mazda 3 vs Golf mark 4

[puffnut]

Hey everyone

I'm starting to think that its time to sell my Hyundai Coupe because I want a more fuel efficient car. I know I definitely want a diesel. I love the 1.9 tdi golf engine however I've always loved the look of the Mazda 3, which is a 1.6 diesel.

So basically i'll have about £3000 I can get a higher mileage golf or a newer, low mileage Mazda 3. what does everyone think about the Mazda's 1.6 engine and how does it compare to the golf?

Thanks everyone

[Ian Geary]

Surely if mk4 golf is in the list due engine, then the Seat Leon should also be in?

Father in law had a mazda 323. A bit prone to rust, but steering was nice and handling competent enough.

Ian

[selym]

My wife has a Mazda 3 1.6 petrol, so I can't comment about the diesel engine. However, I like the car. It is uninspiring but comfortable, and what I would regard as a nice drive. It has also been ultra reliable (famous last words).

I'd definitely buy another.

[BritishRacinGrin]

3 grand seems a lot for a 12+ year old Golf, especially considering it's a MkIV which wasn't VW's finest hour in my opinion.

If you want the VAG 1.9TDI look at Boras, Jettas, Passats, Octavias, Exeo, A4, Leon etc etc you'll be able to beat the Golf for value for money.

Personally though I'd go for the Mazda as it's going to be newer, likely to be more reliable, better looking and a more sporting drive.

[BritishRacinGrin]

P.S. PH Standard 'why do you need a diesel', 'how many miles do you do' comment.

[puffnut]

I'd like a diesel because before the Hyundai I had a 2002 Audi A3 diesel and I just loved the torque at low revs. Most of my miles are motorway miles but I don't do that many, maybe 10000 a year. But the Coupe only gets about 30 mpg if I'm lucky so it would be worth it, plus i'd be able to have a bike rack on these cars! any one with experience of the 1.6 diesel would be much appreciated.

Thanks for all the comments so far

Alex

[sorin1987]

I have just bought a 2006 mazda 3 1.6 petrol. I like the car and from my research it seems that is very reliable. So far seems like a good car. I would recommend it.

[schmunk]

Skoda Octavia?

Same 1.9TDi engine as the Golf, but more roomy inside.

£3,000 gets you a lowish mileage 2005/06 car, or a newer car with higher miles.

[Superhoop]

Mazda3 - A good all-round, every day car

PSA 1.6 diesel engine - Google Ford Focus/Peugeot 308 1.6 diesel turbo issues. It's the same engine and suffers from the same problems.....

[puffnut]

Does anyone have any experience with the fabia vrs because they have the vw 1.9. What I'm really trying to find out is the mazdas torque and acceleration compared to something like a golf