Toyota & Honda: what happened to them and why?!
Toyota & Honda: what happened to them and why?!
Author
Discussion

uncler

Original Poster:

37 posts

216 months

Friday 20th March 2015
quotequote all
Ok, this has been bothering me for a while (and I've alluded to it in other threads), but I am having trouble understanding the market position both Toyota and Honda have in the UK these days...

They were the companies the other manufacturers were terrified of back in the 80's and 90's as they churned out loads of decent, reliable (sometimes boring) cars that the public lapped up. As well as the hum-drum models which were decent enough in their own right compared to the competition of the time, they had numerous halo models to boost the appeal of the range (MR2, Celica, Supra, CRX, Prelude, NSX, plus Type R variants of Honda's bog standard cars). Basically, any customer in the market for a new car in the mid 90's could have walked into any Toyota or Honda dealership and found something that appealed.

Then all of a sudden they just seemed to give up, removed any hint of excitement from their product range and started to churn out cars that are, at best, distinctively average compared with the competition. Product ranges were dramatically reduced and they must have fired all their designers as between them, they produce the worst looking cars for sale in the UK currently (the boring monotony of the Auris and the bonkers mess that is the Civic).

I just can't see why anyone would buy a Toyota or a Honda these days (yes and if anyone checks my garage I do have a Toyota!). You could literally go to any other manufacturer and find a car that is either better looking, more economical, more powerful, more practical, more distinctive, more fashionable, better handling, more comfortable, better equipped, etc. And if you do happen to want a reliable all-rounder, then Hyundai and Kia are there with cars that match the Toyotas and Hondas in all categories but look loads better and are probably cheaper too.

Did they become complacent or just lose target of the European market? All that said, I'm staggered to see that they are still selling cars and wonder who it is that is buying them - a stubbornly loyal customer base perhaps?

uncler

Original Poster:

37 posts

216 months

Friday 20th March 2015
quotequote all
Oh and I wanted to also express my frustration with Toyota for the current Aygo ads that tell me how fun the car is, presumably because it’s got a big ‘X’ on the front and is driven around by attractive 20-somethings having ‘fun’. Annoying.


DrDoofenshmirtz

16,952 posts

231 months

Friday 20th March 2015
quotequote all
Toyota have the GT86. That's their modern day Supra/Celica/MR2 I guess.
Honda have got the Civic Type-R for the sporty pensioners.

I agree though - the scrapings are a bit thin! It's all about Hybrid's these days.

lbc

3,340 posts

248 months

Friday 20th March 2015
quotequote all
The masses only want small engine boring reliable cars that are cheap to run.

bitchstewie

68,496 posts

241 months

Friday 20th March 2015
quotequote all
Not sure about Honda but don't Toyota make some seriously weird and whacky cars, that they just don't sell in the UK i.e. less to do with what they make and more to do with that we the UK consumer typically want to buy?

graham22

3,328 posts

236 months

Friday 20th March 2015
quotequote all
Wonder how Honda (and Toyota) sales compare to the 80/90s.

When I had a CRX in 94, it was an unusual and very rare choice, many people didn't know what it was, let alone the performance compared to GTIs and RS Turbos. There were very few Hondas around. Even in 2000 owning an Impreza Turbo was a fairly rare choice.

Perhaps with the advent of the internet, we 'saw' more of these than what you actually perceived, plus there was the influx of imports, I guess a big proportion of halo models were in fact imports coming in later in the models life.

I'm sure we see more Hondas now than before, many more Civic Type RS compared to CRXs for instance.

Yes, current model line up is a little dull but unfortunately, how many people want a small 2 seat hardtop these days.

Don't forget the GT86 as already said.


emicen

9,258 posts

249 months

Friday 20th March 2015
quotequote all
Well, the answer for Toyota is a bit obvious, they earmarked Lexus for sporty and luxury. They have a nod to their past in the GT86 as a spiritual successor but their real sports cars are via the Lexus brand: LFA, ISF, RCF. Be interesting which banner the new Supra is released under. Was wearing Toyota badges last time I saw the prototype/showmule.

Honda, still produce some things but the UK market just isnt that big for them. They sell a lot of CTRs. and will continue to do so. The CRZ is being re-released with a more TypeR esque engine. They produce a lot of stuff we dont get over here as they've never really shook the image of reliable pensioner charriots in this country.

Conscript

1,378 posts

152 months

Friday 20th March 2015
quotequote all
lbc said:
The masses only want small engine boring reliable cars that are cheap to run.
This, I'm guessing.
Although they are making more boring cars, they are, on the whole, still excellent if you just want a "car".

