Check engine light bulb scraped out
Check engine light bulb scraped out
Author
Discussion

mrnvh

Original Poster:

56 posts

156 months

Friday 27th March 2015
quotequote all
I bought a 10 year old fiesta 4 days ago from a garage as a daily hack for a new job. Condition wise it's right for the age; Exhaust needed fixing, couple of new tyres but runs well, steers well and has a stack of invoiced history. The previous MOT listed the engine light was on as an advisory but when I bought it, it wasn't on.

However I've only just noticed that the check engine light doesn't come on with the key like the other lights, and that the speedometer rests above zero when stopped which made me a bit suspicious; So I dismantled the cluster last night to find that it's already been opened before due to a bent clip, and the LED for the engine light has been crudely scraped or snapped out by something like a screwdriver.

I pulled the codes on an OBD reader but the only one I got was "P1000 OBD drive cycle incomplete" which suggests that either the battery has gone flat/been disconnected before, the codes have been cleared or its got a pending emissions fault, so i'll just have to wait and see on that one.

What should my next steps be with the garage? I feel as though I've been mislead but it might not be the garage's fault, the previous owner could have done it to get a "clean" part exchange in. At the very least I think I am being reasonable in expecting the garage to repair or replace the cluster and go from there, rather than dragging out the SOGA for something this old, but I am unsure?

TooMany2cvs

29,008 posts

157 months

Friday 27th March 2015
quotequote all
mrnvh said:
I bought a 10 year old fiesta 4 days ago from a garage as a daily hack for a new job. Condition wise it's right for the age
How much?

mrnvh said:
At the very least I think I am being reasonable in expecting the garage to repair or replace the cluster and go from there, rather than dragging out the SOGA for something this old, but I am unsure?
SOGA rights are tempered by "reasonable expectations" for the age/price/apparent condition. With that in mind, I'm not convinced that you'd have a case worth the time/hassle to follow up. Good customer service says they should stand by it. OTOH, if they're the kind of place that would "forget" to notice that the EML wasn't self-testing...

mrnvh

Original Poster:

56 posts

156 months

Friday 27th March 2015
quotequote all
TooMany2cvs said:
How much?
£1400

TooMany2cvs said:
SOGA rights are tempered by "reasonable expectations" for the age/price/apparent condition. With that in mind, I'm not convinced that you'd have a case worth the time/hassle to follow up. Good customer service says they should stand by it. OTOH, if they're the kind of place that would "forget" to notice that the EML wasn't self-testing...
I'm inclined to agree with you there, I don't actually think its a huge problem; just a bit underhanded if they have indeed done that instead of just saying "It threw a code for a lambda sensor" and priced it in. They had gone to the trouble of a new clutch, timing belt kit and handbrake mechanism before sale so it strikes me as odd that they wouldn't just fix whatever it was. But they may be the victims too and haven't noticed or like you said "forgotten". smile

At the very least I'll give them a ring as it costs nothing to ask.

Edit: Just rang, he seemed upset about it and has offered to repair it free of charge. Short thread!

Edited by mrnvh on Friday 27th March 08:42

HertsBiker

6,443 posts

302 months

Friday 27th March 2015
quotequote all
Isn't this an mot failure?

SuperPav

1,358 posts

156 months

Friday 27th March 2015
quotequote all
mrnvh said:
I'm inclined to agree with you there, I don't actually think its a huge problem; just a bit underhanded if they have indeed done that instead of just saying "It threw a code for a lambda sensor" and priced it in. They had gone to the trouble of a new clutch, timing belt kit and handbrake mechanism before sale so it strikes me as odd that they wouldn't just fix whatever it was. But they may be the victims too and haven't noticed or like you said "forgotten". smile

At the very least I'll give them a ring as it costs nothing to ask.

Edit: Just rang, he seemed upset about it and has offered to repair it free of charge. Short thread!

Edited by mrnvh on Friday 27th March 08:42
That's a very good outcome, wouldn't really have expected them to repair it if I'm honest, as it's a 10 year old Fiesta. Good dealer, clearly.


As for MOT, for the 1,000,000th time, no, an EML light on is not in itself an MOT failure.



HertsBiker

6,443 posts

302 months

Friday 27th March 2015
quotequote all
No self check is ok then? In that case why don't we all do this and save expensive repairs!

r11co

6,244 posts

261 months

Friday 27th March 2015
quotequote all
HertsBiker said:
Isn't this an mot failure?
mrnvh said:
The previous MOT listed the engine light was on as an advisory but when I bought it, it wasn't on.
1,000,001th time wink

Good outcome and a credit to the garage concerned. What is the betting they picked the car up at auction after previous owner 'WBAC'd after their 'quick fix' on the EML?

SuperPav

1,358 posts

156 months

Friday 27th March 2015
quotequote all
HertsBiker said:
No self check is ok then? In that case why don't we all do this and save expensive repairs!
Well if we're going by that logic... Because nobody's ever failed on an EML on, hence no need to do anything about it! biggrin

TooMany2cvs

29,008 posts

157 months

Friday 27th March 2015
quotequote all
mrnvh said:
At the very least I'll give them a ring as it costs nothing to ask.

Edit: Just rang, he seemed upset about it and has offered to repair it free of charge. Short thread!
<grin> Result.