What is urban vs suburban when choosing fuel type?
What is urban vs suburban when choosing fuel type?
Author
Discussion

flooziefay

Original Poster:

4 posts

140 months

Saturday 28th March 2015
quotequote all
OK, there's more to it than the title, but it seems to be the one piece of information missing when trying to pick a new car!

If you're driving short journey's round town then obviously you're doing urban journeys & a petrol car is likely to be better but at what point does driving become suburban & so a diesel become recommended?

Would peak performance for a diesel be after a certain number of miles or length of time driving?

If someone spent an hour in the car doing 5 miles every day then would petrol still be better?
What if the daily commute was 20 miles & took 15 minutes?

Sorry I know it's a boring technical question...

Thanks

shake n bake

2,221 posts

238 months

Saturday 28th March 2015
quotequote all
Just buy a fking car you like the look of.

73mark

774 posts

158 months

Saturday 28th March 2015
quotequote all
shake n bake said:
Just buy a fking car you like the look of.
biggrin

A900ss

3,314 posts

183 months

Saturday 28th March 2015
quotequote all
shake n bake said:
Just buy a fking car you like the look of.
Sometimes this place does just need a 'like' button.

flooziefay

Original Poster:

4 posts

140 months

Saturday 28th March 2015
quotequote all
That's the problem, anything I like the look of doesn't suit my needs -4 wheels, small & space for a car seat & pram...
Most hatchbacks seem to have both diesel & petrol versions nowadays & as I'm too lazy to change cars any more frequently than 10 years, it's worth getting the engine type to suit my driving.

SidewaysSi

10,742 posts

265 months

Saturday 28th March 2015
quotequote all
Better in what way? Are you purely thinking fuel economy? I personally have no clue but if you want to save a few pennies, buying new is probably not a great idea.

Engine characteristics of a petrol and diesel are very different so perhaps test drive a few and buy what you like?

jamieduff1981

8,092 posts

171 months

Saturday 28th March 2015
quotequote all
I usually just ask myself "Which is best? The biggest petrol or the biggest petrol".

Then I buy the biggest petrol engine.

kambites

71,709 posts

252 months

Saturday 28th March 2015
quotequote all
It's more to do with trip length than driving location as such. Diesels tend to shine where most of their use is with the engine warm but struggle if the car is run mostly cold.

mph1977

12,467 posts

199 months

Saturday 28th March 2015
quotequote all
kambites said:
It's more to do with trip length than driving location as such. Diesels tend to shine where most of their use is with the engine warm but struggle if the car is run mostly cold.
especially once into the realms of EGR and DPF equipped engines

shake n bake

2,221 posts

238 months

Saturday 28th March 2015
quotequote all
People read way too much in to fuel economy figures these days.
Put simply, if you're doing 3 miles a day, buy a petrol. If you're chugging along a motorway for 20000 miles s year, buy a diesel. A half decent petrol like a Hyundai i20 will fetch 45mpg easily and will last forever.

flooziefay

Original Poster:

4 posts

140 months

Saturday 28th March 2015
quotequote all
mph1977 said:
kambites said:
It's more to do with trip length than driving location as such. Diesels tend to shine where most of their use is with the engine warm but struggle if the car is run mostly cold.
especially once into the realms of EGR and DPF equipped engines
That's what I can't find information about, trip length. What sort of trip length is better for a diesel? How long or how many miles does it take to warm up?
We've got the car for long journeys so I just need something small for my daily stuff which will be shortly huge amounts of motorway driving but come next year will just be local but local is about 10 miles of 40-60mph roads...
My instinct is diesel but on reading about DPF, I worry about wrecking the engine or whatever it is that gets damaged if you don't do the long distances.

I think I half want to know so I can pick something economical & ...ahem...eco-friendly-ish, half want something I can, in my little work, feel is more specific than yet another boring hatchback, & half just want to know cos I'm a numbers geek & need anything other than ounces of baby food to re-activate my brain.
Plus knowing which I want will halve the endless list of boring little cars on auto trader (& other used car places).

djdest

6,542 posts

209 months

Saturday 28th March 2015
quotequote all
If you want a diesel buy a diesel.
Stop worrying about the DPF scaremongers!
I own a 330d and mostly do short trips through the week but then do long distance for days out at the weekend.
As long as you give it a good drive (i.e. warmed up fully and stretch its legs) regularly you have NOTHING to worry about

TurboHatchback

4,240 posts

184 months

Saturday 28th March 2015
quotequote all
jamieduff1981 said:
I usually just ask myself "Which is best? The biggest petrol or the biggest petrol".

Then I buy the biggest petrol engine.
This is more or less my selection criteria yes.

aw51 121565

4,773 posts

264 months

Saturday 28th March 2015
quotequote all
djdest said:
If you want a diesel buy a diesel.
Stop worrying about the DPF scaremongers!
I own a 330d and mostly do short trips through the week [b]but then do long distance for days out at the weekend.
As long as you give it a good drive (i.e. warmed up fully and stretch its legs) regularly you have NOTHING to worry about[/b]
This yes - but if one lives in a city and never ventures out of the conurbation onto high speed roads for a regular reasonable-length run, then a diesel will clog its DPF and flash a warning light requesting a reasonable drive on a motorway "pretty soon" (or a 'forced DPF cleansing' at a dealer using manufacturer's hardware). Later, if a motorway drive is unavailable or not carried out, the light will stay on and the DPF probably need replacing (the dealer may be able to 'force clean' the DPF using manufacturer's hardware, but all bets are off as to this being successful by this stage).

As such, diesels are not the car for city dwellers who never get away from 20 & 30 limits frown . But said city dwellers are swayed by the "urban" and "suburban" fuel economy figures of diesels and buy 'em in preference to petrols hehe .

PS the "urban" and "suburban" fuel economy figures are derived from tests in a laboratory, in conjunction with minimising CO2 emissions - they bear little (at best) to no relevance to real life driving experience wink .