R56 Mini- all grenades or just the Cooper S?
R56 Mini- all grenades or just the Cooper S?
Author
Discussion

glazbagun

Original Poster:

15,382 posts

228 months

Thursday 26th March 2015
quotequote all
Have been thinking of a boggo Mini Cooper as a lower running cost replacement for my Golf mkV, but either my google is broken or the cars have been nightmares for so many owners.

I sugvest broken google because all the results for "r56 problems" are dominated by Cooper S timing chains, coking up engines, etc.

Are the lesser models equally as plagued?

zainster

442 posts

207 months

Thursday 26th March 2015
quotequote all
I ran an R56 Mini Cooper fJCW for 14 months and it was not only a hoot to drive but utterly reliable and I didn't have one single issue with it in my time.

It was also pretty cheap to run.
I would highly recommend one.

Get one with a mini warranty like I did and you can then have that peace of mind too.

Accelebrate

5,710 posts

246 months

Thursday 26th March 2015
quotequote all
I've owned a just-a-Cooper for a few years now. Take a look at my garage for the running costs. smile

PompeyPaul

519 posts

214 months

Thursday 26th March 2015
quotequote all
I think the R53 still has a very strong following due to the supercharger. Like anything, the internet only tends to show the bad experiences that people have had. Very few write when they have had trouble free motoring...

rigga

8,808 posts

232 months

Thursday 26th March 2015
quotequote all
Non s Cooper's are powered by the n12 engine which does not suffer many issues unlike the N14 fitted to the s and jcw (then replaced with the redesigned N18) having said that not everyone has issue's. But on the internet no posts their car is wonderfully reliable do they.

mon the fish

1,577 posts

179 months

Thursday 26th March 2015
quotequote all
The Cooper is not DI, unlike the S so doesn't suffer the coking issues. Not sure on timing chain problems for the Cooper

Nezquick

1,855 posts

157 months

Thursday 26th March 2015
quotequote all
I had a R56 Cooper S and it spent more time at the garage than on my drive. Utterly useless.

It started with a cold start rattle in the morning. They fixed it the first time and gave it me back. A few days later, it started again so back it went. This time, they did a full top-engine rebuild. The cams were pitted, it was coked up, the timing chain was extremely loose and it all needed replacing. Thankfully, it was under warranty as it was a £4k+ job apparently. This was on a car with 15k miles.

I px'd it shortly after that as I couldn't live with it. I agree that it was great to drive when it worked. It handled like it was on rails (mine had the LSD fitted) and was pretty nippy. Build quality was shocking though. If you like cheap plastic interiors and squeaks then you'll be fine.

Charlie1986

2,107 posts

166 months

Thursday 26th March 2015
quotequote all
I ran a cooper s for 3 years and put 38K no problems at all just tyres which in hindsight would have lasted longer if I tried. The car was hard driven for most of those miles. the pop and crackle of the exhaust is bit addictive

snotrag

15,748 posts

242 months

Thursday 26th March 2015
quotequote all
Timing chain definitely an issue on non S Cooper models! Sister in law has one waiting parts.

Missing the point though_ there's no way I'd assume an R56 Mini will be cheaper to run than a Mk5 Golf, other than maybe an R32?

Krikkit

27,941 posts

212 months

Thursday 26th March 2015
quotequote all
Single biggest issue of the R56 non-S Cooper is the crap dipstick imo - impossible to tell how much oil is actually in the engine!

That, and I'd recommend one with relatively small wheels. My mother had one with the 18" wheels and the ride was absolutely awful. Great on smooth roads, but it couldn't cope with broken surfaces at all, and the tyre roar on the motorway was deafening.

CallorFold

860 posts

164 months

Thursday 26th March 2015
quotequote all
In what aspects would a Mini Cooper be less running costs than a MK5 Golf? (Just wondering..... confused)

Nezquick

1,855 posts

157 months

Thursday 26th March 2015
quotequote all
Krikkit said:
Single biggest issue of the R56 non-S Cooper is the crap dipstick imo - impossible to tell how much oil is actually in the engine!

That, and I'd recommend one with relatively small wheels. My mother had one with the 18" wheels and the ride was absolutely awful. Great on smooth roads, but it couldn't cope with broken surfaces at all, and the tyre roar on the motorway was deafening.
Agreed on both fronts. And they use a LOT of oil....."they all do that sir"

ian_c_uk

1,453 posts

234 months

Thursday 26th March 2015
quotequote all
I had a 2008 Cooper for 4 years / 80k, it could be a bit rattly on start up but always quietened once oil pressure / temperature rose - usually within seconds.

Didn't use any more oil than expected.

I've now got a 2012 (N18) Cooper S, I must admit the reported issues on the N14 engine did make me go post LCI facelift.

anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 26th March 2015
quotequote all
Nezquick said:
If you like cheap plastic interiors and squeaks then you'll be fine.
I remember going in a friend's Cooper a few years back. I couldn't believe the amount of squeaks and rattles and I had a TVR at the time!

crostonian

2,427 posts

203 months

Thursday 26th March 2015
quotequote all
They're junk, I'm a buyer for a large independant and they are on our banned list! Too many problems to list and not isolated incidents, MINIs in general are poorly built and unreliable.

Liquid Tuna

1,403 posts

187 months

Thursday 26th March 2015
quotequote all
St John Smythe said:
Nezquick said:
If you like cheap plastic interiors and squeaks then you'll be fine.
I remember going in a friend's Cooper a few years back. I couldn't believe the amount of squeaks and rattles and I had a TVR at the time!
I've heard this, yet my wife and her friend both had MY2006 Coopers and I thought they were really well built and tight inside - no rattles or squeaks at all, even after a few years of both women driving them with little or no regard for mechanical sympathy, servicing schedule, maintenance of any kind, or kerbs and speed bumps.

rossub

6,068 posts

221 months

Thursday 26th March 2015
quotequote all
I'm 9 months and 7,000 miles (61,000 miles total) into Cooper D ownership and nothing has needed fixing yet smile

12TS

2,262 posts

241 months

Thursday 26th March 2015
quotequote all
Just about to be our 3rd. This will be an F56 Cooper S

We'll have done 100, 000 miles or so in a 2 R56s, one a Cooper, the other a Cooper S. They're reasonably cheap to run when you do the whole cost sums (depreciation, servicing, fuel economy) Neither gave us any big issues, the odd thing went wrong (oil leak, sensors) but nothing major. If you do a search you'll always find the horror stories; Mini sell loads of cars, they wouldn't be that successful if they were poor.