Accident management company - any alternative?
Accident management company - any alternative?
Author
Discussion

Spoonman

Original Poster:

1,085 posts

292 months

Wednesday 25th March 2015
quotequote all
My mum's car has been hit by a lorry. It was a police and ambulance job, and the lorry driver admitted to police he 'didn't see her'.

I've since phoned the haulier, who denied all knowledge of any accident. Fortunately, the police reckon the vehicle was insured.

My mum's okay, albeit shaken up and sore. Her dog (who was in the back at the time) has a cut under her eye, but otherwise they escaped lightly.

The car will undoubtedly be written off, and I could do with getting her a courtesy car in the meantime. Her insurance company has put her on to Albany, but I'm cautious of these accident management setups.

Is there any practical alternative?

justanother5tar

1,314 posts

156 months

Wednesday 25th March 2015
quotequote all
Don't fking do it!

Spoonman

Original Poster:

1,085 posts

292 months

Wednesday 25th March 2015
quotequote all
justanother5tar said:
Don't fking do it!
Not helpful.

Grey Ghost

4,611 posts

251 months

Wednesday 25th March 2015
quotequote all
If her insurers are confident it is a non fault accident and have passed her details to a 3rd party management company speak to them. Have them confirm it is being treated as a non fault claim and go from there.

I was hit in the nearside by a tw@t pulling out of an entrance to a car park in summer of 2013, my insurer passed me on to a 3rd party management company and a nice Mercedes AMG was provided for the 6 weeks my TVR was off the road.

Spoonman

Original Poster:

1,085 posts

292 months

Wednesday 25th March 2015
quotequote all
It's definitely being treated as a non-fault on my mum's part. Plenty of witnesses, plus the lorry driver admitted blame to the police.

I just don't like the idea of lining the pockets of these accident management firms.

justanother5tar

1,314 posts

156 months

Wednesday 25th March 2015
quotequote all
Spoonman said:
It's definitely being treated as a non-fault on my mum's part. Plenty of witnesses, plus the lorry driver admitted blame to the police.

I just don't like the idea of lining the pockets of these accident management firms.
Mine was 100% no fault. The AM company have strung it along that much that the 3rd party are now refusing hire costs.

If you decide to go with an AM, go in with your eyes very firmly wide open. Check all the T&Cs very carefully and read all the small print.

I didn't. And now I'm having all kinds of hassle. Hassle which I don't want, nor did I expect with it being such a simple claim.

Road2Ruin

6,559 posts

247 months

Wednesday 25th March 2015
quotequote all
Grey Ghost said:
a nice Mercedes AMG was provided for the 6 weeks my TVR was off the road.
Quick everyone your insurance is going up!

Grey Ghost

4,611 posts

251 months

Wednesday 25th March 2015
quotequote all
Spoonman said:
I just don't like the idea of lining the pockets of these accident management firms.
They are there to ensure an insured driver who is involved in an incident that is not their fault is put back in the position they were in before the incident as quickly as possible. If that involve a loan car (like for like is the general approach) to replace the damaged one whilst it is repaired or written off so be it. These rules/laws are there to protect you when a motoring accident is not your fault.

With regard to lining the pockets of accident management firms, I was of the same opinion before my incident. However, having been dealt with in a very professional and courteous manner my mind set was changed. It could be argued that we are already paying for these cases through our insurance as the insurers/underwriters will have factored claims such as these into their business costs each year and posted premiums accordingly.

MikeO996

2,008 posts

255 months

Wednesday 25th March 2015
quotequote all
Grey Ghost said:
It could be argued that we are already paying for these cases through our insurance as the insurers/underwriters will have factored claims such as these into their business costs each year and posted premiums accordingly.
And they will factor in increasing costs as these companies become more adept at screwing more money out of the other parties insurance companies. I do not understand why the insurance companies collude with these ambulance chasers when it's pushing everyone's costs up.
I was in a very minor accident a couple years ago and have been plagued ever since with repeated phone calls encouraging me to make a fraudulent claim of having suffered "discomfort" because the insurers "will have put money aside to pay this". Indeed when I finally persuaded them that I didn't want proceed I was told that "we will have to return the money then" as if the insurers had paid up without even a claim.
I got a hire car that my policy didn't cover me for, but the hassle of the accident management company far outweighed the nuisance of the very minor bump.