My sister's 2002 Toyota Yaris would probably be of no itnerest to anyone here - tiny engine, slow, small, not exactly a looker. But as a "car" it is still a fantastic tool - economical, easy to drive, cheap to maintain, inoffensive, easy to park, efficient, and perhaps most of all, strangely reliable (don't think it's ever had so much as an advisory on it's MOT). A couple of years ago, she upgraded to a Toyota Auris which is much the same, but a bit bigger/more modern/comfortable, and her boyfriend uses the Yaris for the very occasional times he needs a car. These are unexciting cars, but if you just want "a car" and you want it to work and keep on working for as cheaply as possible, then Toyota are probably a great shout.

And given that people who just want "a car" make up the vast majority of the market, I think Toyota (and Honda) are just cashing in. Why bother spending money making exciting cars for a minority when you can make a lot more money churning out boring, but ultimately, reliable and excellent cars, to a huge market?

SlowV6

733 posts

170 months

Friday 20th March 2015
quotequote all
I feel they both completely missed the UK market going over from NA petrols, where they both excelled and had a USP of fantastic reliability over rivals, to turbo diesels. In diesel dominated sectors their old "reliability USP" doesn't exist and their offerings aren't competitive so no-one wants them. So they are reduced mainly to Jazz's and Yaris where petrol is still preferred.

The UK is a relatively small market for both companies and I think this has led to the "giving up" observation, which I agree with to some extent.

None of the above excuses the terrible (Civic) or bland (Auris, Avensis) designs pushed out, which doesn't help matters.

A real shame. All IMHO of course.

AA999

5,180 posts

248 months

Friday 20th March 2015
quotequote all
Although only concept cars at the moment Toyota have the FT-1..
http://www.toyota.com/concept-vehicles/

And Honda are displaying their concept of the new NSX...
http://www.honda.co.uk/cars/comingsoon/nsx/


But I agree, for years since the likes of the Toyota Supra that finished production in 2002 and Honda's Type-R badged cars that seemingly became more and more bland, these two companies maybe changed their market angle to the dismay of many.

'Greeny-ness' seemed to take over many manufacturers for a while and I think maybe the Japanese were trying to capture the momentum of Al Gore's prophecy of MMGW and people's fear of the planet imploding.


forzaminardi

2,298 posts

218 months

Friday 20th March 2015
quotequote all
One of the big things that happened, less to Toyota and Honda specifically, and more to the market, was the arrival of German 'premium' brands and Asian value brands in the volume market. Toyota filled a market that was looking for more reliable and modern cars than the old European brands (in the UK Ford, Vauxhall, Rover) offered, but weren't as expensive as the "posh" German brands like BMW or Mercedes. This was the basis of their commercial success, and while that in turn spawned confidence to make the more interesting cars the OP mentioned, it shouldn't be forgotten that fundamentally the key reason for their success was their production of reliable, modern and affordable but generally fairly mundane cars - Corollas, Civics, Accords, Carinas, etc.

Move forward to the 1990s and we have Mercedes and BMW (and latterly Audi) diversifying their product range to produce more affordable cars that apparently offered the reliability and quality of a Japanese car but pepped them up with 'posh' or 'sporty' brand image. At the same time the European mainstream manufacturers were catching onto Japanese manufactuting principles, upping quality and drawing on their heritage and brand resonance to draw customer back. And finally, Koreans (and VW's budget brands) entered the market with even more affordable but fundamentally decent product. So Toyota and Honda's USP - decent motors that are reliable affordable - became less unique and lacked the sparkle of a premium brand to follow a more demanding market.

I'd also suggest that while we may look back on interesting old Toyotas and Hondas with a degree of nostalgia, that shouldn't obscure that fact that back then the brands were regarded as pretty mundane. Us enthusiasts probably had a rosier view of them than the average Joe Blogs who would see a Corolla or an Accord as an average car without any particular appeal and not really see a NSX, Type-R or Supra as worth wasting time thinking about. It's easy for us to fall for all the retrospective hype of 'Senna and Honda' or the glory of Toyota's WRC wins, but frankly it just wasn't all that well known back then, or even regarded as positive - Senna is regarded as a God now, but back then to most Brits he was a cheating Brazilian b*stard.



blueST

4,908 posts

247 months

Friday 20th March 2015
quotequote all
SlowV6 said:
I feel they both completely missed the UK market going over from NA petrols, where they both excelled and had a USP of fantastic reliability over rivals, to turbo diesels. In diesel dominated sectors their old "reliability USP" doesn't exist and their offerings aren't competitive so no-one wants them. So they are reduced mainly to Jazz's and Yaris where petrol is still preferred.

The UK is a relatively small market for both companies and I think this has led to the "giving up" observation, which I agree with to some extent.

None of the above excuses the terrible (Civic) or bland (Auris, Avensis) designs pushed out, which doesn't help matters.

