd be very tempted to go for a 4.2 RS4. My neighbour used to have one and the V8 burble in a morning when he drive off was just lovely.
As the sun comes out I am seriously regretting not going for the RS4 soft-top.
They seem almost depreciation proof too.
And with the drop in petrol prices the 18mpg seems less of an issue!
The lack of cohesion over bumps / uk roads upsets them rather though - but completely agree about the noise smokin

ZX10R NIN

30,662 posts

156 months

Monday 9th March 2015
quotequote all
SLK 55
SL 55

PompeyPaul

Original Poster:

519 posts

214 months

Monday 9th March 2015
quotequote all
ZX10R NIN said:
SLK 55
SL 55
I know the SL has a lot more power, but would be older for the budget. Do you have experience of both. Or can anyway else compare the two?

I'm assuming the SL is probably more comfortable etc but more heavy. Are overall costs the same?

Was it an SL that Clarkson used to own?

derin100

5,217 posts

274 months

Monday 9th March 2015
quotequote all
When considering an AMG within your budget, do your plans make contingency for a calamitous "BANG"?

I used to have a C55 Estate. I only considered buying it because it had over 2 years worth of Mercedes Tier 1 warranty in place. Without it I would have slept even worse than I already do.

If an AMG engine or gearbox lets go on you...!

If the purchase price is £15-20K without a warranty it would not be unrealistic to carry a £5-10K war chest with you on campaign.



derin100

5,217 posts

274 months

Monday 9th March 2015
quotequote all
But something else (as yet unmentioned) that you may wish to consider, if you still remain unconvinced that a Z4 3.0Si is fast enough for you...and if so, don't ever expect me to sit in the passenger seat next to you! laugh


http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2015...

But I'd be quick before "certain" other dealers get their sticky fingers all over it!





Edited by derin100 on Monday 9th March 23:38

MattyB_

2,347 posts

288 months

Monday 9th March 2015
quotequote all
PompeyPaul said:
I know the SL has a lot more power, but would be older for the budget. Do you have experience of both. Or can anyway else compare the two?

I'm assuming the SL is probably more comfortable etc but more heavy. Are overall costs the same?

Was it an SL that Clarkson used to own?
SL55 has considerably higher running costs.
Clarkson swapped his SL55 for an SLK55.

SLK55 is probably the more characterful of the lot, but (so I understand) the Boxster is the "better" car. Just watch out for bore score/IMS on the latter.

CarAbuser

712 posts

155 months

Monday 9th March 2015
quotequote all
Have you considered a Z4 35is?

It's certainly a step up in performance and refinement from the Z4M and with the folding hardtop it's easy to live with for the time the roof is up. Running costs are also less than the AMG or Porsche.

I've not driven either the Boxster or the SLK but according to many the new Z4 sits between both in regards to comfort and handling.

If you can get a 987 Gen2 for that money and the running costs don't put you off then I think that's the best option. More reliable than the Gen1.

ZX10R NIN

30,662 posts

156 months

Tuesday 10th March 2015
quotequote all
derin100 said:
When considering an AMG within your budget, do your plans make contingency for a calamitous "BANG"?

I used to have a C55 Estate. I only considered buying it because it had over 2 years worth of Mercedes Tier 1 warranty in place. Without it I would have slept even worse than I already do.

If an AMG engine or gearbox lets go on you...!

If the purchase price is £15-20K without a warranty it would not be unrealistic to carry a £5-10K war chest with you on campaign.
I have had a fair few AMG's SL55 SLK55 C55 CLK55 C63 & still own a CLK63 & am about to buy a CL63 BiTurbo most didn't have a warranty apart from the C63 I soon voided that with the exhaust & ReMap they very rarely go wrong unless you're not looking after them.

The SL55 is fast as mine was tuned to 696bhp it was more of a fast GT compared to the SLK55 this still won't handle as sharply as a Porsche or BMW Z4 but what an engine note & they're good fun less things to go wrong than the supercharged SL55 but find the right car & you won't be disappointed with either.

Here are some options:
Mercedes
http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2015...

http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2015...

http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2015...

http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2014...

Alternative Porsche

http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2015...

BMW

http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2015...

http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2014...

Alpina

http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2014...

http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2015...

B7 RS4

http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2015...
Here's my old SL55

PompeyPaul

Original Poster:

519 posts

214 months

Tuesday 10th March 2015
quotequote all
ZX10R NIN said:
I have had a fair few AMG's SL55 SLK55 C55 CLK55 C63 & still own a CLK63 & am about to buy a CL63 BiTurbo most didn't have a warranty apart from the C63 I soon voided that with the exhaust & ReMap they very rarely go wrong unless you're not looking after them.

The SL55 is fast as mine was tuned to 696bhp it was more of a fast GT compared to the SLK55 this still won't handle as sharply as a Porsche or BMW Z4 but what an engine note & they're good fun less things to go wrong than the supercharged SL55 but find the right car & you won't be disappointed with either.

Here are some options:
Mercedes
http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2015...

http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2015...

http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2015...

http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2014...

Alternative Porsche

http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2015...

BMW

http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2015...

http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2014...

Alpina

http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2014...

http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2015...

B7 RS4

http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2015...
Here's my old SL55
Thanks for taking the time to suggest those. Weird how the third Mercedes doesn't have a single pictture of the exterior of the car!!

On that list I have already spotted the 6501 and the RS4 after other comments on this thread.

Don't know much about the Aplina range - some change to BMWs by an external company at a guess. I assume their running costs are as per the BMW equivilant?

I didn't even think about needing a £5,000-£10,000 backup fund for an SLK AMG - is it that more likely to go wrong than any of the other varieties suggested on here??

I know the Boxster is getting a lot of love, but just can't get a gen 2 in budget unless it is a 2.7 or similar and would really want the 3.4 S if getting one.

Any general views on the 650i? From the pictures the back seats look absolutely useless, which would in effect make it a large two seater? We don't have kids and most friends are around the 6'0 mark in any case. As I say, we don't need the extra seats, but if they are useless in any case..