Large family 4x4 for £6k
Discussion
I want a big stupid 4x4. My new hobby keeps taking me down rough tracks and I want something I can take to France on holiday full to the brim with our three little darlings and all the crap they travel with.
I want reasonable mpg and off road ability along with long distance motorway comfort.
I'm thinking L322 Range Rover, a Discovery 3 or VW Touareg but am I nuts considering one at that price? My budget is limited while we are moving house.
I think my off road requirement rules out X5s and XC90s - I need decent clearance.
The only other options are the Kia Sorento and the mk2 Hyundai Santa Fe, which seems a lot of newer car for the money but unsure about the off-roading ability.
Not sure about the Merc ML.
Any advice welcome.
I want reasonable mpg and off road ability along with long distance motorway comfort.
I'm thinking L322 Range Rover, a Discovery 3 or VW Touareg but am I nuts considering one at that price? My budget is limited while we are moving house.
I think my off road requirement rules out X5s and XC90s - I need decent clearance.
The only other options are the Kia Sorento and the mk2 Hyundai Santa Fe, which seems a lot of newer car for the money but unsure about the off-roading ability.
Not sure about the Merc ML.
Any advice welcome.

Edited by Emeye on Sunday 22 March 19:01
Luke. said:
Nice car, but I don't think the ground clearance is good enough for where I plan on going unfortunately.how much off-roading do you need (other than ground clearance)?
rough tracks don't require much off-roading ability - you could take a normal estate up a rough track...
my kuga does most that my range rovers ever did other than serious off-roading - it has better ground clearance / 4x4 / etc.
unless you need the diff-locking / low-range gear ratios / etc. I would consider some of the softer off-roaders...
both the RR / Disco 3 are good cars, but can have electrical issues - you can certainly find cars at your budget, but you need to probably stick a good amount of cash away for repairs unless you are very lucky...
rough tracks don't require much off-roading ability - you could take a normal estate up a rough track...
my kuga does most that my range rovers ever did other than serious off-roading - it has better ground clearance / 4x4 / etc.
unless you need the diff-locking / low-range gear ratios / etc. I would consider some of the softer off-roaders...
both the RR / Disco 3 are good cars, but can have electrical issues - you can certainly find cars at your budget, but you need to probably stick a good amount of cash away for repairs unless you are very lucky...
Emeye said:
Luke. said:
Nice car, but I don't think the ground clearance is good enough for where I plan on going unfortunately.Merc ML - 180mm
Subaru Outback - 200mm
Grand Cherokee - 208mm
Audi Allroad - 208mm *
VW Touareg - 208mm
Freelander - 210mm
Disco 3 - 240mm
Range Rover - 281mm
*(which I am surprised hasn't been mentioned- the older version that goes up and down!)
Edited by Efbe on Sunday 22 March 20:10
Efbe said:
just because I was vaguely interested thought I would find some ground clearances.
Merc ML - 180mm
Subaru Outback - 200mm
Grand Cherokee - 208mm
Audi Allroad - 208mm *
VW Touareg - 208mm
Freelander - 210mm
Disco 3 - 240mm
Range Rover - 281mm
[i]*(which I am surprised hasn't been mentioned- the older version that goes up and down!)
Thanks, very useful and surprising! The Audi all road I had discounted due to reading they were stupidly unreliable. It seems from that list that a disco 3 or a Rangey are the best options but probably just as unreliable.Merc ML - 180mm
Subaru Outback - 200mm
Grand Cherokee - 208mm
Audi Allroad - 208mm *
VW Touareg - 208mm
Freelander - 210mm
Disco 3 - 240mm
Range Rover - 281mm
[i]*(which I am surprised hasn't been mentioned- the older version that goes up and down!)
Emeye said:
Thanks, very useful and surprising! The Audi all road I had discounted due to reading they were stupidly unreliable. It seems from that list that a disco 3 or a Rangey are the best options but probably just as unreliable.
I wouldn't focus on ground clearance too much.If the freelander was fine for you before, then all bar the ML will be here.
Also if the freelander provided enough ability offroading, then I take it you are more meaning greenlaning, for which you can live without locking diffs, and of the cars mentioned in this thread will do.
how about something like this:
http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/2006-Suzuki-Grand-Vitara...
before you completely write them off, have a look at the mpg
Also not sure on this version but was in an earlier model and it had locking diffs and a low box. very capable offroad
If it's numbers you want, the Freelander 2 has 210mm ground clearance whilst the XC90 has 218mm.
I've got an XC90 and it's lovely - carries 6 of us in comfort and tops 30mpg, but it is distinctly soft-roader, with decorative plastic trims rather than proper sump guards etc. If you need hard-core 4x4 performance then it's not the car for you, but with a road bias I would thoroughly recommend it.
I've got an XC90 and it's lovely - carries 6 of us in comfort and tops 30mpg, but it is distinctly soft-roader, with decorative plastic trims rather than proper sump guards etc. If you need hard-core 4x4 performance then it's not the car for you, but with a road bias I would thoroughly recommend it.
Apologies if I'm coming across as being a bit dumb in all this - as a petrolhead, 4x4s appear to have passed me by apart from my old freelander.
My bro has an XC90 which is great but it does seem a little soft for what I want and my dad has a Jeep Patriot which has been great but just isn't big enough. If I didn't want something to take bouncing around an XC90 would be top of the list.
I worry about the jap stuff in my budget being too agricultural - a guy at work has a brand new Shogun and I call it the tractor, so I suspect an old one will be very plasticky and noisy.
Looks like I'll have to compromise somewhere though.
Maybe a Disco 2 - would one be just like a bigger version of my mk1 Freelander? just not sure my missus would approve!
My bro has an XC90 which is great but it does seem a little soft for what I want and my dad has a Jeep Patriot which has been great but just isn't big enough. If I didn't want something to take bouncing around an XC90 would be top of the list.
I worry about the jap stuff in my budget being too agricultural - a guy at work has a brand new Shogun and I call it the tractor, so I suspect an old one will be very plasticky and noisy.
Looks like I'll have to compromise somewhere though.
Maybe a Disco 2 - would one be just like a bigger version of my mk1 Freelander? just not sure my missus would approve!
Gassing Station | General Gassing | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff




