What 5k Mid-Size Diesel Estate?
What 5k Mid-Size Diesel Estate?
Author
Discussion

jdwoodbury

Original Poster:

1,372 posts

237 months

Monday 30th March 2015
quotequote all
Ok my Father-in-law is looking for an mid-size estate with the following criteria:

- Ideally 50mpg on a run
- Cruise and AC essential
- Good on the motorway (read comfortable)
- Decent reliability
- No more than 5-5.5k
- Pulls reasonably well

I enjoy the search for an any car but this once pulls out so many options I am little stumped, so far I have:

- Audi A4 Avant 2.0tdi (Not sure on the long term reliability of the VAG diesels)
- Passat Estate (same as above)
- Volvo V50
- Mercedes W203 C220 Cdi
- Honda Accord 2.2Cdti (bland?)
- Mondeo Estate 2.0Tdi (plenty about)

I have to say the C-Class is probably my favorite on that list, most are up on miles though and I have zero experience of them.
What am I missing?

anonymous-user

85 months

Monday 30th March 2015
quotequote all
Volvo V70 D5/2.4D.

The V50 is smaller than most of the other alternatives you mention, it's more of a Focus class estate. The D5/2.4D (same engine, just in different states of tune) is very robust and takes miles incredibly well as long as you stay on top of the maintenance. It tends to split intercoolers but it's far from unique in that and it's not a very expensive fix.

xuy

1,116 posts

185 months

Monday 30th March 2015
quotequote all
I had this decision to make a couple months ago.

I ended up with a S class Mercedes.

The dogs don't like it!

Beck on topic, a Volvo V70 D5

RizzoTheRat

29,148 posts

223 months

Monday 30th March 2015
quotequote all
If VAG's an option then he'll get a lot more Octavia or Superb for his money than he will A4 or Passat. As for engine reliability, in 100k miles the only problem I've had from my CR170 was down to poor workmanship at a local dealers.

RobM77

35,349 posts

265 months

Monday 30th March 2015
quotequote all
He doesn't say he wants something that drives well or that's a 'prestige' brand (as they say!), so as practical as the Mercedes is, they're a lot more expensive than the others new and also hold their value pretty well, so he might not get as much for his money. A quality item, but your £5k won't go anywhere near as far as with the others.

I had an Audi TDi estate for three months a few years ago and it was ok - nothing special and inferior to my E90 3 series in terms of noise cruising on the motorway, handling (no doubt about that at all!!) and engine flexibility (BMW has a very wide torque spread for a diesel, Audi was typical diesel with a very narrow torque band, it was all over in a flash), but I felt that the Audi was superior in terms of interior fit, finish and quality. You do pay a lot for them though for similar reasons to the Merc, so it's a lot to pay just for a nice looking interior.

For the Mondeo I've only driven older models, not the current one, but they were pretty dire (terrible gearchange, horrible handling, cheap and tacky fit and finish, reliability horror stories). However, very recent Fords have impressed me a lot more, so it may be worth a look. The esate version looks spacious too.

The two I haven't driven I actually hear the best things about: the Honda and the Volvo. Worth a look I guess. Honda especially have a great reputation for reliability and build quality.

The other options are:

A 3 series, but I'd probably discount for the same reason as the Merc, due to the age of car you'd get for the money, and the USP that you pay all that money for is the handling, so if he's not after handling he'll be paying for something he doesn't want. A good all round car though - very quiet at speed, good driving position, nice features etc. I love mine, but my main interest is handling, so that's not really relevant here. They're certainly one of the smaller estates too.

Octavia: I drove a brand new one of these in 2007 and the fit and finish were ok, but the ride and handling were dreadful and I couldn't wait to part with it. ETA in response to Kambites' comment below: It was a totally standard diesel one and I did about 300 miles in it. I've not tried the VRS, which may ride and handle a lot better, but surely that'll just do less to the gallon and he doesn't necessarily want the performance?

HTH in some small way!

Edited by RobM77 on Monday 30th March 15:05

kambites

71,709 posts

252 months

Monday 30th March 2015
quotequote all
Can you get a diesel Octavia VRS estate for £5k?

