Need help with my quandary…
Need help with my quandary…
Author
Discussion

Labbetts

Original Poster:

992 posts

170 months

Saturday 14th March 2015
quotequote all
I'm going round in f*ckng circles and it's driving me mad. So i thought i'd turn to the wisdom of you lot, as i seem incapable of making any decisions.

Bit of history on me, i currently drive a 2011 X3 30d XDrive, which is fast enough but lacking somewhat in driver involvement and fun factor. I came from an M135i, which (although brilliant) was just too small for my wife and 2 kids (9 and 4). It had power i didn't really need, and a lack of space i could do with.

I think i want rid of the X3, so have gone through the usual thought processes. I have looked at a facelift X3 35d which i love. But it seems an indigence to spend £20k more to get pretty much the same car, albeit with a Sports Auto Gearbox and new nose.

I looked at Evoques, but was worried about the lack of power, i also think the leather is pretty poor - with some ex demos looking like 5 year old used stock.

We looked at Golf GTI's Mk7, haven't ruled them out but feel a bit 'been there done that' (i've had 5). I also don't think the interior is on par with the BMWs.

Looked at Mercs, but A Class is too small and C Class too corporate. GLA interesting but only Diesel an option as the petrol gets hammered in the reviews.

WIfe doesn't like estates, feels saloons are a bit blokey… i can kinda understand that. She also likes being high up so would prefer an SUV ( i can talk her round mind ). She would never entertain a C63, even if she does love how they sound. Have come close to a 335i M Sport.

The car that stood out was an S3 Sportback, but it does feel a little tight in there. Beautifully finished inside and out though so it's definitely in pole position. Q5 fits the bill but is being replaced next year, so buying one now seems like residual suicide.

Anyone have a suggestion that i might have missed. I have £35kish and would like new, or 1 year old. I would pay more for a car with superb residuals (X3 35d etc) but no more than say £43k

…off to bang my head against another wall so would welcome any advice, especially on the new S3.


Gavin0478

480 posts

172 months

Saturday 14th March 2015
quotequote all
How about an S5 sportback?

DSLiverpool

16,574 posts

233 months

Saturday 14th March 2015
quotequote all


Fast, cheap, handles, good build - can't fault it

jas xjr

11,309 posts

270 months

Saturday 14th March 2015
quotequote all
DSLiverpool said:


Fast, cheap, handles, good build - can't fault it
I know nothing about these but it looks very strange or is it just that picture?

pboyall

176 posts

152 months

Saturday 14th March 2015
quotequote all
Not German - OP has only listed the German marques so unlikely to be any point suggesting anything else.

DSLiverpool

16,574 posts

233 months

Saturday 14th March 2015
quotequote all
It looks a bit Tonka on 21" wheels but I like it, the build is certainly as good as recent Mercs I have had - it's a good car as a 5.0

eldar

25,343 posts

227 months

Saturday 14th March 2015
quotequote all
pboyall said:
Not German - OP has only listed the German marques so unlikely to be any point suggesting anything else.
Apart from the non German Evoke....

LanceRS

2,235 posts

168 months

Saturday 14th March 2015
quotequote all
It's not just the picture, I have to walk past one most mornings. They do look like that.

In relation to the OPs problem, it's got yo be a case of drive it and see. We are not from the ' it's just a car' camp. We buy our cars because we like them and the way they make us feel, even if sometimes there are practical considerations as well.

Deerfoot

5,257 posts

215 months

Saturday 14th March 2015
quotequote all
Labbetts said:
Q5 fits the bill but is being replaced next year, so buying one now seems like residual suicide.
I recently had a go in the SQ5, it was fantastic and I'm not a fan of the genre.

Vaud

59,969 posts

186 months

Saturday 14th March 2015
quotequote all
Doesn't like estates but like SUVs?

S4 Avant, and ask her politely to get over the issue. wink