15" steel or alloy wheels for ride quality?
15" steel or alloy wheels for ride quality?
Author
Discussion

cb010

Original Poster:

76 posts

142 months

Thursday 26th March 2015
quotequote all
Hey folks

I've had two test drive in a Hyundai i30, in a S and SE spec.

The S had 15" steel wheels whereas the SE had 15" alloy wheels.

When I did the second drive in the SE it felt much better in terms of absorbing the potholes and various lumps and bumps on our well maintained roads.

I don't know whether alloy wheels are somehow better at interacting with the suspension, or whether I was simply feeling more comfortable on the second test drive.

I'd prefer steel wheels but your thoughts would be very welcome.

Thanks smile

vtecyo

2,122 posts

160 months

Thursday 26th March 2015
quotequote all
You should try the gel ones they're putting on the new S Class.

Mave

8,217 posts

246 months

Thursday 26th March 2015
quotequote all
You know steel is an alloy, right :-)
I would have expected steel wheels to be marginally less stiff and so feel more compliant, but more likely to be something else like (tyre pressure? Seats?)

HertsBiker

6,443 posts

302 months

Thursday 26th March 2015
quotequote all
In theory the steels are lighter so should be better. But not always. What tyre widths and pressures they running?

shake n bake

2,221 posts

238 months

Thursday 26th March 2015
quotequote all
did you drive one after the other, without driving anything else? We're they both new/used?

Krikkit

27,941 posts

212 months

Thursday 26th March 2015
quotequote all
HertsBiker said:
In theory the steels are lighter so should be better. But not always. What tyre widths and pressures they running?
In my experience comfort is highly dependent on unsprung weight - steels at 14-15" are generally lighter than the equivalent alloys, but tyre profile also makes a huge difference.

Getting technical I'm sure the spring and damper rates will make a difference - some may suit alloy weight, others steel.

Matttracker

630 posts

178 months

Thursday 26th March 2015
quotequote all
This probably only comes down to make and pressures of tyre over the metal of the wheel

TooMany2cvs

29,008 posts

157 months

Thursday 26th March 2015
quotequote all
If both wheels and tyres were the same size, and the only difference was the wheel design/material, then I'd be saying there's suspension differences. Apart from a kg or two unsprung weight (which isn't going to be noticable in something like a cooking Hyundai), the only way in which the wheel material would make a difference is if one wheel is flexing and deforming - which is NOT going to be good for longevity at all...

jon-

16,534 posts

247 months

Thursday 26th March 2015
quotequote all
Matttracker said:
This probably only comes down to make and pressures of tyre over the metal of the wheel
Exactly this.

There can be a huge variance in tyres alone.

cb010

Original Poster:

76 posts

142 months

Thursday 26th March 2015
quotequote all
shake n bake said:
did you drive one after the other, without driving anything else? We're they both new/used?
Both were used (ex-rental) and about 9 months old. I drove both within the space of an hour. Both had the same tyres: 195/65 R15

Tyre pressures could have been different. I may not go for an ex-rental as some places are pricing ex-rentals at the same point as one private owner...

anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 26th March 2015
quotequote all
Why wouldn't they, all other things being equal?

PositronicRay

29,101 posts

214 months

Thursday 26th March 2015
quotequote all
Maybe different brands of tyres, new(ish) tyres tend to feel nicer than worn.

Mrs PR wanted a used Hyundai last yr, the deals on new cars were so good we couldn't bring ouselves to buy a late used car.

SuperPav

1,358 posts

156 months

Thursday 26th March 2015
quotequote all
Any difference you felt will not have been down to steel vs. aluminium wheels.

One car may well have had a harder life on the suspension than the other (9 months is enough time for stuff to bed in/wear), tyre pressures or even tyre brands may have been the culprit.



McSam

6,753 posts

206 months

Thursday 26th March 2015
quotequote all
jon- said:
Matttracker said:
This probably only comes down to make and pressures of tyre over the metal of the wheel
Exactly this.

There can be a huge variance in tyres alone.
I'd agree that the tyres and their pressures would be far more influential.

Though if the tyres are the same size and weight in both designs, whichever wheel is lighter - typically but not always the alloy* - will ride and handle more nicely. Unsprung mass is incredibly important, and even as little as 1kg a corner is enough to make an appreciable difference.

Light alloy, implying aluminimum, titanium or magnesium-based, for the clever bugger above thinking we should just ignore decades of naming convention!

jkh112

23,948 posts

189 months

Thursday 26th March 2015
quotequote all
HertsBiker said:
In theory the steels are lighter so should be better. But not always.
I have seen this stated on PH a few times and find it intriguing. When alloy wheels started appearing on higher spec models of ordinary cars one of the benefits highlighted was a reduction in weight. I wonder if this is no longer true as alloy wheels have become more normal and hence cheaper alloys and construction methods have led to increased weight.
I did a quick search to check I wasn't remembering things wrong and one of the first sites I found was this one from 1999
http://grassrootsmotorsports.com/articles/wheels-o...
It does state that reduced weight is a benefit of alloy wheels over steel.

In the case of the OP, I would have thought tyre pressures would be the most obvious reason for the difference.

TooMany2cvs

29,008 posts

157 months

Thursday 26th March 2015
quotequote all
jkh112 said:
I have seen this stated on PH a few times and find it intriguing. When alloy wheels started appearing on higher spec models of ordinary cars one of the benefits highlighted was a reduction in weight. I wonder if this is no longer true as alloy wheels have become more normal and hence cheaper alloys and construction methods have led to increased weight.
Alloys can be thin and light but easily bendable, or they can be thick and heavy and robust. The same obviously applies to steel wheels (the Discovery steels I've got on the Landy are "only" 7x16, but weigh a bloody ton), but alloys of the same weight as steels tend to be more fragile than steels, so alloys of the same robustness tend to be heavier. The OEM alloys I put on my old XM were the same size as the steels, but noticeably heavier - but they had a reputation for being undamageable.

"Alloy wheels", for road use, are normally aluminium alloy. For competition use, they can be magnesium alloy, which is even lighter but has serious drawbacks for road use.

davepoth

29,395 posts

230 months

Thursday 26th March 2015
quotequote all
cb010 said:
shake n bake said:
did you drive one after the other, without driving anything else? We're they both new/used?
Both were used (ex-rental) and about 9 months old. I drove both within the space of an hour. Both had the same tyres: 195/65 R15

Tyre pressures could have been different. I may not go for an ex-rental as some places are pricing ex-rentals at the same point as one private owner...
Given how I've been known to drive rental cars in the past, I'd be inclined to agree. The difference could well be down to knackered shocks on the steelie car, due to being driven over speed bumps at 40mph...

cb010

Original Poster:

76 posts

142 months

Thursday 26th March 2015
quotequote all
davepoth said:
Given how I've been known to drive rental cars in the past, I'd be inclined to agree. The difference could well be down to knackered shocks on the steelie car, due to being driven over speed bumps at 40mph...
I'm surprised rental firms haven't installed black boxes to monitor and charge drivers for aggressive driving. They are usually very good at fleecing customers!

Someone mentioned tyres - the salesman said that the OEM tyres (Kumho I believe) are a bit firmer than the ones customers usually choose as replacements.

Having done some more research this evening, I think I will give the ex-rental cars a miss.