A real shame. All IMHO of course.
Agree. At some point the mass market shifted from favouring reliability to economy/CO2. The Japanese makers seemed very slow off the mark with good diesels in particular.

BritishRacinGrin

26,708 posts

191 months

Friday 20th March 2015
quotequote all
DrDoofenshmirtz said:
It's all about Hybrid's these days.
Basically this, change of tack towards Eco which I think has, and will probably continue to prove prudent.

anonymous-user

85 months

Friday 20th March 2015
quotequote all
blueST said:
SlowV6 said:
I feel they both completely missed the UK market going over from NA petrols, where they both excelled and had a USP of fantastic reliability over rivals, to turbo diesels. In diesel dominated sectors their old "reliability USP" doesn't exist and their offerings aren't competitive so no-one wants them. So they are reduced mainly to Jazz's and Yaris where petrol is still preferred.

The UK is a relatively small market for both companies and I think this has led to the "giving up" observation, which I agree with to some extent.

None of the above excuses the terrible (Civic) or bland (Auris, Avensis) designs pushed out, which doesn't help matters.

A real shame. All IMHO of course.
Agree. At some point the mass market shifted from favouring reliability to economy/CO2. The Japanese makers seemed very slow off the mark with good diesels in particular.
Honda Has a very bland and overprice range in the UK. Compare there range to Mazda for Example and Mazda seam to be on a roll with some great cars, all cheaper than Honda too

Otispunkmeyer

13,834 posts

186 months

Friday 20th March 2015
quotequote all
uncler said:
Oh and I wanted to also express my frustration with Toyota for the current Aygo ads that tell me how fun the car is, presumably because it’s got a big ‘X’ on the front and is driven around by attractive 20-somethings having ‘fun’. Annoying.
I really like the little Aygo... Might actually be buying one this weekend. In Orange.

I do agree with the sentiment of the thread though and I think Honda are worse than Toyota. At least Toyota have a decent range of cars, Honda have the Jazz, Civic and CR-V I think and thats about it. Honda to me at least style their cars a bit better (Aygo excluded because I think it looks good, its got that cheeky jap manga look to it). But thats not much really when you look at Toyotas styling which makes their cars look totally bland with some hideous proportions. And have you see the dash boards inside them? Some weird upright slab sided looking job...no flair whatsoever.

Oddly, I think the Prius is probably one of the better looking in their range and the only other car I wouldn't mind driving around in other than the Aygo.

Wouldn't have any of the current Honda's and I drive a previous gen civic. OH's parents have a new CR-V which gets treated as the utility it is, but its still quite expensive for what it is. Its got a weak ass 2.0l petrol engine and the stereo really does look like an aftermarket afterthought.

uncler

Original Poster:

37 posts

216 months

Friday 20th March 2015
quotequote all
MonkeyMatt said:
Honda Has a very bland and overprice range in the UK. Compare there range to Mazda for Example and Mazda seam to be on a roll with some great cars, all cheaper than Honda too
Would definitely agree with this; I just can't understand what USP Toyota/Honda have with their current range and therefore, why on earth they still bother. Mazda have developed with the market - they were always a little niche with their cars, although they were often very good. Their current range consists of unique and to my eyes at least, good looking cars. They are also on par with competitors for economy, driving pleasure and the interior standards expected in the UK market making them a desirable choice, if not a popular one.

Thinking back to the original post, its not just the Korean cars that have stepped on Toyota & Honda's toes, Vauxhall and in particular Ford have improved their offerings so much that it isn't worth even considering an Auris or Civic unless you particularly fancy driving around in the motoring equivalent of back ache.

Monkeylegend

29,591 posts

262 months

Friday 20th March 2015
quotequote all
Well they sold about 14.5 million new cars worldwide between them in 2014, so they must be doing something right. Maybe they understand/dictate the market requirements better than posters on here do.

Just a thought wink

DanielSan

20,113 posts

198 months

Friday 20th March 2015
quotequote all
New Civic Type R, NSX. Likely to be a new Civic Type.R engined CRZ coming to the UK soon, and rumours of an S2000 replacement in the pipeline also with the new Turbo engine. Hardly nothing.

chrispj

266 posts

174 months

Friday 20th March 2015
quotequote all
lbc said:
The masses only want small engine boring reliable cars that are cheap to run.
Don't forget the soft touch plastics. Far more important than any engineering integrity.

Steve vRS

5,412 posts

272 months

Friday 20th March 2015
quotequote all
Well Toyota had a go at doing something fun and interesting with the GT86.

And people complain about them not being as powerful of fast as a heavy, uninvolving TDi hatch and didn't buy them.

So they made more Aygo which seem to sell.

Steve