SilverSixer

8,202 posts

182 months

Monday 30th March 2015
quotequote all
New as you can find SAAB 9-5 I reckon. Lots of car for the money.

Fattyfat

3,310 posts

227 months

Monday 30th March 2015
quotequote all
I have a Highline spec B6 Passat with the later CR diesel engine. You'd get a good one for your budget

Spacious and reasonably well kitted out (AC, Heated leather, Cruise etc) and so far reliable. Usual VAG drive though but then do you need more in an estate?

Dan_1981

18,129 posts

230 months

Monday 30th March 2015
quotequote all
I bought an 08 9-3 Estate 1 months ago for £5750

1.9tdi

It returns 54mpg on the motorway

Heated leather

Bose stereo - thats very very good.

Cruise & AC.

I've done 70k in it in 18 months - replaced one front spring, two front tyres and had a couple of services.

Also ridiculously comfortable.

peterg1955

746 posts

195 months

Monday 30th March 2015
quotequote all
If loadspace is a priority, note that the Passat was (not sure if it still is) based on the Audi A6 florrpan rather than the A4 and consequently has a lot more room.

kambites

71,709 posts

252 months

Monday 30th March 2015
quotequote all
peterg1955 said:
If loadspace is a priority, note that the Passat was (not sure if it still is) based on the Audi A6 florrpan rather than the A4 and consequently has a lot more room.
The current Passat is MQB based. Same platform (although obviously not the same floorpan) as the Golf. The previous version was also transverse engined but I think based on its own floorpan? The version before that was longitudinal engined and Audi based; I think that went out of production in something like 2005? I must admit, I'd always assumed that version was based on the A4 platform rather than the A6 one.

Edited by kambites on Monday 30th March 15:12

ben5732

763 posts

187 months

Monday 30th March 2015
quotequote all
I'd avoid the passat the 05+ was an absolute lemon plagued with issues.
I'd go with the Volvo myself.

motor mad

474 posts

220 months

Monday 30th March 2015
quotequote all

I briefly owned an Audi Avant B7 2.0tdi. This information might be useful to you if looking at VAG cars with these specific engine codes.

http://www.audi-sport.net/xf/threads/2-0tdi-oil-pu...

ben5732

763 posts

187 months

Monday 30th March 2015
quotequote all
Same issues with the passat as above obviously.
Plus injector issues, handbrake motors braking every two years, door locks breaking, egr issues. Both my dad and a friend have one and both will never again.

jdwoodbury

Original Poster:

1,372 posts

237 months

Monday 30th March 2015
quotequote all
Thanks for the suggestions folks, I am liking the V70....I thought they would be too leggy but looking through the classifieds can get circa 2005 with just over 100k, so not too bad. I owned a V70 2.4 Petrol some time back, it was very comfortable indeed and a great load lugger.

Krikkit

27,943 posts

212 months

Monday 30th March 2015
quotequote all
Avoid the auto, they can be a bit sketchy if they haven't had their oil replaced. Other than that they're very reliable, although like all engines of this era they can suffer with injector problems.

jdwoodbury

Original Poster:

1,372 posts

237 months

Monday 30th March 2015
quotequote all
Krikkit said:
Avoid the auto, they can be a bit sketchy if they haven't had their oil replaced. Other than that they're very reliable, although like all engines of this era they can suffer with injector problems.
I had a 2001 V70 Auto actually, at 140k miles it started to thump into gear from rest, never had it looked at as it was px'd

ChasW

2,163 posts

233 months

Monday 30th March 2015
quotequote all
I'd go Audi 1.9Tdi

We had the saloon Quattro on a 53 plate. It's still going strong at 200k+ with the chap I sold it to at 70k. I had the turbo replaced at 60k and he has only done routine maintenance since.

pmanson

13,388 posts

284 months

Monday 30th March 2015
quotequote all
Mazda 6?

I've got a 2009 hatchback (2.2d 185bhp sport) that has just rolled over 102k (trade in will get me about £4k). Nice, comfy car (i do 25k p/year) but tyre noise is a little loud.

Seats fold completely flat so pretty practical.

I've got a heavy right foot and i'm averaging circa 45mpg