2008 Civic VS 2007 Mini Cooper D
Discussion
I currently have a Cooper D and had a Civic in the past.
The Civic is a fair bit quicker, but will use a little bit more fuel. The build quality of the Mini is better - it really is a solid little thing.
I wasn't a fan of the gearbox in the Civic and I'm sure you're aware to look out for the chocolate clutches. Other than than that, reliability is on a par so far. Nothing much did or has gone wrong with either of them for me. Cant comment on higher mileage though - sold the Civic at 60k and the Mini is on 61k.
My Civic was a Type S, so it looked better and handled better than the 5 doors.
The Civic is a fair bit quicker, but will use a little bit more fuel. The build quality of the Mini is better - it really is a solid little thing.
I wasn't a fan of the gearbox in the Civic and I'm sure you're aware to look out for the chocolate clutches. Other than than that, reliability is on a par so far. Nothing much did or has gone wrong with either of them for me. Cant comment on higher mileage though - sold the Civic at 60k and the Mini is on 61k.
My Civic was a Type S, so it looked better and handled better than the 5 doors.
The clutches on the Civic are a well known weak point, as they can't handle the power. If you test drive one, give it the absolute beans in every gear to make sure it's not slipping. I noticed mine slipping on the day I drove it home from the dealer and thankfully it was replaced FOC, along with the Dual Mass Flywheel.
I would say the Mini is more fun, yes. But it's still a diesel, so it's never going to be the same as a Cooper S.
I would say the Mini is more fun, yes. But it's still a diesel, so it's never going to be the same as a Cooper S.
Gassing Station | General Gassing | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


