Where do I stand on getting my money back
Where do I stand on getting my money back
Author
Discussion

jcs25

Original Poster:

19 posts

192 months

Friday 27th March 2015
quotequote all
Hi Guys, I was just after some thoughts and advice on where I stand.

I bought my car a E90 2005 325i BMW tourer 3 weeks ago from a garage. Within 24 hours there were issues with miss firing and stalling.

Took it back and the diagnostics read misfire on all 6 cylinders. They had a look said there was some moisture it ran fine got it back the following day. Then 4 days later the same problem happens again. Seems like a coil pack issues. Goes back again they replace all 6 coil packs. Then it keeps missing again when they run it the following day. So off it goes to a specialist who says its a common issues with solenoids to do with the vanos and needs an engine flush. Which they did. Got the car back and it has run fine for almost 3 weeks and 1000 miles then last night exactly the same problem has come back. Missfires on idle or stalls completely and will run ok at higher revs. Obviously will be calling them when they open to get it looked at again. Has a 12 week 3000 mile warranty. However am fed up with the whole issue and am tempted to ask for my money back. Am I covered for this under the sales and goods act? Any help appreciated. Should of kept my low mile R32.

Jasandjules

72,686 posts

260 months

Friday 27th March 2015
quotequote all
I would inform them they have one final chance to fix it completely. Any further issues you will reject the car completely.

andymc

7,627 posts

238 months

Friday 27th March 2015
quotequote all
jcs25 said:
Hi Guys, I was just after some thoughts and advice on where I stand.

I bought my car a E90 2005 325i BMW tourer 3 weeks ago from a garage. Within 24 hours there were issues with miss firing and stalling.

Took it back and the diagnostics read misfire on all 6 cylinders. They had a look said there was some moisture it ran fine got it back the following day. Then 4 days later the same problem happens again. Seems like a coil pack issues. Goes back again they replace all 6 coil packs. Then it keeps missing again when they run it the following day. So off it goes to a specialist who says its a common issues with solenoids to do with the vanos and needs an engine flush. Which they did. Got the car back and it has run fine for almost 3 weeks and 1000 miles then last night exactly the same problem has come back. Missfires on idle or stalls completely and will run ok at higher revs. Obviously will be calling them when they open to get it looked at again. Has a 12 week 3000 mile warranty. However am fed up with the whole issue and am tempted to ask for my money back. Am I covered for this under the sales and goods act? Any help appreciated. Should of kept my low mile R32.
Sounds like a compression test is needed, im trade and i would be refunding you and sending it to the auction as it sounds a fortune to fix

jcs25

Original Poster:

19 posts

192 months

Friday 27th March 2015
quotequote all
could it not just need another flush or the solenoids for the vanos replacing?

r11co

6,244 posts

261 months

Friday 27th March 2015
quotequote all
jcs25 said:
could it not just need another flush or the solenoids for the vanos replacing?
VANOS solenoid usually detectable as little more than a hesitiation around 1500 revs.

I have a 2005 E90 330i which had the similar symptoms within weeks of purchase. Turned out to be water ingress in the engine ECU which, despite being mounted in a plastic box, can end up sitting in a puddle of water because the recess the box sits in has no drainage holes and the box itself has a valve in the bottom which is supposed to let water out but not in, but doesn't work. A common problem with early E90s where the plenum drains have been disturbed or blocked with dirt/leaves.

About £2-3k to fix using dealer parts and programming. I managed to get a second hand ECU which I then sent off to be programmed with the contents of my wet one, all in for about £250 (including insured express courier which wasn't cheap).

Also vital that while all the gubbins are out you drill some holes in the recess!!