Edited by MikeO996 on Thursday 26th March 11:49

Cliftonite

8,754 posts

169 months

Wednesday 25th March 2015
quotequote all
Make sure there is a little insurance policy built into the credit hire agreement that pays the (usually exorbitant) hire costs if the guilty party's insurance declines to pay them.




Spoonman

Original Poster:

1,085 posts

292 months

Wednesday 25th March 2015
quotequote all
Thanks for your help, guys. Some useful information there for me to bear in mind.

Her car's damaged on both sides and had a rear wheel ripped off, so I expect it'll be written off. I may just lend her a car if nothing is sorted out with the insurance tomorrow.

Sump

5,512 posts

198 months

Wednesday 25th March 2015
quotequote all
Chuck in a whippy claim. Use it to cover the increase in premiums in the future on insurance.

Spoonman

Original Poster:

1,085 posts

292 months

Wednesday 25th March 2015
quotequote all
It wouldn't be a spurious claim if she did - she can hardly move already. I guess being spun 360 degrees at 40mph and hitting a crash barrier isn't too great for a pensioner's wellbeing.

55palfers

6,396 posts

195 months

Wednesday 25th March 2015
quotequote all
Sign up with the accident company on the agreement that you get 50% of the car rental bill they bang into the £p insurer

nottyash

4,671 posts

226 months

Thursday 26th March 2015
quotequote all
I would always use them instead of touching my own insurance. I learned the hard way and have usedbthem twice.
Excellent results both times.

TankRizzo

8,031 posts

224 months

Thursday 26th March 2015
quotequote all
Grey Ghost said:
They are there to ensure an insured driver who is involved in an incident that is not their fault is put back in the position they were in before the incident as quickly as possible. If that involve a loan car (like for like is the general approach) to replace the damaged one whilst it is repaired or written off so be it. These rules/laws are there to protect you when a motoring accident is not your fault.

With regard to lining the pockets of accident management firms, I was of the same opinion before my incident. However, having been dealt with in a very professional and courteous manner my mind set was changed. It could be argued that we are already paying for these cases through our insurance as the insurers/underwriters will have factored claims such as these into their business costs each year and posted premiums accordingly.
Actually, they are there to rinse insurance firms through extortionate credit hire charges.

I would not use one, because you are on the hook for the charges if the AMC cannot reclaim them from the TP insurer. The easiest thing to do is contact the TP insurance company and deal directly with them, they will be grateful you are not engaging an AMC.

Spoonman

Original Poster:

1,085 posts

292 months

Thursday 26th March 2015
quotequote all
It turns out there is another option... Even though the insurance company supplies courtesy cars only in fault accidents, Hastings in this case agreed to pay for a suitable hire car rather than using the accident management company. A much better solution, in my eyes.

Spoonman

Original Poster:

1,085 posts

292 months

Thursday 26th March 2015
quotequote all
PS I've tried twice over the years to go straight to a third party's insurer.

On this occasion, the haulier refused to acknowledge the accident, so I couldn't get to speak to its insurer.

And, several years ago, I was hit by an Ocado van. I tried to go direct through the third party's insurer, but it took six years to receive a payout, even though they'd admitted liability. Believe it or not, the third party's insurer sent a solicitor to county court twice to fight the case, who even had the audacity to request costs, despite admitting blame...

If you can get your insurer to fight for you, it saves lots and lots of hassle.

TankRizzo

8,031 posts

224 months

Thursday 26th March 2015
quotequote all
Spoonman said:
PS I've tried twice over the years to go straight to a third party's insurer.

On this occasion, the haulier refused to acknowledge the accident, so I couldn't get to speak to its insurer.

And, several years ago, I was hit by an Ocado van. I tried to go direct through the third party's insurer, but it took six years to receive a payout, even though they'd admitted liability. Believe it or not, the third party's insurer sent a solicitor to county court twice to fight the case, who even had the audacity to request costs, despite admitting blame...

If you can get your insurer to fight for you, it saves lots and lots of hassle.
I can only tell you I've done it twice and my parents once, I didn't have any hassle at all - courtesy car dropped off after a few days. The firms were Direct Line (twice) and MoreThan.

Spoonman

Original Poster:

1,085 posts

292 months

Thursday 26th March 2015
quotequote all
TankRizzo said:
I can only tell you I've done it twice and my parents once, I didn't have any hassle at all - courtesy car dropped off after a few days. The firms were Direct Line (twice) and MoreThan.
Furry muff. I don't doubt it.

Unfortunately, I seem to be a dhead magnet, and nothing is ever straightforward... :-)