Golf dies then is resurrected! Then dies again. Any Thought?
Discussion
I know it's Easter but...
My partner has a 08 Golf Tdi (the 1.9 105hp) closing in on 100,000 miles.
She was driving to work yesterday when, at about 50mph, it went dead. Everything stopped, she coasted it to the side of the road (busy main road) but even when she put on the hazard warning lights they wouldn't work. Dash was out, everything was out. Tries to restart it, absolutely dead. It was exactly as though the battery had become completely disconnected.
So she calls the RAC. They turn up half an hour later, turn the key, car bursts into life! Works perfectly. She she sets off, RAC chap following her. A couple of minutes later, car dies again. RAC chap tries starting it, dead. Opens bonnet, checks all connections, nothing apparent wrong. Tries again, starts. Drives another couple of minutes - dies.
So by this time obviously it is a real problem, so he gets her to work and tows the car to a 'RAC Approved' garage. Where it now languishes as obviously it is a bank holiday weekend - unfortunate timing.
Anyway, hopefully next week they'll get to it but just wondered if anyone had any thoughts or ideas as to what's happened, or had even experienced anything similar?
My partner has a 08 Golf Tdi (the 1.9 105hp) closing in on 100,000 miles.
She was driving to work yesterday when, at about 50mph, it went dead. Everything stopped, she coasted it to the side of the road (busy main road) but even when she put on the hazard warning lights they wouldn't work. Dash was out, everything was out. Tries to restart it, absolutely dead. It was exactly as though the battery had become completely disconnected.
So she calls the RAC. They turn up half an hour later, turn the key, car bursts into life! Works perfectly. She she sets off, RAC chap following her. A couple of minutes later, car dies again. RAC chap tries starting it, dead. Opens bonnet, checks all connections, nothing apparent wrong. Tries again, starts. Drives another couple of minutes - dies.
So by this time obviously it is a real problem, so he gets her to work and tows the car to a 'RAC Approved' garage. Where it now languishes as obviously it is a bank holiday weekend - unfortunate timing.
Anyway, hopefully next week they'll get to it but just wondered if anyone had any thoughts or ideas as to what's happened, or had even experienced anything similar?
One of the horsey brids at work just bought an 05 reg MKV Golf and most of the electrics didn't work which meant the car didn't either. They have replaced "the main circuit board" (her words, not mine) and the car now works. In with the service history were bills for just about every electrical thing on the car. Were is me, alarms bells would have been ringing, but they probably wouldn't have worked.
Before she bought it, I suggested she look at a Japanese car.
Before she bought it, I suggested she look at a Japanese car.
Sounds exactly like a total electrical shut down, so I'd start looking at things that can do that;
- Loose battery connections or broken battery cables. The main +ve or earth cables may look OK, but the core may have fractured. Get a test lead on them, and give them a wiggle.
- Main fuse? Not sure if there is one on a Golf, but it may look OK, but be loose in it's holder, or damaged.
- Dodgy ignition switch. I had a Fiat Uno that I had to replace the main switch in the column on as it became so loose with age it could just jump from run to off when I went over speed bumps.
- Dodgy aftermarket alarm or immobiliser?
I'd start by connecting a jump lead directly from the battery earth terminal to a good earth point on the engine block & see if normal service is resumed.
Corroded earth leads - those with plastic sheathing are the worst as the cable can corrode to nothing under the plastic so whilst the ends look OK there's nothing in the middle - and their connecting points are a common issue & will give the symptoms you describe.
After that it's a case of checking all connections & wires - the wiggle test often finds internal breaks.
Corroded earth leads - those with plastic sheathing are the worst as the cable can corrode to nothing under the plastic so whilst the ends look OK there's nothing in the middle - and their connecting points are a common issue & will give the symptoms you describe.
After that it's a case of checking all connections & wires - the wiggle test often finds internal breaks.
The problem is that once the car springs back to life it all works perfectly again, which will make fault finding a nightmare.
I had a cell go on a battery once with exactly the same effect (car completely dead) although it was when it was parked. But once it was dead, it was dead - no springing back to full health again.
The car is completely stock by the way, and we've had it effectively from new, so I know it hasn't been fiddled with or had an aftermarket alarm.
It's also run perfectly for the 100,000 miles so far and still drives like new. In fact its been a fantastic car.
I had a cell go on a battery once with exactly the same effect (car completely dead) although it was when it was parked. But once it was dead, it was dead - no springing back to full health again.
The car is completely stock by the way, and we've had it effectively from new, so I know it hasn't been fiddled with or had an aftermarket alarm.
It's also run perfectly for the 100,000 miles so far and still drives like new. In fact its been a fantastic car.
Ari said:
The problem is that once the car springs back to life it all works perfectly again, which will make fault finding a nightmare.
Which is the point of the 'wiggle test'. With the engine running wiggle the wires. If/when the engine stops the wire you were wiggling is likely to be the fault.
Gassing Station | General Gassing | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



